ehagerty
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- Jul 16, 2001
- Messages
- 2,099
Bought two tickets ($30/pp) - one for myself, and one for DS21. Somehow, with all the activity (scheduling updates), DS did not show up. I thought about drinking his portions as well, but instead, took them with me to early seating dinner.
Table:
Shawn, describing the wines
Recap of wines served:
1. 2005 Grgich Hills Chardonnay (the producer that won against French judges in blind tasting - apparently there is a movie worth seeing about it - "Bottleshock" - which I have in my shopping cart on Amazon. These are the fun things you learn by participating in activities like this, with people who share interests....). I did not record the details that made this a selection on the sommelier wine list (there seems to be a range online)
2. 2006 Purple Angel - I didn't take notes, but here is an except from google:
We had this bottle in May, at Frederick's (Wonder Palo Sommelier) recommendation. Average google price = $55, Palo = $99 (100% is a normal, fair mark-up - the lower end wines are marked up 200-300%)
3. 2007 Caymus Cabernet "Special Select"
4.Verve Clicquot - again, unsufficient notes to know why this particular bottle was on the sommelier list.....
Now, for the evaluation of the activity:
What, if changed, would make it even better?
The best location (so far) for a wine tasting that I've experienced is Palo's (light). Just a suggestion. I know they have to set up for dinner, but if there are only a dozen participating, hold it in the special room there.....
Table:

Shawn, describing the wines

Recap of wines served:
1. 2005 Grgich Hills Chardonnay (the producer that won against French judges in blind tasting - apparently there is a movie worth seeing about it - "Bottleshock" - which I have in my shopping cart on Amazon. These are the fun things you learn by participating in activities like this, with people who share interests....). I did not record the details that made this a selection on the sommelier wine list (there seems to be a range online)
2. 2006 Purple Angel - I didn't take notes, but here is an except from google:
Forbes Magazine highlighted the Montes Purple Angel2005 in its recent article "20 Exceptional Wines from South America." They declared that the Montes Purple Angel was "A flat-out steal. Carménère takes a new dimension," claims the label, and does it ever! From its confectionery vanilla icing, plum blossom and violet aroma to its silky, perfectly weighted palate feel and juicy flavors of ripe plum and blackberry, this a genuine aristocrat."
91 Pts. The Wine Spectator "Ripe and plush, with a dense but reserved core of plum and blackberry fruit that will need some cellaring to get past the mocha, coffee and loam notes. Long and dark on the finish, this is well put together. Carmenère and Petit Verdot. Now in its third vintage, and improving. Best from 2009 through 2011. 1500 cases made."
91 Pts. The Wine Spectator "Ripe and plush, with a dense but reserved core of plum and blackberry fruit that will need some cellaring to get past the mocha, coffee and loam notes. Long and dark on the finish, this is well put together. Carmenère and Petit Verdot. Now in its third vintage, and improving. Best from 2009 through 2011. 1500 cases made."
We had this bottle in May, at Frederick's (Wonder Palo Sommelier) recommendation. Average google price = $55, Palo = $99 (100% is a normal, fair mark-up - the lower end wines are marked up 200-300%)
3. 2007 Caymus Cabernet "Special Select"
Rated 94
Complex, riveting aromas of spice, cola and sassafras join wild berry, spice, black cherry and sage notes in this full-bodied, intensely flavored, tightly focused and very persistent display of fruit that's long and lingering. Drink now through 2017.
Wine Tasting Notes
Deep, almost purple crimson color. Concentrated aromas of cassis and plum lead to flavors of dark berry fruits, ripe currant and cocoa, framed by a slightly toasty oak. This incredibly rich and full-bodied wine shows well-structured, silky tannins and a long, velvety finish.
Retail $100-$160Complex, riveting aromas of spice, cola and sassafras join wild berry, spice, black cherry and sage notes in this full-bodied, intensely flavored, tightly focused and very persistent display of fruit that's long and lingering. Drink now through 2017.
Wine Tasting Notes
Deep, almost purple crimson color. Concentrated aromas of cassis and plum lead to flavors of dark berry fruits, ripe currant and cocoa, framed by a slightly toasty oak. This incredibly rich and full-bodied wine shows well-structured, silky tannins and a long, velvety finish.
4.Verve Clicquot - again, unsufficient notes to know why this particular bottle was on the sommelier list.....
Now, for the evaluation of the activity:
- Enjoyed? Definitely
- Repeat? Every time
- Recommend? If you are into wine
What, if changed, would make it even better?
- Light / Location - I like Diversions and Session OK, but the light is not good for evaluating the wine color.
- Glasses - The debate goes on as to whether the shape of the glass influences nose and taste. Even if it were scientifically proven to have no bearing, I would prefer to taste sommelier-level wines in the Schott glasses from Palo's - even if it were only for ambiance. Quite honestly, holding up these glasses to the porthole light to check color revealed dish-washer rinse residue - that can't be good for taste or visuals. Nice, polished glasses.....
The best location (so far) for a wine tasting that I've experienced is Palo's (light). Just a suggestion. I know they have to set up for dinner, but if there are only a dozen participating, hold it in the special room there.....