It was 4 years ago, but we were not impressed with Chefs. Food was not great, and our 2-top was barely the size of a 1-top (it seemed shoved into an awkward spot against a column in the middle of an already crowded room), & the waiter kept pushing items not included on our dining plan.
Also about 4 years ago we had a GREAT meal at Le Cellier. Fantastic food all around, great service, and they made us feel really special celebrating our anniversary.
Have always enjoyed San Angel. So that would get my vote.