Interesting...I have a more neutral view of it. I like its small size and easy/wireless docking to sync to computer. However, the sleep function only occasionally works, which you'll notice is not uncommon if you read their message boards. The software/firmware updates did not work. I've decided I don't care enough about tracking my sleep, so I haven't sent it back or anything.
I think a high quality pedometer might have a better movement sensor. For example, a really bumpy car ride (3rd row of SUV) will give me 1000 steps! I got 2000 on Kilimanjaro Safaris at AK. Now granted, those problems don't affect my average day.
Also, there are not a good variety of choices of "other activities" to add to the profile. I think for the price of the item, the website functionality, graphs, etc. could be better done.
But overall, I've been wearing the Fitbit for 6 months, so I guess it's good enough!

I wouldn't go out of my way to recommend it, mainly because I think it's a little overpriced for my experience with it. But also, I'm cheap, so take my sense of value with a grain of salt!
