Has Karl Rov Committed Treason??? Newsweek and the CIA Leak

Status
Not open for further replies.
ThAnswr said:
Several questions:

1) Why the hell did Rove bring up Wilson's wife at all?

2) How many wives could Wilson have had at the time?

3) Didn 't the "nation's top cop" Alberto Gonzales do an investigation at the request of Bu$h and pronounced all was good and no one at the WH leaked anything"

4) Didn't Bu$h himself say he would fire the leaker without any caveats such as " but not if the leaker did not mention the name"?

5) Why do you think Rove gave Cooper permission to reveal the leaker?

Let me answer #5. Rove technically doesn't think he did anything wrong, and even if Bu$h tried to get rid of him on moral grounds (pardon me: hahahahahahaha...........broke myself up with that one), Rove knows where the Bu$h bodies are buried.

Guaranteed, the day after Bu$h sends Rove packing, the lead story on the front page of every newspaper in the country will be:

* Bu$h's Texas driving records (so far they've been scrubbed),

* Bu$h's National Guard service,

* Bu$h's drug/alcohol abuse,

* Bu$h's arrest records,

* and 1 or 2 other incidents/stories Larry Flynt claims he's uncovered but won't print because the women and doctors involved do not wish for their story to be made public.

And then there's poor Daddy Bush, who fired Rove in 1992 for leaking a phony story to Novack. He's probably sitting at home, shaking his head, and wondering what kind of a stupid ******* he raised.

I say let the games begin.


Larry Flynt has secret stories too. :rolleyes:

Another anti-President Bush rant with another laundry list of past allegations not even relevent to the topic. :sad2:

Let the games begin?? You're already playing judge, jury, and executioner. Why don't you play sheriff too. You, Leb, and the Professor can go get the cuffs and track him down.
 
JoeEpcotRocks said:
You, Leb, and the Professor can go get the cuffs and track him down.
Could be hazardous. We've already seen what happened to Mace Windu, Kip Fisto and others that went to arrest someone of Rove's moral "stature"
 
JoeEpcotRocks said:
Let the games begin?? You're already playing judge, jury, and executioner. Why don't you play sheriff too. You, Leb, and the Professor can go get the cuffs and track him down.
Could we make it into a reality series with Michael Moore directing?
 
JoeEpcotRocks said:
Larry Flynt has secret stories too. :rolleyes:

Another anti-President Bush rant with another laundry list of past allegations not even relevent to the topic. :sad2:

Let the games begin?? You're already playing judge, jury, and executioner. Why don't you play sheriff too. You, Leb, and the Professor can go get the cuffs and track him down.

I see the game's already beginning.
 
This is fun to read. I hope to catch the rerun on Cspan tonight. TRANSCRIPT: WHITE HOUSE GRILLED ON ROVE
QUESTION: Scott, can I ask you this: Did Karl Rove commit a crime?

MCCLELLAN: Again, David, this is a question relating to a ongoing investigation, and you have my response related to the investigation. And I don't think you should read anything into it other than: We're going to continue not to comment on it while it's ongoing.

QUESTION: Do you stand by your statement from the fall of 2003, when you were asked specifically about Karl and Elliot Abrams and Scooter Libby, and you said, "I've gone to each of those gentlemen, and they have told me they are not involved in this"?

QUESTION: Do you stand by that statement?

MCCLELLAN: And if you will recall, I said that, as part of helping the investigators move forward on the investigation, we're not going to get into commenting on it. That was something I stated back near that time as well.

QUESTION: Scott, this is ridiculous. The notion that you're going to stand before us, after having commented with that level of detail, and tell people watching this that somehow you've decided not to talk.

You've got a public record out there. Do you stand by your remarks from that podium or not?

MCCLELLAN: I'm well aware, like you, of what was previously said. And I will be glad to talk about it at the appropriate time. The appropriate time is when the investigation...

QUESTION: (inaudible) when it's appropriate and when it's inappropriate?

MCCLELLAN: If you'll let me finish.

QUESTION: No, you're not finishing. You're not saying anything.

