Grand Californian Direct sales promotion

For us owners and these new soon to be owners it's a hard one. While I love that my home resort is still selling at a premium and retaining its value and that we just saw an influx of cash, I also dont love that they could see this as a we can get away with not keeping it up and people will still buy.

@Sandisw do you know when they buy back points and resell them how that cash is distributed within the overall budget?

DVD is the sales arm of DVC so it has no impact on the budget for operation of the resort or funding of DVC. So, any sales of points at any of the resorts counts as part of DVD's profit/loss statements.

In terms of refurbs? We hire DVC to manage that aspect of the program...which again, isn't related to the developer at all. The board has already recognized that things need to be fixed with the refurb at VGC.

Is this the info you wanted?

Basically, DVC promoting and selling VGC right now will have no impact on the budgets for DVC.
 
Last edited:
DVD is the sales arm of DVC so it has no impact on the budget for operation of the resort or funding of DVC. So, any sales of points at any of the resorts counts as part of DVD's profit/loss statements.

In terms of refurbs? We hire DVC to manage that aspect of the program...which again, isn't related to the developer at all. The board has already recognized that things need to be fixed with the refurb at VGC.

Is this the info you wanted?
yes thanks. Part of me was thinking maybe this goes into our budget and they could use it for a proper refurb .
 
Then when you realize you could get 50 points at VDH for $4000 cheaper, it kind of squashes any desire to buy VGC.

That's true but what I care about most is that I'd lose just 15%-20% relative to current resale values with VGC, and I'd lose more (probably both percentage-wise and $/pt-wise) on VDH if I sold it a couple of years down the road for some reason.
 
That's true but what I care about most is that I'd lose just 15%-20% relative to current resale values with VGC, and I'd lose more (probably both percentage-wise and $/pt-wise) on VDH if I sold it a couple of years down the road for some reason.
If I take into account the stays I have done with my points and the value I got by using a credit card to buy I come out way ahead if I sell my VDH now. YMMV.
 
I think I'm the only person who doesn't really think about future resale value when I've bought contracts. It's neither here nor there to me as I have no control over the market. And I don't know when I'll want to see anything. If we stay healthy, I hope to have these contracts for at least a couple decades (well, BRV we will likely ride out to the end.) And who knows what their value will be when I'm an old lady? So I don't even think about that.

But I wouldn't purchase at all if I thought selling within a few years was a possibility. (It only would be if something catastrophic happens in our lives and I don't like to think that way.)
 
I think I'm the only person who doesn't really think about future resale value when I've bought contracts. It's neither here nor there to me as I have no control over the market. And I don't know when I'll want to see anything. If we stay healthy, I hope to have these contracts for at least a couple decades (well, BRV we will likely ride out to the end.) And who knows what their value will be when I'm an old lady? So I don't even think about that.

But I wouldn't purchase at all if I thought selling within a few years was a possibility. (It only would be if something catastrophic happens in our lives and I don't like to think that way.)
Having flexible points is a fantastic thing. It’s also really nice getting discounts on food/merch, etc.

Remember to download your DVC-Y card to your iOS device for when you go into the member lounge in June!

(No throwing chips down to the resale only members on the ground floor…. it frowned upon my management…) 😂
 
I think I'm the only person who doesn't really think about future resale value when I've bought contracts. It's neither here nor there to me as I have no control over the market. And I don't know when I'll want to see anything. If we stay healthy, I hope to have these contracts for at least a couple decades (well, BRV we will likely ride out to the end.) And who knows what their value will be when I'm an old lady? So I don't even think about that.

But I wouldn't purchase at all if I thought selling within a few years was a possibility. (It only would be if something catastrophic happens in our lives and I don't like to think that way.)
You're not the only one. I have spent maximum dollars on my points, and haven't spent a moment thinking about their resale value.
 
You're not the only one. I have spent maximum dollars on my points, and haven't spent a moment thinking about their resale value.
i’ll bring up the story of mine of a friend who bought 150 points at Riviera, Aulani and Disneyland hotel and then proceeded to get downsized from his job and have to take a job where he was making significantly less. All three of those resorts took massive depreciation hits.

So there is a difference between people who are buying when they’re already at or near retirement and have accumulated significant assets versus people who are young with a family and are buying with the expectation that their income will continue at its current level.
 
i’ll bring up the story of mine of a friend who bought 150 points at Riviera, Aulani and Disneyland hotel and then proceeded to get downsized from his job and have to take a job where he was making significantly less. All three of those resorts took massive depreciation hits.

