Feeling torn about possible upcoming trip with only one child...

moesy4

Mouseketeer
Joined
Apr 30, 2015
Messages
448
We did our first trip to Disney last fall when our kids were 6, 3, and 2...10 days, Grandma came along to help. We learned as we went, had a fantastic time, and made lots of memories. My husband was along for the ride...he enjoyed it for what it was, but doesn't really have any particular affinity to things Disney on top of hating crowds, heat, waiting, etc. So while he enjoyed himself, he would still be ok never going back...although he has compromised and the current plan is to do one last big trip in about 4 years when all the construction is done.
I, on the other hand, was not particularly drawn to Disney beforehand but had a fantastic time and am still aching to go back. It was our first trip and so we learned as we went, still dealt with naps and toddler meltdowns, and missed a lot of stuff. Particularly with my oldest, things like Pirate's Adventure, Wilderness Explorers, etc. had to be breezed by to keep toddlers happy and keep us hitting the bigger things.
Anyway, we homeschool and there is a homeschool group that does a big trip there every year...there are several classes that Disney offers that you can take part in, as well as some non educational events and networking with other homeschoolers. I have heard only the best things about the classes and it would be right up my son's alley. I would love to take him on this trip and also be able to incorporate more of the learning opportunities we had to pass over last time...talk to the cast members at the World Showcase, finishing Wilderness Explorers, etc. It would also fulfill my desire to accomplish some of the things we didn't get to do last time with a very capped cost (some of our extra schooling budget plus credit card rewards, plus of course 2 people instead of 5, etc.) and give me peace to wait the 4 years without feeling like we missed out. Obviously though, I realize we can homeschool just fine without the trip, and if I need to wait 4 years I will still have gotten to go twice more than many, many others so it still is very much a want.
Ok, so my hesitation is the younger two kids. We have never been an "all or none" family...vacationing is very, very important to us and what we budget and plan carefully for and evaulate individually what works in that point of our lives as to what we do . We have done couples only vacations, I've gone on girl's trips, we've done two cruises with just our oldest when the other two were babies, plus of course plenty of trips with everyone as well. But with this trip, our younger two have both been here and know what they are missing, and at least our then 4 year old will be old enough to know what he is missing. The trip is educationally focused, but of course we would still be doing rides and such.
There really isn't a middle ground...financially this fits in only as a trip with the two of us. We either go now or wait 4 years and go as a family. There is a very shaky 3rd option of waiting another year and me taking both boys, but I question whether the program will still be offered for various reasons I won't go into here. Our youngest could never handle the pace of the trip regardless so that doesn't bother me so much as our middle one. It would be a struggle for him still and it would definitely hamper our ability to do the educational activities with him there, but I would still feel so guilty for leaving him behind when I know he would love the trip. Any thoughts, insight, etc?
 
I think that it is important that children learn that they don't always get everything they want just because they want it, and that one doesn't miss out simply because the others can't do it too. In this case you have a very valid reason for taking your oldest child, and your middle child is old enough to understand a simple explanation why. I am sure that in the future there will be an opportunity for each child to do something that the other 2 can't. This is a simple part of life.

I totally get your guilt though, but I think that you shouldn't let that stop you from going and enjoying that time with your son. You will only have the opportunity of doing this with your son at this age once. Regret would be worse than a bit of wishing you could have taken both.
 
I've had multiple trips where it's all four of us, just me and dh, just me and dd, and just me and both kids. I think it's nice to have the "special" one on one time especially with your oldest. If he's like mine there are many times in our day to day life that oldest dd will not get what she wants due to the younger sibling. Oh and we homeschool too so since we spend 99% of our time all together I don't feels as bad splitting things up occasionally. That trip sounds awesome btw. :)
 
Hmmm, I hadn't thought about the fact that this isn't a "just the oldest" option forever...assuming we homeschool all 3 there is no reason to assume I couldn't do some sort of educationally centered, fun trip with each individually based on their own interests at the time. In my head I just assumed as they all came into the age where things like naps and activity levels weren't a big deal, we would shift to an "all or none" type of family. But that doesn't have to be the case for sure!
 

