I used Tickets Now once four years ago for Broadway show tickets. It was a lifesaver for me on a trip to NYC where I had messed up and had booked two shows for the same night by mistake and only realized that less than 48 hours before the shows.
Here was my experience.
I woke up in the middle of the night 3 a.m. and decided to pull timed tickets, theatre print at home stuff we’d need for the next day before going back to bed, and OMG I saw that I messed up in my planning and instead of having
Book of Mormon tickets for Jan. 2nd realized I had tickets for Jan. 3rd, the same day I also had tickets for Sweeny Todd.
I saw that Book of Mormon only had resale tickets listed on Ticketmaster for January 3rd, so didn’t know what chance I’d have to sell mine last minute before the show but decided to try. I went through the steps on Ticketmaster to sell, but nothing went through. I did a live chat with a Ticketmaster representative and found out that this option is often cut off 24 to 48 hours before a show – oh well.
But I knew there were other resale outlets, so I tried Tickets Now and put them up for sale there and that worked. I paid $169 originally and the lowest I could put these up for was $195 for me (they tell me it’s a Ticketmaster policy and I can’t list for any less – Ticketmaster it seems doesn’t want to let resellers undercut them), so I do that. Tickets Now then listed the tickets for $230 to get their cut with Tickets Now fees.
I wasn't sure how that was going to work out for me, as I even saw four other tickets out there for at little cheaper prices than mine for the same show on their site, but they were side orchestra not dead center orchestra like mine. Anyway, I went to sleep and got up at 9:30. I checked my email and to my surprise and delight my tickets sold at 8:04 a.m.
All in all, I felt really good about being able to get my money back plus extra so last minute. The whole process was pretty darn easy and something I was able to do pretty seamlessly as a panicky person in the middle of the night.
I think I was fortunate that my tickets were for a popular sold out show and that I had some pretty desirable seats. I still haven't seen Book of Mormon though. I'm waiting for a traveling show of this to come to my home town.