You stood at that podium and said that Karl Rove was not involved. And now we find out that he spoke about Joseph Wilson's wife. So don't you owe the American public a fuller explanation. Was he involved or was he not? Because contrary to what you told the American people, he did indeed talk about his wife, didn't he?

MCCLELLAN: There will be a time to talk about this, but now is not the time to talk about it.

QUESTION: Do you think people will accept that, what you're saying today?

MCCLELLAN: Again, I've responded to the question.

QUESTION: You're in a bad spot here, Scott...

(LAUGHTER)

... because after the investigation began -- after the criminal investigation was under way -- you said, October 10th, 2003, "I spoke with those individuals, Rove, Abrams and Libby. As I pointed out, those individuals assured me they were not involved in this," from that podium. That's after the criminal investigation began.

Now that Rove has essentially been caught red-handed peddling this information, all of a sudden you have respect for the sanctity of the criminal investigation.

MCCLELLAN: No, that's not a correct characterization. And I think you are well aware of that.

We know each other very well. And it was after that period that the investigators had requested that we not get into commenting on an ongoing criminal investigation.

And we want to be helpful so that they can get to the bottom of this. Because no one wants to get to the bottom of it more than the president of the United States.

I am well aware of what was said previously. I remember well what was said previously. And at some point I look forward to talking about it. But until the investigation is complete, I'm just not going to do that.

QUESTION: So you're now saying that after you cleared Rove and the others from that podium, then the prosecutors asked you not to speak anymore and since then you haven't.

MCCLELLAN: Again, you're continuing to ask questions relating to an ongoing criminal investigation and I'm just not going to respond to them. QUESTION: When did they ask you to stop commenting on it, Scott? Can you pin down a date?

MCCLELLAN: Back in that time period.

QUESTION: Well, then the president commented on it nine months later. So was he not following the White House plan?

MCCLELLAN: I appreciate your questions. You can keep asking them, but you have my response.

QUESTION: Well, we are going to keep asking them.

When did the president learn that Karl Rove had had a conversation with a news reporter about the involvement of Joseph Wilson's wife in the decision to send him to Africa?

MCCLELLAN: I've responded to the questions.

QUESTION: When did the president learn that Karl Rove had been...

MCCLELLAN: I've responded to your questions.

QUESTION: After the investigation is completed, will you then be consistent with your word and the president's word that anybody who was involved will be let go?

MCCLELLAN: Again, after the investigation is complete, I will be glad to talk about it at that point.

QUESTION: Can you walk us through why, given the fact that Rove's lawyer has spoken publicly about this, it is inconsistent with the investigation, that it compromises the investigation to talk about the involvement of Karl Rove, the deputy chief of staff, here?

MCCLELLAN: Well, those overseeing the investigation expressed a preference to us that we not get into commenting on the investigation while it's ongoing. And that was what they requested of the White House. And so I think in order to be helpful to that investigation, we are following their direction. ...

QUESTION: Does the president continue to have confidence in Mr. Rove?

MCCLELLAN: Again, these are all questions coming up in the context of an ongoing criminal investigation. And you've heard my response on this.

QUESTION: So you're not going to respond as to whether or not the president has confidence in his deputy chief of staff?

MCCLELLAN: You're asking this question in the context of an ongoing investigation, and I would not read anything into it other then I'm simply going to comment on an ongoing investigation.

QUESTION: Has there been any change, or is there a plan for Mr. Rove's portfolio to be altered in any way?

MCCLELLAN: Again, you have my response to these questions.
I would feel sorry for Scotty if I thought that he was innocent in this affair. Rove leaked the name of a CIA agent. The fact that he did not name her by name and social security number is not a defense.

Rove needs to be fired or have his security clearance revoked.
 
What the Heck said:
Surely, you gest.

Edited to add: "Gest? What the heck is a gest? It's jest".

Don't call me Shirley.

Honestly, that has to be one of the funniest movies of all time. Every bad cliche, every bad plot, and every bad acting job is in that movie. And it works.

One of my favorites: "I picked a bad week to give up amphetamines".
 
Anyone else noticed that the Professor is always the one to bring threads back on topic?



Rich::
 
well its clear he gave her name and should nothave
it was wrong
if a regualr person did this they would get fired
i dont understand how he knew this
should he have?
and you would think bush knew he leaked her name
the whole thing is a mess
i guess my point is he did something wrong and should have to pay for his actions
 
What the Heck said:
Oh yes, such reliable sources like Michael Moore, the same Michael Moore who accused the White House of removing a certain Major's name from President Bush's records for personal reasons in F 9/11. Of course the fact that HIPPA laws made it illegal in 2004 for those records to be released with someone elses name (and not in 2000 when Moore got the original one) had absolutely nothing to do with it. I started to watch F 9/11 last night for the first time, but after the first 15 minutes, I started looking around for a better piece of fiction and found Harry Potter on the Family Channel.


If you had actually taken the time to read the article, you'd know that Moore is not cited as a "source" in the Plame affair, but rather as a neo-con whipping boy, which you have so adequately illustrated by your vitriol.
 
dcentity2000 said:
Anyone else noticed that the Professor is always the one to bring threads back on topic?
Rich::
Thanks. In that same spirit, Senator Lautenberg and a watchdog group, Citizens for Ethics and Responsibility in Washington (CREW), have both come out calling for Rove's security clearance to be suspended pending completion of this investigation. Lautenberg to Bush: Nix Rove's security clearance
“Karl Rove has accused liberals of not understanding the consequences of 9-11, but he’s the one who blew the cover of a covert CIA agent. The President should immediately suspend Karl Rove’s security clearances and shut him down by shutting him out of classified meetings or discussions.

The excuses offered by Karl Rove’s lawyer don’t pass the laugh test. Naming someone’s spouse is the same as naming them. And as a 31-year veteran of politics, Karl Rove should know that if you want to keep a secret, you don’t tell a reporter.”
Here is the press release from CREW. CREW Asks President Bush to Suspend Rove Security Clearance Pending Outcome of Plame Investigation; Letter Sent to Bush Today
WASHINGTON, July 11 /U.S. Newswire/ -- Citizens for Ethics and Responsibility in Washington (CREW) sent a letter today to President George Bush requesting that he immediately direct Karl Rove's security clearances be suspended pending the outcome of the government's investigation into the leak of Valerie Plame's identity as an undercover agent for the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA).

As reported today in Newsweek, Karl Rove was a confidential source for Time magazine reporter Matt Cooper on the identification of a covert CIA agent. Rove disclosed that Ambassador Joseph Wilson's trip to Iraq to investigate charges that Iraq was trying to buy uranium from Niger was authorized by Mr. Wilson's wife, a CIA employee working on issues related to weapons of mass destruction. At that time, Valerie Plame, Ambassador Wilson's wife, was a covert operative with the CIA whose identity as such had not yet been publicly revealed.

Under federal law, it is a crime to "intentionally disclose () any information identifying" a covert agent “to any individual not authorized to received classified information." 50 U.S.C. (Section) 421(a). Thus, by disclosing to Matt Cooper Ms. Plame's relationship with the CIA and thereby identifying her as a covert agent, Mr. Rove appears to have committed an illegal act.

"Considering that it is a federal crime to identify covert agents, and that President Bush signed executive orders identifying the vital role the President plays in protecting national security secrets from unauthorized disclosure, it is appropriate for the President to suspend Mr. Rove's clearance pending the investigation's outcome," Melanie Sloan, executive director of CREW, said today.

"The evidence uncovered so far raises serious questions about Mr. Rove's conduct and his ability to safeguard highly sensitive classified information. Until those questions are resolved, CREW believes it is not appropriate for Mr. Rove to have continued access to classified information. Anything short of suspension raises an unacceptable risk to our nation's security," Sloan wrote to the President today.
Can anyone justify Karl Rove's security clearnance not being revoked given the reports. Rove's own attorney has admitted that Rove leaked the idenity of a CIA agent.
 
