Tman, we have only used the Disney fishing excursions so I do not know the answer to your question. However, if you call WDW-PLAY, they should be able to answer it for you.
This is what is currently posted on the official WDW website in regards to fishing:
- - - - - - -
Enjoy the wind in your face and the spray of water on the deck as you head out for a private catch-and-release fishing trip or enjoy a leisurely dockside outing. There is an expedition designed to fit your needs, including two-hour excursions for up to five people, with boat, guide, tackle, rods, and reels. For guppies, a "Junior Fishing Excursion" is available for 6 to 12-year-old Guests.
Bay Lake Excursions
Fish on Crescent Lake and the Studio Lake with a Disney guide. Excursions are available at Disney's Polynesian Resort, Disney's Contemporary Resort and Disney's Grand Floridian Resort and Spa.
Lake Buena Vista Excursions
Set off for your "reel" experience from the Downtown Disney® Marketplace, Disney's Port Orleans Resort Riverside or Disney's Old Key West Resort.
Disney's Port Orleans Resort Riverside Excursions
Enjoy a southern-style excursion with cane pole fishing near Ol' Man Island. Invite the whole gang and enjoy the family special for down-home fun.
Disney's Fort Wilderness Resort & Campgrounds Excursions
"Cast" off all your troubles, relax and unwind a reel as you have a leisurely wilderness fishing outing with cane poles and kick-back fun.
Disney's Yacht Club & Beach Club Excursions
Launch from Disney's Yacht and Beach Club Resorts for a two-hour excursion. The sparkling water and hungry fish make for a memorable outing for the whole family.
Disney's BoardWalk Excursions
Take a leisurely two-hour excursion that includes gear and refreshments. It's fun for the whole family and that's no fish tale!
- - - - - - -