Fantasmic Package - Where to Dine?

[disneyfansx5]

Would love your opinions on which restaurant to try with the Fantasmic Package? We will be paying OOP for this dinner. The cost difference is about $25.00 between H&V and Brown Derby with Mama Melrose's in between.

Cast: me, DH, 2 DD's (ages 7 and 5), and DS (age 2). My children are not picky eaters. They love Japanese food, Mexican food, Chinese food, steak, etc.

I have already booked the following ADR's, but I could make changes.
LeCellier
Boma
PSB - Breakfast
'Ohana
Tony's Town Square
50's PT
CP - Breakfast

 

[PeachesDoesHair]

My family will be dining at The Brown Derby. We already had reservations for the Play House Disney Lunch with JoJo, and Mama Melrose's was not available. I have not ever eaten at Hollywood and Vine, but I can tell you that we love The Brown Derby and Mama Melrose's. Some of the best chicken I've ever eaten was at Mama Melrose's. And of course, I love the Cobb Salad at the Brown Derby. I am really glad that Mama Melrose's wasn't available to book---I would have never made a decision if I had to pick between the two!

 

[Tam1067]

We did the package at Mama Melrose in July and just LOVED it--it was one of our favorites from the entire trip.

 

[sfgarb]

Mama Melrose is tops!

 

[F1Julie]

Brown Derby is delicious. It was our favorite meal of our last trip. The FDP is a great deal for the Brown Derby if you are paying OOP. I had hoped to eat there again on our upcoming trip, but I can't get a good ADR time. We're going to Hollywood and Vine which is my last choice, but was the only FDP with a decent time slot.

 

[kimberh]

I love the chicken Parmagiana at Mama Mel Rose.

 

[aubriee]

We've done all three and prefer Mama Melrose. We don't particularly care for H&V and while we did enjoy the BD, we just prefer Mama Melrose.