Disney Employee sent home for wearing head scarf for Ramadan

Is Disney Right to require the removal of the head scarf?

  • Yes - It's a costume and adding or deleting any piece is detracts from the costume.

  • No. Religious freedom should trump the costume requirements.

  • Other - Because there has to be an "other"


Results are only viewable after voting.
Again, you're talking about apples and oranges. Tattoos have no religious purpose.

If someone wants it to it does. I could give religious significance to my cup of coffee if I want. It is all pretty arbitrary in the end anyway whether it is a dumb cup of coffee, a ridiculous tattoo, or an unnecessary head covering.
 
You (and most people in this thread) are missing the point. If Disney's costume policy is unconstitutional, and I think that it is, having majored in constitutional law & political science, she has a right to challenge it.

Don't you think that Disney would have examined the constitutionally of their dress code LONG before this woman was even employed by Disney?

I did answer all of your questions.

and, for the record, FireDancer, here's the prevailing legislation:

1972: Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 was modified to require all medium and large companies to accommodate the religious needs of their employees, except in those cases where the cost would be prohibitive.

They DID try to accommodate the religious needs of their employee. SHE rejected their accommodations.

When I worked at WDW, I injured my hand. Casts and braces are against the "Disney Look." I, a white, Christian, woman from Illinois was sent to the back to work. I didn't want to take the time off until I healed so for the 2 weeks I was in a visible cast I worked "backstage."

When I worked in Entertainment, again I was injured. You know where they sent me to work that day? In the back. I stuffed random envelopes. One day I even sat in the garage of one of the old "residential street" houses and tested lightbulbs for Spectacle of Lights. I wasn't hired as a "light bulb tester" I was hired as a character.

Disney has precedent and did try to accommodate her needs. Isn't their fault she refused the accommodations.
 
http://ireport.cnn.com/blogs/irepor...rsation-what-s-ok-to-wear-on-a-plane?hpt=Sbin
Went from this thread to that first thought I had was hope that is against some dress code.

It is a slippery slope what if I decided this should be my new dress code to meet my religous needs.

A company has the right to a dress code. If they must be in costume then comply or don't take the job. Disney is not signaling out any religion as others have said crosses and other religous articles cannot be worn on stage.

Denise in MI
 
Thank you Frank...and like I said before I think we're wasting our time (no matter what is in my signature line) ;)
 
I'm not sure what effect it would have on her standing, but certainly, she'd have more of a case if she didn't practice when she was hired. Either way, she's got a great case.

I don't think they could have sent her to work anywhere other than the specific job she was hired for, without being in legal hot water.

Sure they can. By my experience working for Disney...I'm certain that she was hired under the category of Food and Beverage. She was employed as a Food and Beverage worker...period. It doesn't generally get more specific than that. There are then different rolls under that job you can be assigned to.

Don't you think that Disney...a huge multinational cooperation with an army of lawyers would have made provisions for this in the employment agreement. :confused3
 
Sure they can. By my experience working for Disney...I'm certain that she was hired under the category of Food and Beverage. She was employed as a Food and Beverage worker...period. It doesn't generally get more specific than that. There are then different rolls under that job you can be assigned to.

Don't you think that Disney...a huge multinational cooperation with an army of lawyers would have made provisions for this in the employment agreement. :confused3

If it's the case that Disney can shift people around for any reason they want, then I agree with you.
 
I think this is just one of those issues where we'll just have to agree to disagree. It will be taken care of by the people who are responsible to take care of it in time.
 
When I worked at WDW, I injured my hand. Casts and braces are against the "Disney Look." I, a white, Christian, woman from Illinois was sent to the back to work. I didn't want to take the time off until I healed so for the 2 weeks I was in a visible cast I worked "backstage."

When I worked in Entertainment, again I was injured. You know where they sent me to work that day? In the back. I stuffed random envelopes. One day I even sat in the garage of one of the old "residential street" houses and tested lightbulbs for Spectacle of Lights. I wasn't hired as a "light bulb tester" I was hired as a character. Disney has precedent and did try to accommodate her needs. Isn't their fault she refused the accommodations.

This sums up how cast members are accomodated when they can not, for whatever reason, work "out front". What this tells me is that you earned a salary for the time you worked, right? And, it didn't matter whether you were "out front" or "backstage", right? You were paid, right?

Why can't Ms. Boudlal do the same thing? Perhaps it is because she wants her cake but wants to eat it as well?

In other words, she is using her religious beliefs, Muslim in this case, as a sword against longstanding Disney policies.
 
She is on CNN now with her lawyer & suing Disney....shocking!
 
If it's the case that Disney can shift people around for any reason they want, then I agree with you.

I don't have my employment agreement handy but they sure have done it a thousand times before. The might not be able to at the salaried level but for hourly workers in the parks I've experienced it myself and see it done countless times. They are also VERY upfront before you are even hired about what is and is not considered the "Disney Look" and I know you sign paperwork agreeing to adhere to it when you accept employment.

I can't look at it right now but I'm hazarding a guess that somewhere in that signed employee paperwork Disney reserves the right to move you within your job category (at least on a temporary basis) for inability to meet on stage requirements.

You think, after 50+ years in the theme park business if they were violating the constitution someone would have noticed it before.
 
Now she is live on CNN.......

When she started with Disney she didn't wear the head scarf, this is a new thing....
 
This sums up how cast members are accomodated when they can not, for whatever reason, work "out front". What this tells me is that you earned a salary for the time you worked, right? And, it didn't matter whether you were "out front" or "backstage", right? You were paid, right?

Why can't Ms. Boudlal do the same thing? Perhaps it is because she wants her cake but wants to eat it as well?

In other words, she is using her religious beliefs, Muslim in this case, as a sword against longstanding Disney policies.

Yes, I was paid at the same hourly rate I would have earned in my "regular" job. Sure was hosing down trays with a trashbag on my hand ideal? Not really. Was cutting lemons for the ice tea or stacking prepackaged food so someone else could take them out on stage super fun? Nope. But I did it. I was free to request the day off withOUT pay had I wanted to do so.

In fact, when I "out" in entertainment I was also given the same break schedule and differentials that I would have been given had I been working on stage. And let me tell you, testing Christmas lightbulbs one by one in a battery tester with nothing more than a fan in an un-airconditioned garage in July isn't remotely fun. But if you weren't cleared to be "on stage" that's what you did if you wanted to be paid.
 
She is on CNN now with her lawyer & suing Disney....shocking!

After seeing her press conference on AOL News video, there is no suprise that she is suing Disney. She appears on the video clip to be very assertive and noncompromising about her "right" to wear her hijab as part of her regular costume, no matter what Disneyland Resorts wanted her to do.
 
When I worked at Disney, I saw quite a few women wearing the hijab. There's nothing wrong with working backstage, and is just as important to those working onstage. Heck, most of the ones that work in the utilidors got paid more than those working onstage.
Disney also has a large work program for those that are on "light duty". It could be passing out paychecks in the cafeteria, checking IDs at the Cast Connection store. It's not always fun work, and won't always keep you indoors, but they are providing a suitable alternative to allow you to work and maintain your pay. Or the person could very well take the sick pay, but you run into bigger issues when you miss more than 3 days of work in a row.
 
What if the dress code is unconstitutional?

Then we should also be going after strip clubs, Hooters, Lifeguard Stations and the United States Military for unconsitutional dress codes.
If my religion disctates that I must be modestly clothed, I don't get a job at Hooters and expect to modify the uniform to my personal values. If I convert to a religion that required modest dress after I've been working at Hooters for 2 1/2 years, I still don't expect to alter the uniform to fit my new-found values and beliefs. I seek employment where I can be clothed appropriately.

On a side note...this is day 2, and I have yet to see Gloria Alred, Al Sharpton or the Rev. Jesse Jackson weigh in on the matter. I think somebody's media-***** alarm is broken!
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom