I'm No Fool said:
I don't understand why, discounting emergencies and with just a minimal amount of planning, it's so hard to return to a ride within a 1 hour window. For example, if you have a TS at 1, don't get a FP that expires before 2:30. If it's 12:45 and the FP time is 1-2 don't get in a line with an hour wait for a ride at the opposite end of the park.
I have been lurking this thread for a few days and decided to jump in.
First, FWIW, my perspective on this is highly influenced by my experience at
Disneyland. I've been to DLR dozens of times, and am planning a first trip to WDW for May. DLR accepts late FP as a matter of policy. If a CM questions you on a late FP, it is because they are not familiar with the policy. They have had this policy for at least the last 3 years. It is well known on the DLR internet forums, and everyone who knows about it just uses it. Last summer I picked up FPs for Space Mtn at 8AM and used them at 11:50PM that night (when the standby lines were 120 minutes, BTW!). No problem.
So I am a bit surprised by how many people here on a WDW forum take exception to using late FPs, almost as if it is unethical. If WDW accepts late FPs past their window, IMO it is a bit like the state trooper letting you slide for doing 70 mph in a 65 mph zone. Yes, it is technically wrong, but it is rarely enforced.
BTW, the DLR FP system has other loopholes that apparently don't exist at WDW. But that is a discussion for another time.
Second, in a park as large and complex as WDW, I can see many reasons why someone would have trouble getting back within a one-hour window. Part of the problem is how Disney has laid out FP and, in a sense, restricts information about it. For example, say you are in the hub and want to grab a FP for Space Mtn. You have to walk all the way over to SM to find out when the return time is. Maybe the return time is when you have an ADR or are planning a 3-hour break in the afternoon. If the one-hour window is strict, then you do not get your FP for Space Mtn because you can't make it back. So what next? You walk all the way over to Frontierland to pick up a FP for Splash Mtn because it is the next highest priority for you that day. Ooops, the return time is again inconvenient. Now you've just wasted 20-30 minutes, and have no FP.
My point is that if Disney wants to have a strict one-hour window, it would be much more reasonable to locate multiple FP dispensers around each park where you can get a FP for
any attraction that supports FP. The return times would be posted for each attraction, and you could get your FP with full knowledge of the trade-offs of return times and your own schedule.
Third, I agree that accepting late FPs defeats the purpose of the system, and is technically unfair. However, the system as it exists now is flawed. Some people argue that it should be scrapped. Some people argue that even having FP at all is unfair and "unDisney".
I see FP as something one can use to maximize their experience. Sort of like this forum. If it is "unfair" to have FP (I have seen this on other threads - not this one), there are a host of other things that are unfair (such as gaining tips on forums such as this).
In conclusion, I don't think FP itself is unfair, and I don't think using a late FP is unfair if it is accepted by the CM and/or is Disney policy.