Did you guys just wing it touring the island, or did you get a tour guide? I go on the cruisecritics forum and notice a lot of people pay for a tour guide to show them the island, which I was thinking of doing.
Husband and I cruised to Bermuda last year...we were lucky enough to sail during the last season Holland America had regular weekly calls there, since their ship was small enough to dock right in Hamilton. All ships currently sailing there tie up at the Dock Yard/King's Wharf on the far western tip of the island. You just have to plan a little extra time into your transportation from there as it is not a central location.
We did not take any organized tours or even hire a Blue Flag cab driver as a 'tour guide'. We found it incredibly easy to do everything on our own with nothing more than a 3-day bus/ferry pass ($28 each for unlimited trips on the bus and ferry) and a $12 Fodor guide to the island.
During our 3.5 days docked in Hamilton, we did the following:
* Horseshoe Bay Beach
* Gibbs Hill Lighthouse ($5 each to climb to the top...awesome views!!)
* Extensive touring in St. George using Fodor Guide as our assistant
* Toured Ft. St. Catherine (walked there from St. George)
* Visit/late lunch at Tobacco Bay Beach overlooking the water (walked there from the Fort)
* Hamilton Harbor Night Festival
* Crystal Caves (toured both caves)
* Visit to the original Swizzle Inn for rum swizzles
* Shopping along Front Street in Hamilton
There is SO much to see in Bermuda; many things we did not get to but that just gives us a good reason to go back.
We didn't miss at all not having a 'tour guide' and really enjoyed being able to take things at our own pace. We visited in early May when the temperatures were absolutely perfect for walking all over without overheating.
I would cruise there again in a heartbeat; I only hope that someday HAL will return with one of their smaller ships to dock in Hamilton again. IMO that is superior to being at the Dockyard just for transportation convenience.