Well, we really liked the DDP last May, with appetizers and tip included, it was a very good deal -- even though we paid OOP for it. We stayed at a value, the Pop.
This year, we are going in September. DDP not as good a deal with no tip or appetizer, but still a decent deal. We are staying at a moderate, paying rack rate, but the DDP is free. But we are a bit concerned about going during hurricane season, the heat, the humidity...
I wouldn't plan this again just for the CS plan for free. We like CS ok, but really do like to have one TS meal a day. I might go during February or some other time when the prices are lower, and try for a discount code on the room. I do like the convenience of staying on site, but would consider staying off site if the place was nice and the price was right, and just renting a car. And next time, the Harry Potter attractions will be open at Universal, so that would be worth seeing. I've also heard that Universal's rooms are a much better deal -- we might consider staying there, renting a car, going a couple of days to US, and just paying for admission for the other days at WDW.
Bottom line -- we all knew that Disney would continue to shave more and more off of the "
free dining" (IF they even continued offering it), until that break-even point, when guests no longer consider it that much of an incentive. As long it's still a money-maker for Disney, and people still keep coming in droves even for the CS plan, then that's what Disney will offer. If Disney sees a big change and their resorts and parks are empty again during hurricane season (and considering that most families' entertainment/vacation budgets are shrinking drastically), then next time around maybe Disney will sweeten the pot again.