So there is a difference between people who are buying when they’re already at or near retirement and have accumulated significant assets versus people who are young with a family and are buying with the expectation that their income will continue at its current level.
yeah, sometimes bad things happen while you're busy making plans.

Definitely the safest is to always buy resale at the lowest possible price. The opposite of what I did IOW.
 
And a “Vacant Tub” too.
Better than “occupied tub”!
Definitely the safest is to always buy resale at the lowest possible price. The opposite of what I did IOW.
I mean *safest* is probably not buying at all and shoving everything in a globally diversified basket of assets that appreciate…but yeah, resale is less likely to take a huge loss in case of near-term emergency. I think @AstroBlasters point is that, in an uncertain world, people with millions in assets that throw off predicable income probably shouldn’t worry much about resale value, families with a single earner who’s career is in a precarious industry (without massive retirement savings) probably should keep “worst case scenarios” in mind before plunking down 50k on a timeshare. And if it’s not Astro’s point then I’ll adopt it as my own.
 
Last edited:
i’ll bring up the story of mine of a friend who bought 150 points at Riviera, Aulani and Disneyland hotel and then proceeded to get downsized from his job and have to take a job where he was making significantly less. All three of those resorts took massive depreciation hits.

So there is a difference between people who are buying when they’re already at or near retirement and have accumulated significant assets versus people who are young with a family and are buying with the expectation that their income will continue at its current level.

I dont think we are really in latter of being super financially secure where if jobs were lost we would keep DVC. I can say for me (I know not all are on board with my methods) I only bought VDH with its restricted resale knowing that with what I paid I could come ahead or at minimum break even. So I did everything I could to lessen my costs upfront and also to improve my chance of a higher selling price should I need to sell by splitting my contracts/FW. I thought about resale value alot prior to buying both direct and resale. While nothing is guaranteed and the economy could take a crap, I did what I could upfront. If I had to pay straight cash like I had to do with resale, direct would have been a no deal option for me, the savings I got by using credit cards (paid in full at billing) negated any loss I took when driving my contract off the lot when paired with my stays at the hotel.

I will add to this, I would come out more ahead selling my VDH than I would my VGC I bought resale. Although for most people VGC isnt a fair comparison given its high price tag even on resale.
 
Having flexible points is a fantastic thing. It’s also really nice getting discounts on food/merch, etc.

Remember to download your DVC-Y card to your iOS device for when you go into the member lounge in June!

(No throwing chips down to the resale only members on the ground floor…. it frowned upon my management…) 😂

Yep! My husband already pulled up the DVC-Y card on his phone and showed it to me. I need to find it on mine.

I remember a couple years ago, someone here said they would throw cheez-its down to me from the lounge. Was that you? I can't remember who it was. 🤣

i’ll bring up the story of mine of a friend who bought 150 points at Riviera, Aulani and Disneyland hotel and then proceeded to get downsized from his job and have to take a job where he was making significantly less. All three of those resorts took massive depreciation hits.

So there is a difference between people who are buying when they’re already at or near retirement and have accumulated significant assets versus people who are young with a family and are buying with the expectation that their income will continue at its current level.

My husband was laid off from his job back in 2016. It was definitely scary. And we always know that's a real possibility because you just never know what can happen with a job. We wouldn't need to sell off our DVC right away, thankfully. But those contracts would definitely be the first things we'd ditch if we took a big financial hit.

We know we will be selling our VDH someday when we're old, at the very least though. And probably VGC too. And if we make almost nothing at that time, oh well. That's life.

I'm just hoping we all stay healthy enough to keep taking Disney trips.
 
Yep! My husband already pulled up the DVC-Y card on his phone and showed it to me. I need to find it on mine.

I remember a couple years ago, someone here said they would throw cheez-its down to me from the lounge. Was that you? I can't remember who it was. 🤣



My husband was laid off from his job back in 2016. It was definitely scary. And we always know that's a real possibility because you just never know what can happen with a job. We wouldn't need to sell off our DVC right away, thankfully. But those contracts would definitely be the first things we'd ditch if we took a big financial hit.

We know we will be selling our VDH someday when we're old, at the very least though. And probably VGC too. And if we make almost nothing at that time, oh well. That's life.

