My heart broke when BJ died, it was just so heart wrenching. even though we know it's not real. To this day when they show the scene of Tony laying his head on Maxie's chest I cry real tears, it was just so real.
I also cried when Lucky 'died' in the fire. It wasn't so much his dying, it was watching the reactions of everybody else. Seeing Elizabeth and Laura break down was extremely emotional. Those are the true soap moments.