I wouldn't plan on being back at DHS before 9:15 at the earliest.
I would eat at one of the Epcot area resorts.
You didn’t have a good experience your last visit to Ohana?Yes, this! Getting back and forth from the Poly is going to take a lot of time - driving, parking, eating (which alone could take 90 minutes), driving back, parking, getting through security, etc. It's just not worth it. There are a TON of restaurants in the EP resort area which is just a walk or boat ride away. If you aren't on the dining plan, take a look at the restaurants at Swan/Dolphin which are, arguably, some of the best on property (we really like bluezoo). S/D are the first stop on the boat from DHS, so super simply. If you are on the DDP, 1 credit restaurants include Trattoria al Forno, Ale & Compass and Cape May. All comparable in food quality to O'hana, IMHO.
Thank you everyone for your feedback! We really want to get Ohana in and I think I knew the answer was NO but was hoping for a magical Yes response. We have seen Fantasmic many times but not the star wars night time show. This is my one day I don’t have nailed down. I also have an ADR for lunch at 50s and an ADR at cape May for dinner. Trying to figure out which one of the 3 to keep?
Fantasmic is at 8 pm and the Star Wars Spectacular is at 8:30 pm. Although I've never tried to do both,
can you get a decent spot for Star Wars if you're coming from Fantasmic?