We haven't stayed in too many onsite resorts, but
Value: Prefer ASMu over POP; ASMu seems smaller, easier to get around, less noisy- just preferred the atmosphere in general at ASMu.
Moderate: Liked both CSR and POFQ, for different reasons. I guess CSR gets the nod, but just barely.
DVC: Stayed at OKW and did not enjoy it. It seemed too much like every offsite Florida condo resort we've ever stayed in; nothing really special about it for us.
NOW I am trying to decide where to stay for DD's 21 birthday celebration. We are going during her fall break in October (11-15) 2014; she's talked for years of eating/drinking through Food and Wine Festival for her 21st! Trying to decide between BWV and AKV (will rent points for studio room for DH, DD, myself). Love BW and the location, especially for F&W, but AKL is our dream resort
savannah view, of course!!