They might. Is she allergic to all of the options? My son with allergies refuses uncooked fruit (we suspect an intolerance) and the only desserts he can have are rice dream, fruit and some sorbets. Usually we have to get the equivalent to the menu which is rice dream. Once we were told that they absolutely would not substitute anything for the fruit because the only item the chef could make safe was a mickey check meal. We have never asked for sorbet since the time we were charged for an adult sorbet when we got it along with the kids meal at a place that had no kids desserts he was not allergic to. That was a $5 meal with a $7 dessert for a 3 year old. (And then he didn't even like it!) We go to about 20 table service meals per year. ETA: in the sorbet incident we asked if he could get a kid sized sorbet as his dessert since they didn't have rice dream, the chef said yes and we were not warned it was going to be the full adult sorbet.