I know this thread has been out for awhile...but just in case anyone was following our journey that started on the day this thread began - I wanted to give you an update.
I had read so many reviews and replies to this thread that said it 'only took 2 weeks' and similar, so honestly after 2 weeks I was tired and frustrated and almost ready to throw in the towel, but just kept saying to myself 'let's see where we are in another week'.
We started with the MALEM alarm on Jan 22nd.
So it started out that he was dry 2 or 3 nights...but it was just due to the newness and the 'reminder' that he was wearing on himself. Then he started arlarming - many nights initially 2 times per night. It was mostly pattern-ish - 1:00am and 5:00am. It was difficult to get him up and out of bed after the first couple of nights. He was tired and DRAGGING. He was very wet and we went through the 2 sets of sheets we had stacked on his bed a few of the nights. There werer some times when he would at least stop himself and be able to 'finish' in the potty - so I considered those successful alarms at least. We had one setback with a bad stomach bug after about day 7 or 8 and we were NOT able to keep it on him (would have gotten too dirty with all the other things coming out of him) - so it stayed off for 2 nights. I'm not sure if this truly affected how long it took us overall.
Next week to 10 days we had a bunch of alarms where he would be only VERY slightly wet (not even through to the sheets) - this was a step in the right direction. Still had a bunch of 2 alarm nights. But I did have one or two nights where he woke himself up to go potty in the middle of the night with no alarm first. YEA!
Now the last week to 10 days I will tell you that I am THRILLED we didn't throw in the towel. He has been dry...no alarms at all. One morning he was very slightly wet (only on the underwear) but the alarm had broken overnight - so he stopped himself all on his own with no alarm. Anyway - if it wasn't for that one night we would have just about reached our 14 dry nights (instructions say to go 14 days before removing alarm). I am amazed. He isn't even getting up overnight a lot (maybe 2 times a week) to go. Most of the time he holds it all night and just gets up about 6:00am to go for the first time. So....IF all goes well with actually taking the alarm off...we might be in the clear. I hesitate to even write that because I still can't believe it. I do worry that without the 'reminder' hanging on his PJ's - that he might revert. I am actually considering just hanging the alarm part on - without the sensor - for a few nights to see what happens.
Now for the 'broken' alarm thing. I am a bit disapointed - I bought the more expensive model (figuring - you get what you pay for) - and the attachment holding the pin onto the alarm broke off after about a week. We have been duct taping it on since then. THEN, for 2 nights about a week or so ago - the sensor went off several times for no apparent reason - to the point where we had to disconnect it. I might send it back to get my money back - but haven't decided as we 'dried' it out by attachign the sensor to a dry washcloth for all day and it has worked since. We'll see but that's a lot of money to have that many problems in a month.
If anyone has any questions - let me know. I am very, VERY happy I finally did it and tried this. I have been considering it for over a year. DS will be 8 in May and I will be thrilled if we are even MOSTLY dry by then.