does anyone else think that hilary duff is kinda fake?

She needs to decide if she wants to be punk or gurly.

Ok, maybe I'm missing the point, but why do you all feel like this? I mean, most of what I listen to is stuff like Relient K, New Found Glory, Saves the Day, Five Iron Frenzy, etc. but I'm still very girly and kind of "preppy" if you want to label me. Why should I need to have only one side to myself? Does this make me a fake poser, too??

I see no problem if Hilary Duff wants to dress "punk" one day and girly the next. And really, criticizing her acting or singing ability is one thing, but I hardly think that anyone here has a right to ridicule the personality and private life of someone they don't even know.
 
nsyncraider17 i listen to punk to and am still preppy but in her song so yesterda she dressed punk to me and to me so yesterday is not a punk song
 
Well most people think bands like Simple Plan, Good Charlotte, MXPX, etc. are punk. When they definitely are not.

Real punk bands are Green Day, The Ramones, The Clash.
 

OMG... that headline caught my attention immediately!!! As you can tell from my namey-thingy, I'm Lizzie McGuire and Hilary Duff obsessed (my friends say I need a 12 step program...). I'm not some little 8 year old chick who needs to get a clue... I'm 14. Anyway, as a friend of Taylor Hoover (for those of you less educated, she's Hilary Duff's best friend and played Taylor in the Lizzie McGuire Movie) I can speak directly from knowing Taylor AND Hilary. Hilary is one of the sweetest people you will ever meet, and she's also so nice to her fans and will do pretty much anything for them. Just thought I'd put my two cents in, because whenever I see someone saying bad stuff about her without even really knowing the real Hilary, I have to say *something*. Please don't think I'm a little brat or anything.... I'm just doing my job.
xoxo 4ever
nicole*
lizziemcguirefan
 
Well, this answer is coming from someone with 15 years experience as a professional music producer.

1. Hillary Duff has a nice voice. Unfortunately with very minimal range and she can not sing. Most of her voice have been processed using pitch-corrector in the studio.

2. Disney is not even producing her pitch correction properly. There are tell-tale signs on exactly where her vocal have been fixed using a computer.
 
Originally posted by lizziemcguirefan
OMG... that headline caught my attention immediately!!! As you can tell from my namey-thingy, I'm Lizzie McGuire and Hilary Duff obsessed (my friends say I need a 12 step program...). I'm not some little 8 year old chick who needs to get a clue... I'm 14. Anyway, as a friend of Taylor Hoover (for those of you less educated, she's Hilary Duff's best friend and played Taylor in the Lizzie McGuire Movie) I can speak directly from knowing Taylor AND Hilary. Hilary is one of the sweetest people you will ever meet, and she's also so nice to her fans and will do pretty much anything for them. Just thought I'd put my two cents in, because whenever I see someone saying bad stuff about her without even really knowing the real Hilary, I have to say *something*. Please don't think I'm a little brat or anything.... I'm just doing my job.
xoxo 4ever
nicole*
lizziemcguirefan



um i wouldn't call us less educated just because we dont care about hilary duff or anyone involved with her

WDWhunk: the clash and green day rock:teeth:

fatcow: thank you for clearing it up to everyone that her voice is somewhat computerized
 
All this stuff you are saying about Hilary is so immature and wrong. I am a big fan of Hilary and I believe bashing any celebrity is wrong. I think most of you hate her cuz your jealous. She's been acting since she was 3 years old and became named as one of the biggest teen stars out there in a short amount of time. And just because she did a disney show and movies doesn't mean mostly all her fans are younger. She is doin movies that are on a higher base..A Cinderella Story is more like a teen movie and Cheaper by the Dozen is more like a family movie...so please don't post anything mean about celebrities or anyone here cuz its so immature and pointless. And if you have something to say to me say it!
 
hahahahahahahaha LMAO..... *dies laughing*
i stopped reading ur post at the "you guys are just jealous" part... omg what a LAME excuse... every fan of britney and all the other, i hate to say it but, teenyboppers say that we are just jealous. uh, yeah right. i love myself and my life, why on earth would i want to be hilary duff? seriously. that is just so ridiculous to say that... NOBODY is jealous we just don't think like you do. and we are NOT stupid and immature for voicing our opinions. this is america, and everybody seems to forget that we all have freedom of speech and the freedom to think for ourselves... meaning that not everybody has to like your precious hilary duff. *kyla*
 
I can't say that Hilary is my favorite actress.... but she doesn't stink. And i know this is not her fault but the "lizzie mcguire" show isn't somthing little 8 and 10 year olds should be watching. The show implys that it is important for everyone to like you and that you should always try to become popular and that being yourself isnt enough but you have to try to be better or like everyone else.


And her voice sounds COMPLETELY computerized if you ask me...... but thats just my own opinion......

Also... it really bugs me that just because shes famous already and has a pretty face that she GETS to even be considered for a singing contract.


