Do you think Kelly CLarkson would have won this time around?

[Spinning]

I am not a big fan of AI but I must say I was sucked in the past 2 shows. She never really impressed me and last night I thought she sang terrible! So just wondering do you feel she would have won if she was up against Ruben and Clay?

 

[phorsenuf]

Nope...she wouldn't have stood a chance!!!! I thought she sounded horrible last night!

***still crying over my beloved Clay....but he'll win in the end ***

 

[Luckymommyx2]

I agree that she didn't do her best last night but overall I think she has more potential/range than Ruben or Clay. Personally I would have voted for her over the other two. I bought her cd and absolutely love it! I don't think I'll be buying a cd from either one of the other two. JMO.

 

[Jeafl]

I thought Kelly was terrible last night, but it probably has to do with that horrible song! I do like her other song A Moment Like This though. She has a great voice, you just couldn't tell from listening to her last night.

 

[Miss Jasmine]

I don't know what happens when they drag her out on stage, but her CD is awesome. I love it.

 

[vald1977]

No, I don't think she would have won this year. I do think she is a LOT better than Kim L. and would have at least made it to the final three. She may have even knocked out one of the guys and made it to the final two.

 

[Demosthenes]

Kelly wouldn't have made it to the top 5 this year and Justin wouldn't have made it to the top 12...IMHO.

 

[BibbidiBobbidiBOO]

I have no clue how she won last year(I did not watch then). All she does is scream, not sing. I just don't "get" it. I do prefer male singers in general though.

 

[palmtreegirl]

NO. I think all of the top 3 would've beaten her. I've never been a Kim Locke fan but last night she won me over, I think she blew Kelly away.