You have asked the right question to an obsessive planner. Since I've got mine going already I can work on your plan.
Thanks so much for taking the time to help me. It is greatly appeciated.
If I've got the dates right you will be touring on Fri, Sat, and Sun.
Actually. We will be touring on Friday, Saturday, Sunday, and Monday. We would like to have one of those days (perhaps Saturday or Sunday) be a rest day. We will take this time to go to the pool and go to Downtown Disney. We are leaving at park closing on Monday (May 7, 2007). We were thinking since MGM has evening hours, we would just go there in the evening and leave to head back when ready.
I would probably stick to MK, AK and MGM.
Remember, we are not first time visiters. I have been to all the parks before just didn't stay onsite or more than one day. Stephanie has never been to MGM or AK. We wanted to try and hit all the parks. Over the course of the past two hours, I tried to make a schedule. It is posted below.
Spectromagic parade is only on the 5th and 7th. This is a romantic parade IMHO.
We seen this together twice, and it is indeed romantic. We like waiting right after for Wishes, which is also romantic. We are going to make these a must, once again!
My DH and I met/married while at college in Florida so this thread has really brought back some memories. We had the resident passes and took lots of mini-trips. We celebrated our 15 year anniversary this year. Woah! I just gave away my age

O, well.
Well I appreciate your decision to try and help me. I am glad you are touched by our story. We hope to charish all these memories and hopefully have children to bring back to the world and enjoy with someday.
Below is the schedule I came up with... It is not really detailed but it is just a draft. Thanks for your time to review my plans.
Thursday, May 3 - Daytona Beach departure at 11:00 AM. Drive to Orlando. Once in the area, stop at the store and grab some items. Mainly water and snacks. Arrive at the resort shortly after. Check in. While we are waiting for the room we will change and go to the pool and walk around the resort. After getting into the room, I will give Stephanie time to relax. Later, we will go to Downtown Disney and just check it out. We will make it a must to get to bed early. Did I mention, we plan to eat somewhere healthy at Downtown Disney.
Any suggestions? 
We also want to set a wake up call.
How do we go about doing this?
Friday, May 4 - Wake up early. Get to the park, well before opening. Today, we will be at EPCOT. In the morning, hit future world. We would try to get on as many attractions as possible before 12 to 1 ish. At this time, we will go back to Soarin' and get a fastpass for when we return in the evening. Go back to the resort. I will hit the pool as Stephanie rests, which she plans to do (so she says). I will go and wake her up in time to go to the resort cafe. We will have something to eat. In the evening we will head back to EPCOT. We are thinking of getting there at 6:00. We will find out where to get a wristband for evening magic hours. We will first walk through World Showcase and find a good spot for Illuminations. We never seen this so want to get a good seat.
Any Suggestions? 
After this we will do more of World Showcase and Future World until we are ready to leave.
Saturday, May 5 - Sleep in after a long day at EPCOT. We will take this day to rest, relax, and enjoy. We will wake up and explore the other All Star resorts. Stephanie wanted to stay at All Star Music, but it was full. She is a huge fan of music. We will also go to Downtown Disney. We also want to hit the Poly. This time next year, we plan on having a honeymoon. We are very intrested in doing this at Poly. Therefore, we want to check the resort out. We might do this in the evening to watch Wishes from the beach. I heard it is lovely and romantic from this spot.
Sunday, May 6 - Wake up early. Get to Magic Kingdom well before opening. We would love to open the park. However, we have no children. Therefore, we doubt we would get picked.

We will still have fun. When it opens, we will basically take it easy. Because we will be back in the evening. We just love the opening atmosphere and watching other families running with their children. Man, I really want some kids!

Well, I can say that know! haha! We will leave at 12:00 ish because of crowds. We will go back to the resort. We will rest, relax, and enjoy. In the evening we will eat at the resort cafe before going to Magic Kingdom. We will watch Spectro and Wishes. This is where I have encountered a problem.
The Disney website listed the Magic Kingdom as closing at 9 on this day. However, the WDWINFO calendar has Spectro at 9 and Wishes at 10. So I am confused. Does it really close at 9?

The evening hours let us stay three after after parks offical closing.
But when is the offical closing?
Monday, May 7 - Wake up early. Get everything together and put it in Stephanie's car. Check out really early, if possible. Drive to Animal Kingdom for extra magic hours. Stay there until about 3:00 ish. Then drive to MGM and stay there for the rest of the day. Get wrist band for evening magic hours. Stay until whenever. Drive home.