Hawaii cruise question

cgattis

DIS Veteran
Joined
Jan 1, 2009
Messages
5,508
Summer 2017 we are going to Hawaii!! Now, what are we going to do??!?! I'd like to see several islands but do not love the idea (or cost) of hopping around with 4 people. So I've been thinking about an inter-island cruise. I want our trip to end with four (ish) night at Aulani, for a fullday at Pearl Harbor and three days of just the resort.

Has anyone done an inter-island cruise? I know Disney is starting to offer some cruises to Hawaii, but I want the land portion too. They'll probably start offering that the year after we go...
 
Have you considered NCL? They are the only line that is allowed to cruise around all the islands without having to port in a foreign country. You may want to look at staying at Aulani and doing NCL before or afterward. NCL Pride of AMerica stops and starts on Oahu.
 
Yes, I'm finding all kinds of info on NCL, but those really don't get great reviews (probably from lack of competition). But I see mention that Holland America, RCCL, and others do "seasonal" inter-island, but in not having much luck in my research. Seems like the cruise lines all make it hard to just browse their sites--they don't have good overviews of itineraries/routes IMO. Plus most of the ones I'm finding in/out of Oahu seem to include Pearl Harbor, which I really wanted to do on my own time, but that's not a sticking point.
 
Summer 2017 we are going to Hawaii!! Now, what are we going to do??!?! I'd like to see several islands but do not love the idea (or cost) of hopping around with 4 people. So I've been thinking about an inter-island cruise. I want our trip to end with four (ish) night at Aulani, for a fullday at Pearl Harbor and three days of just the resort.

We did a combination Aulani and inter-island cruise in February of this year. We spent 7 days at Aulani followed by a 7-night island cruise on NCL's Pride of America. If I were doing it again I might reverse the order of the two. In the end we found that while we enjoyed seeing the other islands, it was Aulani that we loved the best.

This is going to sound terrible, but frankly once you've seen 2-3 of the islands they kind of blur together. I really don't mean that to sound bad, they really are all gorgeous, with lush scenery and beautiful beaches. I just don't know how many times you can shop at similar shops or visit similar beaches or marvel at similar mountainscapes. Again, yes we did enjoy the islands. I just wanted to temper your expectations.

As far as the ship goes, we've had better cruises. The level of crew interaction on board was spotty. Some crew were wonderful. Others were just there earning a paycheck. Dining on board was also a bit of a disappointment. We sailed in concierge suites (three different suites in our travel party) which gets you a very nice room and a personal "butler". An example of the un-evenness of the service was that our butler was fine (not exceptional but fine), one of the other butlers acted like he was being put out whenever asked to do something, while the third one went out of his way to please his passengers.

Our experience at Aulani was uniformly good. This was our second visit to Aulani, having spent 4-nights there in 2014 as well. The CM's there are all very well trained and genuinely friendly. We enjoyed just spending time enjoying the lush grounds but also made time to see the other parts of Oahu. Pearl Harbor is a must. We spent about 4-hours there, hitting it about 9 am. Before you go, hit their website and purchase your timed tickets for the Arizona memorial. Then plan your visit to get there at least an hour ahead of time so you can look at the exhibits before you get on the boat. We then spent a bit more time looking at the various artifacts before leaving. We did not do the tours of the various ships but you might be interested in that too.

Other things we did on Oahu were to go into Waikiki just for the "tourist" experience there and to eat in a couple of restaurants. One real surprise was the Pineapple Room by Alan Wong, which is found in a Macy's store of all places. We drove up to Diamond Head and then further along that stretch of coast taking in some beautiful sights. On another day we drove up to the North Shore, stopping at the Dole Plantation along the way just to shop for about a half-hour. Some folks like to take the tour at the Dole plantation, which will take longer. Once at the North Shore we pretty much just drove along the coast road and did stop at one of the multitude of shrimp trucks. Its kind of a must-do experience as is getting shaved ice. :)

Another day we drove over to Kailua for more shopping and site seeing. The drive over there is really spectacular as you go through a tunnel in the mountains and come out the other side. Beautiful scenery all around.
 

We did a combination Aulani and inter-island cruise in February of this year. We spent 7 days at Aulani followed by a 7-night island cruise on NCL's Pride of America. If I were doing it again I might reverse the order of the two. In the end we found that while we enjoyed seeing the other islands, it was Aulani that we loved the best.

This is going to sound terrible, but frankly once you've seen 2-3 of the islands they kind of blur together. I really don't mean that to sound bad, they really are all gorgeous, with lush scenery and beautiful beaches. I just don't know how many times you can shop at similar shops or visit similar beaches or marvel at similar mountainscapes. Again, yes we did enjoy the islands. I just wanted to temper your expectations.

As far as the ship goes, we've had better cruises. The level of crew interaction on board was spotty. Some crew were wonderful. Others were just there earning a paycheck. Dining on board was also a bit of a disappointment. We sailed in concierge suites (three different suites in our travel party) which gets you a very nice room and a personal "butler". An example of the un-evenness of the service was that our butler was fine (not exceptional but fine), one of the other butlers acted like he was being put out whenever asked to do something, while the third one went out of his way to please his passengers.

Our experience at Aulani was uniformly good. This was our second visit to Aulani, having spent 4-nights there in 2014 as well. The CM's there are all very well trained and genuinely friendly. We enjoyed just spending time enjoying the lush grounds but also made time to see the other parts of Oahu. Pearl Harbor is a must. We spent about 4-hours there, hitting it about 9 am. Before you go, hit their website and purchase your timed tickets for the Arizona memorial. Then plan your visit to get there at least an hour ahead of time so you can look at the exhibits before you get on the boat. We then spent a bit more time looking at the various artifacts before leaving. We did not do the tours of the various ships but you might be interested in that too.

Other things we did on Oahu were to go into Waikiki just for the "tourist" experience there and to eat in a couple of restaurants. One real surprise was the Pineapple Room by Alan Wong, which is found in a Macy's store of all places. We drove up to Diamond Head and then further along that stretch of coast taking in some beautiful sights. On another day we drove up to the North Shore, stopping at the Dole Plantation along the way just to shop for about a half-hour. Some folks like to take the tour at the Dole plantation, which will take longer. Once at the North Shore we pretty much just drove along the coast road and did stop at one of the multitude of shrimp trucks. Its kind of a must-do experience as is getting shaved ice. :)

Another day we drove over to Kailua for more shopping and site seeing. The drive over there is really spectacular as you go through a tunnel in the mountains and come out the other side. Beautiful scenery all around.
I definitely wanted to save Aulani for last, so that sounds good. Sounds like your cruise experience was about what I'd read, which is why I'm trying to look at other lines. Did you do shore excursions or just explore on your own? I really appreciate any input, as I'm really just in the research phase on this one! Thanks!!
 
Yes, I'm finding all kinds of info on NCL, but those really don't get great reviews (probably from lack of competition). But I see mention that Holland America, RCCL, and others do "seasonal" inter-island, but in not having much luck in my research. Seems like the cruise lines all make it hard to just browse their sites--they don't have good overviews of itineraries/routes IMO. Plus most of the ones I'm finding in/out of Oahu seem to include Pearl Harbor, which I really wanted to do on my own time, but that's not a sticking point.
As noted, NCL is the only major cruiseline that does inter-island cruises. Any cruises on other cruiselines are not Hawaii-specific, but may include Hawaii enroute to other locations (generally a requisitioning cruise). This is because of the Passenger Vessel Services Act. No foreign-flagged ship can transport passengers from one US port to a different US port (as in NOT a closed loop cruise) without a stop in a distant foreign port. The closest distant foreign port to Hawaii is about 2 days travel (each way). Even a closed-loop cruise (beginning and ending in the same US port) requires a foreign port stop. And there just aren't any that close to Hawaii. NCL is allowed to sail the Pride of America because she's US flagged.
 
As noted, NCL is the only major cruiseline that does inter-island cruises. Any cruises on other cruiselines are not Hawaii-specific, but may include Hawaii enroute to other locations (generally a requisitioning cruise). This is because of the Passenger Vessel Services Act. No foreign-flagged ship can transport passengers from one US port to a different US port (as in NOT a closed loop cruise) without a stop in a distant foreign port. The closest distant foreign port to Hawaii is about 2 days travel (each way). Even a closed-loop cruise (beginning and ending in the same US port) requires a foreign port stop. And there just aren't any that close to Hawaii. NCL is allowed to sail the Pride of America because she's US flagged.
But I read on Travel Channel (I think it was) that some of the other lines do seasonal inter-island. Is that not correct? Could it possibly be--something I read on the internet is not true??? *gasp* ;). Seriously, any idea?
 
Did you do shore excursions or just explore on your own?
We (a party of 5) explored on our own. In one port (Maui I think) we rented a car. In other ports we negotiated with the taxi van driver for a flat-rate x-hour tour of the island. We told the drivers we wanted to see "their Island", not just what the tourist spots were. Worked out well for us and splitting the cost between the 5 of us made it less expensive than the ship's tours.
 
But I read on Travel Channel (I think it was) that some of the other lines do seasonal inter-island. Is that not correct? Could it possibly be--something I read on the internet is not true??? *gasp* ;). Seriously, any idea?
What you probably saw referenced the cruises that occasionally sail from the west coast to Hawaii, such as DCL. The rule is that they have to port in a foreign country. So, some will start/end in Vancouver. The ones that start/end in California have a stop in Ensenada. DCL has done both of those types of cruises in the past.

I looked at Hawaiin cruises a few months ago. It seemed like most are starting or stopping in Vancouver. I also read mixed reviews for Pride of America, but I am open to trying that someday. The DCL cruises that go to Hawaii have a lot of sea days. I assume all the other lines will, too, since they have to stop in a foreign port.
 
But I read on Travel Channel (I think it was) that some of the other lines do seasonal inter-island. Is that not correct? Could it possibly be--something I read on the internet is not true??? *gasp* ;). Seriously, any idea?
As I said, only if it's part of a longer cruise. Legally that's all the major cruiselines can do if they cruise from a US port. Now, there may be some small ships (well, really larger yachts) that could do only inter-inland cruises that may be flagged in the US.
 
We went to Kiribati on our closed loop holland America cruise out of Oahu maybe 8 years ago. Holland America is fine; we had a great time. Kiribati was a waste of time though.
 
You may be finding outdated information about other cruise lines doing seasonal inter-island cruises. Before NCL was given the exception, other cruise lines were able to do this. But since the route is now served by a US flagged vessel (NCL's), no other non-US flagged vessels may do this route without complying with the PSVA. There also used to be inter-island ferry service but that was short-lived and ended in 2009 I think.
 
Summer 2017 we are going to Hawaii!! Now, what are we going to do??!?! I'd like to see several islands but do not love the idea (or cost) of hopping around with 4 people. So I've been thinking about an inter-island cruise. I want our trip to end with four (ish) night at Aulani, for a fullday at Pearl Harbor and three days of just the resort.

Has anyone done an inter-island cruise? I know Disney is starting to offer some cruises to Hawaii, but I want the land portion too. They'll probably start offering that the year after we go...
You did not mention what travel agent you use but I would suggest contacting Tracey Heinrichs of DreamsUnlimited Travel, she has been helping us for years and recently sailed the NCL Hawaii cruise! She would have the latest info and she even took the time to stop and meet me in Kona on her cruise!! Aloha, Karen
 
You may be finding outdated information about other cruise lines doing seasonal inter-island cruises. Before NCL was given the exception, other cruise lines were able to do this. But since the route is now served by a US flagged vessel (NCL's), no other non-US flagged vessels may do this route without complying with the PSVA. There also used to be inter-island ferry service but that was short-lived and ended in 2009 I think.

Ah, that could be! Thanks--it's been harder to find info than I expected, so help is appreciated!

You did not mention what travel agent you use but I would suggest contacting Tracey Heinrichs of DreamsUnlimited Travel, she has been helping us for years and recently sailed the NCL Hawaii cruise! She would have the latest info and she even took the time to stop and meet me in Kona on her cruise!! Aloha, Karen

Hmm, I figured I'd book it all myself, since I did our AK trip. But I should definitely check with Dreams--they might have some better ideas or have better (and first-hand!) info! Thanks for the idea--it actually hadn't even crossed my mind!!
 

GET UP TO A $1000 SHIPBOARD CREDIT AND AN EXCLUSIVE GIFT!

If you make your Disney Cruise Line reservation with Dreams Unlimited Travel you’ll receive these incredible shipboard credits to spend on your cruise!



















New Posts







DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top