Disney Employee sent home for wearing head scarf for Ramadan

Is Disney Right to require the removal of the head scarf?

  • Yes - It's a costume and adding or deleting any piece is detracts from the costume.

  • No. Religious freedom should trump the costume requirements.

  • Other - Because there has to be an "other"


Results are only viewable after voting.
Other of course. ;)

Disney should not have told her they were going to accomodate her in the first place if they could not do it as per the castmember rules. Shame on them. They need to make the dress code policy clear for everyone and stick to it. So, they opened themselves up for criticism and attention.

I guess WDW needs to adopt stricter "no tolerance" policies.

Mystery Machine you know I love you but this was at Disneyland/
 
Sounds like the woman is pushing her own agenda. Lots of that going on in this country for the last year and a half.

Facts are, the company has a dress code and it needs to be followed. I am sure they would say the same of it were any other situation.

Disney is a stickler for their policies in every form. Don't beleive me...read this story!? (I warn now, it is not for kid eyes) ;)
http://lamag.com/featuredarticle.aspx?id=7016&page=1
 
I am normally on the side of religious freedom, but in this case, no. Disney is right.

I am on that side too which is why I was a bit uncomfortable even making the post I did. I'm uneasy that we're telling someone they can't wear their religious symbols but I understand we're not saying she can't, but that she can't in certain areas. She wasn't going to lose her job, but she was asked to go into a non-face position which I'm fine with.
I don't know, maybe I'm being two faced here. :confused3



But what if someone’s faith REQUIRED them to be tattooed and pierced should Disney make accommodations and hire them.
Prehaps lettingthem work in Fantasyland?

Yes Disney could hire them but Fantasyland is a face job so having them work in a behind the scenes job is a fair compromise.
Someone else compared this to the job of an actor and I have to agree. By playing favor to this womans religion could very well make other customers and co-workers uncomfortable. I think it's very appropriate to not allow ANY religious symbols on public display when you're hired for a public customer service position.

Disney worked with her and gave her options but she decided that it was her way or no way. Disney tried. She did not.
 
I am really trying to understand why this is so complicated and going on & on...she isn't required to wear this for her religion BUT if she was then she would not be in compliance with the mandatory dress code of a private company...in this case Disney....no private company can be forced to hire anyone and bend any rules for anyone...whether its a nun in habit as someone mentioned or an orthodox Jew that has to wear long hair or a yarmulke (excuse my spelling if it is incorrect) they would have to go along with the dress code of the employer.

The bottom line is no company has to hire anyone..especially one that doesn't want to comply. My DD is USMC, she has long hair, she knew going in either cut it a certain length or do what you have to to put it up everyday ..she wasn't forced into the service and this castmember wasn't forced into Mickeyland

good grief
 
Disney is known for it's excellent "theming". the utilidors is one reason why you will never see a CM dressed in the Liberty costume walking through tomorrowland. it would impede on the "illusion", which is what theming is.
while I respect the Cm for wanting to adhere to her religious beliefs,we all know that sometimes you cannot take a job if it goes against such.
Disney does NOT have "uniforms". it has "costumes".
there are other rules for these costumes (men with facial hair, tatoos, women with hoop earrings, etc.)
while I realized most of these rules are not religious oriented, she knew about the "costumes" when she applied for the job.

when I am on the "jungle Cruise" I "know" it is just an employee. but I want to "make beleive" that the "pilot" is really a jungle cruise pilot.

heck, a few weeks back we took our grandson to a "wild West Town" in Union, IL. all the employees were dressed in cowboy garb. they did a GREAT job of pretending to be from the old West. they played the part... the whole time! whether it was the actors in the "shoot-out/stunt show, or guy showing my grandson how to "lassoo the stupid plastic cow, to the guys showing him how to "pan" for gold. (they were hilarious!)
someone wearing a habib, or a yamuke (sp?) would have taken away from that "illusion" that we were really in a wild west town (as would someone with a big tattoo of Ozzie Osbourne , or a girl with purple hair, or peace sign earrings)
nopthing wrong with making a stand, but you have to realize there might be some jobs you cannot get because of it.
 
I think allowing her to take an alternative position backstage is a perfect compromise. It allows her to observe her religious practice, which she is entitled to, while allowing Disney to maintain their standard of dress code.