Hmmm, I hadn't thought about the fact that this isn't a "just the oldest" option forever...assuming we homeschool all 3 there is no reason to assume I couldn't do some sort of educationally centered, fun trip with each individually based on their own interests at the time. In my head I just assumed as they all came into the age where things like naps and activity levels weren't a big deal, we would shift to an "all or none" type of family. But that doesn't have to be the case for sure!

That is how I would look at it. I was not homeschooled. But an educational trip that would have been awesome for me would have bored to death the sister closest to me in age (about the same interval as your oldest two).

And tbh, I don't necessarily think "all or nothing" trips are the best idea for all families. Your husband sounds a lot like my dad. Disney was a fun trip with him the first time, but I would not have willingly gone with him again. The crowds stressed him out. He's not a sightseeing kind of guy.
 
I'd take the older kid and go. My philosophy with my kids is that life isn't fair...and that's OK. They are both dearly loved and will get whatever they need as each needs it. If one needs something more today, that's ok. At some point the other will need something more. I don't aim for things to be even though and I try to teach them to be happy for their sibling when he/she gets something good.

Also, I don't believe in "once in a lifetime" opportunities, but I do believe in grabbing whatever opportunities come your way and making the most of it. Who knows if next year will have the right set of circumstances?
 
I have three children and sometimes we take vacation as a family but one year I took each kids on an individual trip. My daughter choose Disney, one son choose Universal Studios and the other son choose a trip to swim with manatees. I think all of the kids enjoyed these individual trips way more than any family trips we have taken. My boys aren't huge fans of Disney but my daughter is and I'm sure there will be more trips there with just her. I think you should go and at some point in future maybe you'll be able to take the other kids and a special adventure centered around their interests.
 
We've never had the opportunity just to take one before we were local. I homeschool too - but my husband couldn't take off work to watch the other two if I had taken just one. (Plus, with the spacing of mine, nursing would have got in the way for a while). However, if it had worked out, I don't see the issue with it. Your younger two are so young - there will be plenty of time for special things for them too. On that note, we did take two of our nephews to Universal a year ago - they were 12 and 15. We did not take their little brother who was 5. They flew without adults and we didn't want the responsibility or work of taking a 5 year old as well. (And the parents probably wouldn't have let the 5 year old go without them anyway!) We will be taking the youngest nephew on a trip sometime when he's at least 12. As far as "fair," fair doesn't mean equal. It means you give each child what they need when they need it the best you can.

Are you going with Carolina Homeschoolers/Traveling Homeschoolers? We've done Disney with them twice now. We moved to Orlando a few months ago so now FL resident discounts are better - but that means we can't do the classes.
 
We've never had the opportunity just to take one before we were local. I homeschool too - but my husband couldn't take off work to watch the other two if I had taken just one. (Plus, with the spacing of mine, nursing would have got in the way for a while). However, if it had worked out, I don't see the issue with it. Your younger two are so young - there will be plenty of time for special things for them too. On that note, we did take two of our nephews to Universal a year ago - they were 12 and 15. We did not take their little brother who was 5. They flew without adults and we didn't want the responsibility or work of taking a 5 year old as well. (And the parents probably wouldn't have let the 5 year old go without them anyway!) We will be taking the youngest nephew on a trip sometime when he's at least 12. As far as "fair," fair doesn't mean equal. It means you give each child what they need when they need it the best you can.

Are you going with Carolina Homeschoolers/Traveling Homeschoolers? We've done Disney with them twice now. We moved to Orlando a few months ago so now FL resident discounts are better - but that means we can't do the classes.

That is the one we are looking at...we have never been with them before but I've talked to several who really enjoyed it. What did you think?
 
That is the one we are looking at...we have never been with them before but I've talked to several who really enjoyed it. What did you think?
I really enjoyed it. I loved that we weren't really traveling as a group - that we could do what we wanted, when we wanted as long as we showed up for the class.
 












Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom