Do you and your spouse have seperate discretionary spending accounts?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Pooki
  • Start date Start date
  • Forum Forum Budget Board
  • Discussion topic Discussion topic Disney Budget Board

Pooki

Mouseketeer
Joined
Jan 31, 2007
Messages
288
DH and I decided to open seperate checking accounts just for our discretionary spending and have a monthly amount allotted to it. We have yet to discuss all the details as to what this money should cover, but I just wanted some other people's input as to how they handle their budget. This money will be to spend however we want, or to save for bigger ticket items. Some things that we need to figure out are: If you go on a "date," do you do the bill dutch, or take turns paying for each other? Also, one of the things we buy very frequently are DVDs (even though I still think DH buys too many, and for too much)...should these come out of the pocket of the person that really wants it, or do you take it out of a household budget or misc. category? What about haircuts? What else do you specify that should come out of your spending money that may not come to mind as easily? Thanks in advance for your ideas :goodvibes
 
DH and I do not have seperate accounts. We do have a few seperate accounts that are used for specific things, but we both have access to them.

Is there a reason you can't keep the money in your main checking account and just have guidelines about how much should be used each month for each person's discretionary money?

I guess I don't understand the reasoning behind opening up a seperate account. You could both just say "We have $100 a month each to spend as we like" and then use it out of the main account - right?

Honestly, I couldn't imagine going out with my dh and wondering who would pay the check. What is mine is his, and what is his is mine. I am glad that stuff ended when I stopped dating. Lol!

I do understand people do it the way you are describing, but I just don't get it.
 
In our house, my DH and I each get $100 a month of "mad money".

If it isn't a necessity for our household, we must pay for it out of our own funds.

So, bills, food, mortgage, ect... family money.
eating out, entertainment, books, cd's, ect.... "mad Money"

now, sometimes we decide to take the entire family out to eat... that's family money. The eating out we pay for ourselves, is like, going out to eat for lunch, by ourselves, or with just a kid or two..

Ours comes in the form of cash each month. No questions asked, spend it on what you want. I have no idea what he buys with his... and he has no idea what I buy with mine. (Not that it's a secret, it's just irrelevant.)
 
I had one for a while DW took care of all the bills as I was traveling with my different sports all the time. So i had so much each pay go into it. We now use that for our DVC money as I'm not really playing any sports at the time.We did this in case something happened to it no one would have access to our main account and never that much in it.

DW has an account that we use for DDs school funds now that was her mad money.

I do all the bills now and DW goes to Bingo every other week or so. But other then that we just spend what we have .
 
We decided on seperating spending money because I am the one that handles the finances at home, and DH just sort of wings it with spending. We both agree with what we want done with our finances, and how we are saving and paying things off, but honestly, he just doesn't really care much otherwise. Other than knowing that the bills are paid, we are doing a good job on paying debts down and setting money aside for various things, money is just not something he really concerns himself with. We have both tried just taking our "allowance" out in cash, but neither of us like doing this at all and prefer to use the debit card - its just much easier for us. It would be much easier for us if we just had our spending money seperated, that way he would be able to see that he had X amount of dollars to blow on the convenience store...everyday...(a HUGE budget buster of ours), or if he really wanted that new game system, he could start saving his money to save it. And its not just him...I tend to spend more than I should also, but just in different areas. All of our accounts are accessible by both of us, and he knows exactly what is going on with everything, but it would be easier for us to have this one thing for our own, and if he wants to blow all of his money buying Red Bulls and Starbucks, or if I want to buy more candles or shoes, then so be it! I just wanted to know if anyone who already does this, what exactly do you expect to pay out of your own allowance as opposed to miscellaneous "slush" fund or a "family fund."
 
DH and I decided to open seperate checking accounts just for our discretionary spending and have a monthly amount allotted to it. We have yet to discuss all the details as to what this money should cover, but I just wanted some other people's input as to how they handle their budget. This money will be to spend however we want, or to save for bigger ticket items. Some things that we need to figure out are: If you go on a "date," do you do the bill dutch, or take turns paying for each other? Also, one of the things we buy very frequently are DVDs (even though I still think DH buys too many, and for too much)...should these come out of the pocket of the person that really wants it, or do you take it out of a household budget or misc. category? What about haircuts? What else do you specify that should come out of your spending money that may not come to mind as easily? Thanks in advance for your ideas :goodvibes

We use Quicken and I set up two 'cash' accounts that I 'transfer' money to monthly for Dh and I to use. We each get $100 and that is only for stuff. We have a seperate line in our budget for dining out.
 
DH and I do not do this. However, if we were to do it I could think of a few things we would use it for. I would use it to support my habit of buying Vera Bradley bags!LOL DH's buying Blue Ray movies which cost more than regular DVD's. I guess I would have us using it for things to spoil ourselves with. I think dinners out, haircuts, etc should come out of "family" money. Getting your nails done, "toys"(for DH this would be anything for his PS3, PSP)and any surprise gifts would come out of the personal accounts.
 
I am like the other posters here. We have one bank account. But we each have our own play money. Every once in awhile we adjust the money (or budget) to make sure it is working adequetely. Right now we have 100, but it has been as little as 50 dollars when money was tighter. So if I go out wit hthe girls I use my play money. If he plays poker with the guys then I know he is using his play money. I would not like having two seperate accounts, only because then it would be which bills get paid out of which account, who pays for dinner, which parent pays for the kids doctors bills, etc. But I know many people do have two accounts. Good Luck figuring it all out.
 
We decided on seperating spending money because I am the one that handles the finances at home, and DH just sort of wings it with spending. We both agree with what we want done with our finances, and how we are saving and paying things off, but honestly, he just doesn't really care much otherwise. Other than knowing that the bills are paid, we are doing a good job on paying debts down and setting money aside for various things, money is just not something he really concerns himself with. We have both tried just taking our "allowance" out in cash, but neither of us like doing this at all and prefer to use the debit card - its just much easier for us. It would be much easier for us if we just had our spending money seperated, that way he would be able to see that he had X amount of dollars to blow on the convenience store...everyday...(a HUGE budget buster of ours), or if he really wanted that new game system, he could start saving his money to save it. And its not just him...I tend to spend more than I should also, but just in different areas. All of our accounts are accessible by both of us, and he knows exactly what is going on with everything, but it would be easier for us to have this one thing for our own, and if he wants to blow all of his money buying Red Bulls and Starbucks, or if I want to buy more candles or shoes, then so be it! I just wanted to know if anyone who already does this, what exactly do you expect to pay out of your own allowance as opposed to miscellaneous "slush" fund or a "family fund."


Well, like I said, we don't do this, but if I was going to, I would imagine we would just use the discretionary income for truly fun money type stuff.

To me, haircuts for dh isn't fun - he has to have them for work to look decent, ynwim? So, I wouldn't expect that to come out of his fun money.

If he were to go out to dinner with a friend or something, that would count as fun money (me too). My haircuts wouldn't count as fun money (I get a haircut like 3 times a year lol), but maybe if I got lots of pricey stuff often, like coloring and perms it might.

Dining out together would come out of our regular budget I think, unless maybe our regular budget was spent and one of us wanted to use our fun money for that.

Video games that were just for him would be his - video games that are a family thing would be family (example - medal of honor would be all him, if we bought Mario Brothers it would be for everyone).
 
When we got together 10 yrs ago we both had checking accounts.We combined households so we opened a Household account. This is all monthly stuff and groceries. We put the same in every week and what he does after that with his money is his business and the same for me. Neither one of us are big spenders so no problems. We don't ever argue about money. We have a joint savings so our WDW trips are taken care of. I know this is not for everybody but it works for us.He pays most of the time when we go out but sometimes I treat.
 
We do this also and it works really well. I get $400 a month and he gets $200 (I pay for kid stuff out of mine, so I get double). We each spend our "allowance money" any way that we want. We take it out of our combined checking account each month in cash. If we eat out we take turns paying or split. Groceries do not come out of our allowances, that is separate. It works well for us, it has cut down on frivolous spending on the credit or debit card.
 
Some things that we need to figure out are: If you go on a "date," do you do the bill dutch, or take turns paying for each other? Also, one of the things we buy very frequently are DVDs (even though I still think DH buys too many, and for too much)...should these come out of the pocket of the person that really wants it, or do you take it out of a household budget or misc. category? What about haircuts? What else do you specify that should come out of your spending money that may not come to mind as easily? Thanks in advance for your ideas :goodvibes

This is exactly why my DH and I have one account and we have a budget that we stick to. We make sure that there is enugh left each month before buying things but it works for us.

I guess if you are set on doing it my opinions are to - go dutch (it is will not always cost the same) and I think that the person wanting the DVD should pay - why should the other have to pay for DVD's they don't want. . . isn't that what you are trying to achieve by having separae accounts - so you can each buy whatever you want with it?
 