I'm just hoping we all stay healthy enough to keep taking Disney trips.
I believe it was you who ASKED for someone to throw you cheez-its down from the lounge!

Not that you have that Y next to your DVC you have moved up the FOMO ladder to the DVC-BY 😂
 
Yeah....and if you're like me and would need 150 direct for benefits...the price difference really is nuts.

150 points at VDH with incentives and using MB = $28,300 (plus closing costs)
150 points at VGC with no incentives/MB = $49,500 (plus closing costs)

An extra $21,200? No thanks. Sure, you don't have the extra TOT at check-out but still....that's a massive difference in up front cost.

I think direct VGC only makes sense for smaller add-ons.



True. Though maybe the people who are contemplating ditching off site would buy direct without realizing there's a resale market out there. I remember after our first state at the Grand Cal, immediately going onto the DVC site to see if I could purchase VGC. Thankfully, I came here and was able to learn about resale! (Though I don't think they had and direct points at the time anyway.)



We haven't stayed there but it was on our list of places to maybe try (before DVC). They had a big renovation (which took forever and they closed the whole place down to do it.) I like these little "boutique" type motels though so it's right up my alley. I, of course, wouldn't choose it over VGC though.
First time I went back to DLR in a decade or so I thought Candy Cane was gone. lol


If I owned VDH I would have a DGC loaded up with my ToT way before my trip, and not give it a second thought.
Excellent idea!!

Done! I actually pay at check IN so none of that I had to pay at checkout nonsense
With a gift card, FTW.!!


Having flexible points is a fantastic thing. It’s also really nice getting discounts on food/merch, etc.

Remember to download your DVC-Y card to your iOS device for when you go into the member lounge in June!

(No throwing chips down to the resale only members on the ground floor…. it frowned upon my management…) 😂
All last week, I only had to open the app and go to my profile, no one ever asked for anything more for discount.


Better than “occupied tub”!

I mean *safest* is probably not buying at all and shoving everything in a globally diversified basket of assets that appreciate…but yeah, resale is less likely to take a huge loss in case of near-term emergency. I think @AstroBlasters point is that, in an uncertain world, people with millions in assets that throw off predicable income probably shouldn’t worry much about resale value, families with a single earner who’s career is in a precarious industry (without massive retirement savings) probably shouldn’t keep “worst case scenarios” in mind before plunking down 50k on a timeshare. And if it’s not Astro’s point then I’ll adopt it as my own.
Thats me, I’m that guy. lol
 
So there is a difference between people who are buying when they’re already at or near retirement and have accumulated significant assets versus people who are young with a family and are buying with the expectation that their income will continue at its current level.
True that. And honestly? I think this is an important observation that we'd do well to keep in mind as we counsel others.

I always assume my salvage value is going to be zero when I consider a discretionary/leisure purchase. That way, I can never be unpleasantly surprised. Partly as a consequence, I did put off buying DVC until later in life--I'm still a good 10 years away from retirement, so I'm not there quite yet, but close.

My advice has pretty much always been: Owning DVC is far (far!) from necessary to take aweseome vaations regularly. Likewise, owning DVC is not necessary for regular, awesome vacations at WDW. Heck, owning isn't even necessary for regular stays in DVC villas at a very attractive price. It's a convenience, and nothing more.

However, once you've been marinating in the DVC boards for a while, it's pretty easy to conclude that you can't possibly have a half-decent Disney vacation without being a member. But it is not true. Not even close. There is a much longer and larger discussion to have around our consumerist culture, but this is the wrong place to have it.

Now, if someone happens to have $30-40K laying around that they genuinely would not miss, then fine. Go for it! Money is for spending, after all. But if I had to go through the "well, I can always sell it for $X after the kids grow up, so I am really only spending $Y to buy it, not $Z" gymnastics to justify a purcahse, that's a much different story. Income security also plays a role here. Nothing is ever guaranteed, but some income streams have a much lower risk of interruption than others.

families with a single earner who’s career is in a precarious industry (without massive retirement savings) probably shouldn’t keep “worst case scenarios” in mind before plunking down 50k on a timeshare.
I'm not sure about that. I think they very much should keep that in mind! And, unless I completely misread their post, I think that was the direction that @AstroBlasters was headed as well.
 

New Posts









DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom