I think that there is so much else to see and do at WDW, the quality of the dining is often overlooked. We have enjoyed pretty much every meal we've ever had at WDW, with just a couple of exceptions. This includes both counter and table service. I can't say the same about our recent visit to San Francisco, a city that is known for fantastic dining. We had a great vacation in SF, and we had several excellent meals. But we also had a few so-so meals, and even the good meals weren't any better than meals we've had at WDW.
ETA - Sugarmouse, our meals in SF were pricier than comparable meals we've had in WDW.