We have separate accounts, always have. We thought about combining them, but just never did. We doled out financial responsibilities (he pays mortgage, I pay insurance, etc) based on each of our incomes and what was reasonable.

When we do joint spending stuff, we generally say something like "Am I getting this or are you?" if we aren't sure. Mostly when we go out for dinner or other fun, he pays unless we agree otherwise or I am "taking him out". Sometimes one of us picks up the slack for the other in their "department" if needed, but that is rare that it is necessary.

It's been 7 years and it works fine.
 
We have 3 accounts, hers, his and ours. Into ours goes about 80% of each persons salary which covers all household expenses, stuff from Target, Home Depot, etc. (Figure things like my makeup and nail polish offset his... well whatever he'd get at Target for himself). Then we have our own separate accounts so I can buy shoes and clothes and other more girly stuff, and he can buy video games and well, video games. Things like DVDs usually go like "if we are together during the purchase it goes on the joint credit card (which comes out of the joint checking account)" and "if you are by yourself and you want the DVD, put it on your own card".

Dinners out, vacations, anything we both benefit from, come out of the joint account. This really works well for us and prevents the "my husband just spent $200 on xxxxx for himself, so I deserve to do the same" which just leads to lots of debt (this is my sister and her DH modus operandi).
 
No. We're both really cheap, so there is no discretionary spending. :rolleyes2
 
I don't understand "his" and "hers" money, it just doesn't make any sense to me discussing who pays for a dvd or dinner as all of the money we have is our money. For that reason, we have a single account and agree on what our family spends money on. We agree on our overall budget and if I want to buy something except groceries or household necessities, we discuss it, if my wife wants to buy something, we discuss it.
 
My DH and I each have our own account and we also have a joint account. We each get an allowance each month to use for what ever we want. Eating out, trips, hair cuts and clothes ect all come out of the joint account. Our individual account is for things that the other person says "do you really need another..." So my DH spends most of his account on computers and I spend mine on books and pottery. The only thing this money if for is for fun stuff for us. We will occasionally use it jointly to buy something for the house. This works well as it will limit my husbands spending on computer equipment and I dont need to nag him about it. And it also gives me money that I can spend however I want guilt free, something that I know I wouldnt be able to do if it was all joint money.
 
We have a joint checking account where our full-time income is deposited. All of the household bills, including an ING account and random expenses like haircuts and clothing, are budgeted with this account. We are each allotted $20/week for things like lunches or fundraisers.

I have a separate account that is linked to ebay and reward programs. I deposit 5% of my FT pay in to this account and transfer most of that to an ING account, there's very little in it.

We both have part-time jobs. Originally had this money going directly to our joint account, but found I was using it as a crutch and spending it as quickly as I got paid. I opened a separate account for this income, hoping that limited access would keep me out of it. I use this for discretionary spending when the household budget is stretched thin, primarily I want this account for vacation.

DH gives me part of his PT income to compensate for shortfalls in his FT pay so the household doesn't fall short (Jan. and Feb. were slow and he was not been working a full 40 hours a week). He was going to open his own account for this income so that his payment for Snap On tools would be separated from the household account, but has yet to do so. So long as he contributes the amount I have budgeted it doesn't matter to me what he does with the rest (he bowls in 2 leagues and he likes his PC games).
 
We tried to do that but it became to muddled what was a personal expense and what was a household expense so we stopped. Since I am the biggest shopper of the two of us I started giving myself a household cash budget each week for groceries, household items, and an allowance. Whatever is left over at the end of the week is mine to keep to spend how I want. It has really gotten me to cut down on my spending and no longer waste money b/c I have some things in mind I really want. Most of what DH spends is on concert and sports tickets and overall it isn't too bad but I do put my foot down if I think it is getting out of hand.

For your situation, I understand why you want to open the separate accounts and you might as well give it a try for 6 months and if it doesn't work out then try something else. I would say household necessity items should come out of the main account but anything that isn't really needed and just wanted should come from the individual accounts. So a haircut to me is a need but a DVD is not. Same with eating out - we limit ourselves to eating out 3 times a week and consider it a household expense. I think if you do decide to get the separate accounts that it is critical that the two of you decide in advance what is and is not a personal and household expense to make sure you're on the same page.

Good luck!
 
We have one account and each of us is free to spend whatever whenever. That said, we always discuss large purchases and eat out all the time! :thumbsup2
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom