We actually didn't like the RR in the Wish but LOVED it on the Dream/Fantasy. I know that it's smaller on the Magic/Wonder but we would be interested, depending on the price. I watched a YouTube video and I think that we will probably get it, if it's still around $140 for 7 nights. Typically, we go to the RR when everyone is eating dinner, so I don't feel like we would miss any scenery. But you are correct that it doesn't have windows.