Hi LtHouse...congratulations!
My honey and I are getting married right before our cruise on January 4. We looked into several options.
Getting married on the cruise did not appeal to us for several reasons. First of all, price! Second of all, the wedding is not until Friday, the day before the cruise ends...we wanted to get married closer to the beginning.
We looked into the islands. There are many choices here at each of the stops, from a simple court house wedding to a full hurrah. We decided against this because I was very nervous about not getting into an island due to bad weather or what not. Didn't want to come home still single, after all.
The end result for us was to get married Saturday morning right in Port Canaveral, then to board the cruise and enjoy our honeymoon. What a wonderful way to spend our wedding night...first night on the cruise!
Good luck, and let us know what you decide!