go to Michaels, they always have neat little thing you can put together!
and don't worry about not being crafty, i'm soo not crafty (seriously, girl scout leaders take crafty items away from me and find me something else to supervise!!) but you can do little things like get the small baggies, like what buttons come in, put glitter in them, add tiny shovels and pails and you have a great FE!! Stickers are always cute, little pens, pads, or anything pirate! Oriental trading co has lots of neat stuff too!