Ghiradelli's or Beaches N Cream?

[tinkfan05]

If you could only pick one, which one would you choose as the ultimate ice cream experience and why?

 

[fall08CP]

I'm gonna say Ghiradelli because of the extensive menu and TONS of ice cream flavors and topping. However, I love ice cream so I'd be happy at either place!
Menu: http://www.allearsnet.com/menu/menu_gh.htm

 

[IATink]

Wow! That's tough because I love both of them so much. But, I would have to go with Beaches and Cream because of the atmosphere. We did the Kitchen Sink, and it's an experience we will never forget. Oh yeah, and we love the ice cream too!

 

[sunny04]

I would say Beaches N Cream, because the Boardwalk area is just so wonderful! Getting ice cream and wandering around the Boardwalk is the best thing in the world!

 

[frdeb1999]

Both have fantastic choices. We prefer Beaches and Cream though since it's right on the boardwalk.

 

[wdwhereicome]

I don't think I can only pick one!

We love Ghiradelli's for a "just ice cream" night. We go shopping and stop in for a sundae snack. We have tried the 8-scoop Earthquake which was fun to eat. There were 5 of us and we still didn't finish it.

We also love Beaches 'n Cream for dinner and ice cream. We usually split burgers and then get our own ice cream. I love their strawberry shortcake. Absolutely delicious! We have eaten the 5-scoop Kitchen Sink. There is much more drama with it than there was with the Earthquake. They turn off the lights and announce the Kitchen Sink. Lots of fun.

So I guess if I had to pick one for the ultimate ice cream experience it would Beaches 'n Cream for the Kitchen Sink - but Ghiradelli's if we wanted individual sundaes. (What can I say!)

 

[plutospup]

I really, really enjoy Ghirardelli's dark chocolate/hot fudge sundaes. On the other hand B&C's "No Way Jose" sundae is delicous, too! On the other hand (hmm...how many hands do I have?)...the quality of the home made ice cream at Shades of Green is the best on WDW property!

 

[MickeyNicki]

Beaches and Cream because I am a huge peanut butter sundae lover and the No Way Jose knocks my socks off!

 

[bstnsprts]

Try The Fountain at The Dolphin, you won't be disapointed. If you like cheesecake, then the cheesecake ice cream is a must try.

 

[DaveCN]

The last couple of times we had Ghiradelli's, it was not very good. Only had BnC once, and yes, we got the sink!

 

[willis37862]

For ice cream we love Ghiradelli's Beaches and Cream was fun and good but the choices at Ghiradelli's are more to our liking.

 

[mickeymedic]

The hot fudge at Ghiradelli's is amazing!!! I have not tried Beaches N Cream.

 

[jacksmomma]

The Yacht and Beach club is my favorite resort, so naturally I love Beaches and Cream too. Get either the kitchen sink or the Milky Way sundae. My mouth is watering now.

P.S. B&C is a very short and easy walk from the international gateway in Epcot

 

[goldenears]

I have only been to B&C in WDW, but I have been to Ghiradelli's in San Francisco. Both have good ice cream, but I would say B&C b/c it is unique to WDW and because the atmosphere is great!

 

[traviesojmt]

Beaches and Cream gets my vote base upon the No Way Jose alone. HMMMMMMMMM

 

[CR Resort Fan 4 Life]

Ghirardelli's gets my vote.