Thank you so much
@Lain and
@Minniekins for taking the time to really explain, so helpful. I do have other available funds set aside for the trip besides the $500. I was just afraid of going too big and my purchase being flagged or cancelled. I already have the $200 in eBay, you recommended adding $550 to have a $750 balance to churn but would you guys recommend going higher since the money is sitting in a savings account?
I would not recommend putting in more money than you're comfortable with risking. The gift card churning process is risky, but with the reward of essentially free money that can be turned into Disney Gift Cards. As many of us understand, either eBay, Target, or Gift Card Mall could change their rules at any time and close any one of the loops that make this possible since there seems to be a general trend of cracking down on gift card abuse. If that ever happens, are you okay with the possibility of being stuck with several hundred dollars of either Target or eBay gift cards? That said, churning has been around for a while and there's no specific reason to think these retailers will stop it anytime soon.
Do the math when considering GCM charges $2.99 shipping for the first of any denomination gift card and $0.99 for each additional card of the same denomination. GCM sells $50, $100, and $150 Target gift cards. Figure out what combination of amounts results in the lowest shipping cost. If you were to go in at $700, you'd buy 4x$150 and 1x$100 ($8.95 shipping), or 7x$100 ($8.93 shipping); but at $750, you'd buy just 5x$150 ($6.95 shipping). So if you put out $50 more out-of-pocket, you could save an additional $2 on shipping. Only you can decide whether that extra savings is worth the additional investment.
Two more things, how would I get a 8-10 % discount on this initial ebay purchase of Target cards (using a cc, but without ebay promo) ?
PATIENCE! Your trip is not until next year so you have a lot of time to churn, but you seem to be in a lot of hurry to get started even without an eBay Bucks offer. We cannot emphasize enough that because GCM sells Target gift cards at face value and charges shipping, waiting for an eBay Bucks offer is essential for it to make sense to go through eBay at all. You are much more likely to burn through your $5,000/180-day PayPal gift card redemption limit -- possibly twice -- before your trip even happens. The point is to make every cycle count to try and maximize your savings. So wait for a 4x or even just 5x eBay Bucks promo.
I don't think there's any way of getting an 8-10% on an initial purchase without going through one of the gift card reseller sites + Target's 5% Red Card, or waiting for a 4x or 5x eBay Bucks promo. (I don't do the fuel rewards route.) You've been warned about the reseller sites, but if you were to go that route, it'd be to (1) use your credit card to buy a Target gift card from a reseller at ~5% off; (2) use the discounted Target gift card with the additional 5% Red Card discount applied to buy an eBay gift card, resulting in about ~10% savings; (3) use the eBay gift card to buy a Target gift card from GCM during an eBay Bucks promo, resulting in additional savings depending on the promo multiplier. But doing it this way will already dip into your $5,000 limit on the initial churn because you'll be paying with an eBay gift card. Each time you pay with an eBay gift card, that amount is deducted from the $5,000 limit for 180 days. This is why if you want to avoid the reseller sites and maximize the use of your $5,000 limit, we've suggested WAITING for a good 4x or 5x eBay Bucks offer to spend whatever out-of-pocket money you would've spent at the reseller sites to buy Target gift cards directly from GCM.
Each cycle should add % savings to your fund, so it eventually doesn't really matter where you start.
And, Once I buy these new Target cards through ebay, should I buy eBay cards to have ready for the next ebay promo? Thanks so much. I'm sure you guys are helping quite a few people
I know I've written about this recently in response to one of your posts:
http://www.disboards.com/threads/disney-gift-card-deals.2941964/page-560#post-55270941. I'd add that in the most recent 5x promo, GCM didn't run out of $150 Target gift cards, so that may mean you have more time to get your Target cards converted to eBay after a promo starts if you hadn't already done so. It all goes back to your risk tolerance and whether you'd mind possibly being stuck with either Target or eBay gift cards.
(Edited for clarity.)