To proclaim that any American, much less one who is working in the White House is more of an enemy to the United States than bin laden - where does he get off saying that?

Where does he get off saying that? Rall clearly answers your query:


"As far as we know, no one on what passes for the "left" (which would be the center-right anywhere else) has betrayed the United States in the GWOT. No anti-Bush progressive has made common cause with Al Qaeda, Hamas, the Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan or any other officially designated "terrorist" group. No American liberal has handed over classified information or worked to undermine the CIA.

But it now appears that Karl Rove, GOP golden boy, has done exactly that."

It's a very short trip from Rove to Cheney and just a stone's throw to Bu$h.

The neo-con's have a lot to worry about.
 
Lebjwb said:
If you had actually taken the time to read the article, you'd know that Moore is not cited as a "source" in the Plame affair, but rather as a neo-con whipping boy, which you have so adequately illustrated by your vitriol.
Your author was putting himself in the same class as Moore, a "neo-con whipping boy". I was pointing out that your source has the same kind of credibility as Moore (none). When he (Moore) claims he knows why something is done, without any mention of a major law that was passed that affected banks, other financial institutions, government agencies of all sizes, all medical facilities, one that everyone in the country has received at least 3 pieces of mail about (unless they don't have a doctor, don't have a credit card of any kind, and don't have any kind of bank account), wow, he is just such a martyr. And I have some land I would like to sell you, with a great view of the Atlantic - about 5 miles east of Cocoa Beach. Give you a great price.
 
Watch the WH start to distance themselves from Rove. They've already clammed up.

Miller is hiding a different source otherwise she'd be at the beach today....Libby?
 
Lebjwb said:
Where does he get off saying that? Rall clearly answers your query:




It's a very short trip from Rove to Cheney and just a stone's throw to Bu$h.

The neo-con's have a lot to worry about.
Yet they keep winning elections. I wonder why? Could it be that the people really aren't as stupid as your mouthpiece believes? Could it be that the people get pissed when they are asked to swallow such garbage? Could it be that the far left is wrong?

It was talk like this that was supposed to guarantee a new Congress in 2002. And in 2004. And in 2006. And it is talk that this that guarantees Congress will be Republican. Until the left comes back into reality and quits making comments that are outrageous, they will not come back into power, nor will them come close. Just ask Governor McBride - you know, the one in Florida that the Democratic National Committee guaranteed would defeat Jeb Bush, because they spent so much money in the state - and just as much garbage. So, call you names all you wish. Proof is in the pudding as they say.
 
Professor Mouse said:
This is fun to read. I hope to catch the rerun on Cspan tonight. TRANSCRIPT: WHITE HOUSE GRILLED ON ROVE I would feel sorry for Scotty if I thought that he was innocent in this affair. Rove leaked the name of a CIA agent. The fact that he did not name her by name and social security number is not a defense.

Rove needs to be fired or have his security clearance revoked.
Wow, I have seen the error of my ways. An investigation into the White House that the White House wants to wait before they comment until after the investigation is over. Haven't seen anything like it since the Clinton White House. :rolleyes:
 
What the Heck said:
Your author was putting himself in the same class as Moore, a "neo-con whipping boy". I was pointing out that your source has the same kind of credibility as Moore (none). When he (Moore) claims he knows why something is done, without any mention of a major law that was passed that affected banks, other financial institutions, government agencies of all sizes, all medical facilities, one that everyone in the country has received at least 3 pieces of mail about (unless they don't have a doctor, don't have a credit card of any kind, and don't have any kind of bank account), wow, he is just such a martyr. And I have some land I would like to sell you, with a great view of the Atlantic - about 5 miles east of Cocoa Beach. Give you a great price.

Looks like Rall knows what buttons to push.

Don't you agree that Rove's security clearance be revoked until the investigation has run it's course?

Aren't you concerened that the presidents top advisor could possibly face charges of treason?

As a patriotic American aren't you mortified that the President is allowing a person so accused access to top secret documents thus putting our country at increased risk during a time of war?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom