We stayed at the CBR last May and it was beautiful! They just completed a major overhaul of all of the guest rooms fall of last year. They now have new beds, furniture, fixtures, paint, wallpaper, carpet, bedspreads, tubs and curtains. Also, they just finished this month with the renovation of Old Port Royale. It may be the oldest of the moderates, but at this point is looks like one of the newest.
As for convenience, request a building in Martinique (25 or 26), Trinidad North( 31-smoking or 32), Aruba (51-smoking or 52) or Jamaica (44 or 45).
The grounds were well maintained, the CM's were very nice and we wished we had been there longer to enjoy the boats and the pools.
Have a great time. It is likely that the naysayers haven't stayed there since it has be refurbished.