And thanks oxolilshortie..... but im not jealous of her, not anywhere near it actually. I wouldn't want to be like her..... not at all.

And please point out WHERE im being immature...

~*~Aly~*~
 
thank you Aly!!!!!!! here here. i guess it sounds like crazy talk but who in their right mind would want to be hilary and britney? or to be like them like aly said.... ugh! i'm fine right where i am, thank you. and this way i know that if i get to be a famous songwriter it won't be because i'm selling my body and i'm selling sex or just because i have a pretty face... which i wouldn't know if i was britney or hilary. *kyla*
 
Originally posted by oxolilshorti1oxo
All this stuff you are saying about Hilary is so immature and wrong. I am a big fan of Hilary and I believe bashing any celebrity is wrong. I think most of you hate her cuz your jealous. She's been acting since she was 3 years old and became named as one of the biggest teen stars out there in a short amount of time. And just because she did a disney show and movies doesn't mean mostly all her fans are younger. She is doin movies that are on a higher base..A Cinderella Story is more like a teen movie and Cheaper by the Dozen is more like a family movie...so please don't post anything mean about celebrities or anyone here cuz its so immature and pointless. And if you have something to say to me say it!

I agree! You shouldn't talk trash about someone that you have never met! Its pointless, and wrong, and it makes me mad! If you dont know them, you have no room to talk! :mad:
 
it works both ways..... if you dont know her, then how can you say such postive things about her?


practice what you preech.
 
Princess tink,I couldn't have said it better my self!!!:wave:
 
And her voice sounds COMPLETELY computerized if you ask me...... but thats just my own opinion......

It's not only an opinion. As I stated before, it's a fact. If your pitch needs to be corrected a bit, nobody will be able to tell the difference between real voice vs computerized voice. Her voice (and Britney's) are both processed to the nth degree.

this way i know that if i get to be a famous songwriter it won't be because i'm selling my body and i'm selling sex or just because i have a pretty face...

Neither Britney nor Hillary write their own songs. They may brainstorm an idea and get a co-writing credit, but they do NOT write any of their pieces. This matter have been discussed in clinics spearheaded by Songwriters Association.
 
:confused: Hi, this is NOT zen1 posting this, I am her father. She is allowing me to use her computer since I'm over here. Please don't hold her responsible for my comments.

The word "prejudice" ( basically this word means TO PRE JUDGE ) comes to mind when I read some of these Hilary Duff replys. If you do not know Hilary on a personal level and you judge her, you are, by defination, a prejudiced person.

As far as childish or immature goes, I feel that ANYONE who resorts to name calling to make a point is being exactly that...childish and immature.

Now, as far as computer enhanced voices go, I doubt that any CD or TV show or movie is released without some sort of electronic manipulation of the voices or music or some other audio component taking place.

So in my opinion you should all agree to disagree.

zen1's OLD DAD
 
well, first off, you make a good point Zen1..... but we aren't judging her on somthing personal... like her personality, or her kindness.... or anything like that...... im saying she cant act or sing..... and i dont need to be her best friend to realize this....

now thats just my opinion....


the only thing i said that could be taken to that 'personal' level would be that i dont want to be anything like her..... and thats just because im happy being me, and i really dont think her life could be as great as everyone thinks it is.
 
Now, as far as computer enhanced voices go, I doubt that any CD or TV show or movie is released without some sort of electronic manipulation of the voices or music or some other audio component taking place.

Electronic manipulation is commonplace and they are acceptable. It's been like that since the 60's and it's like that today, and will be so in the future.

The problem is that more and more people don't know how to sing and studios/labels take them anyway due to their looks alone.

With the advent of automatic pitch correction scheme, too many so-called singer are becoming lazier every day and becoming much too dependent with the technology.

I've experienced too many top-40 singers (I can't disclose their name due to NDA with the artists and labels involved) who can't sing to save their lifes. So far, I've been spending up to 200 hours per song fixing their vocals.

No, it's not like adding reverb, echo, delay. Sometimes I have to change the entire passage because (picture the following as a melodic line) they sing "C-E-F" when they are supposed to be singing "C-D-G".

Yeah, from the digital artifacts I hear of Hillary's recordings, she doesn't sound like she needed 200 hours of fixing for each song, but she DOES sound like she had been fixed at least 25 hours for each song.

Of course, singers like Diana Krall, Michal Buble, Tony Bennett, require 0 hour of pitch correction. So do Gloria Estefan, Usher, Michael Bolton and Kylie Minogue.
 
I'm 13 not young but not old I personally like Hilary Duff i think she is really pretty and has a decent voice...now my guy friends think she is totally hot! and they are 12-14 yrs. so i dont have a problem with her...yea she's nothing like simple plan...because personally i like them more but hey i still think Pierre is Hot!Hehe!!::yes:: ::yes:: ::yes:: ::yes::
 



New Posts










Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top Bottom