I think many times people do this kind of thing knowing they will get a lot of media attention, especially because Disney is involved, and do it to push their own agenda. I'm waiting for someone who is African American to claim racial discrimination because they were not allowed to portray Snow White or a red headed Irish person doing the same because they can't be Mulan. Maybe someone who is 75 years old and uses a walker will claim age discrimination because they can't be Tinkerbell. There is a big difference between not hiring someone period for any of these reasons (which I am against) and not allowing them to occupy certain roles because of them (which I am not). It just isn't the same.
 
I think allowing her to take an alternative position backstage is a perfect compromise. It allows her to observe her religious practice, which she is entitled to, while allowing Disney to maintain their standard of dress code.

I think many times people do this kind of thing knowing they will get a lot of media attention, especially because Disney is involved, and do it to push their own agenda. I'm waiting for someone who is African American to claim racial discrimination because they were not allowed to portray Snow White or a red headed Irish person doing the same because they can't be Mulan. Maybe someone who is 75 years old and uses a walker will claim age discrimination because they can't be Tinkerbell. There is a big difference between not hiring someone period for any of these reasons (which I am against) and not allowing them to occupy certain roles because of them (which I am not). It just isn't the same.

I'm a white female. does this mean I can't portray alladin?
darn!
 
"Maybe someone who is 75 years old and uses a walker will claim age discrimination because they can't be Tinkerbell."

I'd pay good money to see them zip line from the castle complete with walker!:rotfl2:

On topic; I think that Disney were excellent in their attempt to let her wear her headscarf. They offered her a position behind the scenes but that didn't seem good enough.Presumably she could have returned to on stage duties after Ramadan as it appears that this is the only period during which she wants to wear a head covering. Given that Ramadan is not a new introduction, why has this only come up this year? She has been there for 2 1/2 years after all and if she managed during the rest of her employment, why has it become an urgent issue now?
 
I can't see what the problem with its not offensive its just a white headscarf. Disney is making way too much of a fuss over this as for the costume bit :confused3 it looks neat and tidy why would that take anything away from the "magic" of disney?
 
I am really trying to understand why this is so complicated and going on & on...she isn't required to wear this for her religion BUT if she was then she would not be in compliance with the mandatory dress code of a private company...in this case Disney....no private company can be forced to hire anyone and bend any rules for anyone...
The bottom line is no company has to hire anyone..especially one that doesn't want to comply. good grief

But Ms. Imane Boudlal said, "Their offer to put me in the back is humiliating," she said in a statement. "They're saying because I'm Arab, because I'm Moroccan, because I'm Muslim, they don't want to see me in the front."

Ms. Boudlal, who was not a citizen of the United States when she started working for Disneyland Resorts around 2 1/2 years ago, works as a hostess at the Storytellers' Cafe in the Grand California Hotel. She worked there without wearing a hijab. Now she wants to wear the Muslim hijab.

Disneyland tried to accomodate her and accomodate its customers by offering her a job which was a compromise. But she didn't want any compromise. For her, it is her way or no way.

This isn't because she is Arab. It's not because she is Moroccan. It's not because she is Muslim. It's because she wants to work out of cast costume norms, as prescribed by her hostess job. She doesn't want to comply with the employer's needs and desires for that position

Now, she wants to sue Disney. Why?
 
To me, this story highlights exactly what is wrong with our society. Not just the sue-happy, but the ENTITLEMENT, the "its all about me" mentality. No one wants to look at the option that invloves THEM changing, rather, they expect everyone to change to suit THEIR needs.
I just say this young lady on Good Day L.A. She is a hostess at Storytellers. She explained that she was not personally ready to wear the headscarf in public until recently. (it is a choice after all) She does has the right to practice her religious beliefs. She also has the right to seek employment without a strict dress code. She mentioned she has always worked in the hotel and customer service industry, even in Morrocco. I am pretty sure there are plenty of hotels and resturaunts in the greater Anaheim area without so strict a dress code.
If Jimmy Johnson decided it was against his religion to race on Sunday, do you really think Nascar would reschedule every race to accomadate him? No, they would tell him to pound sand.
This rubs me the same way as banning peanuts in school because of one student's allergy... the more logical solution would be to look for other education options for the one student.
We have sacrificed our rights as a society to conform to few. I'm sorry, but that is backwards. No one understands what the word sacrifice means anymore. Now, the American way is to have your way and expect everyone else to sacrifice for you



I agree with you 100%!! WEll said, thank you!
 
I can't see what the problem with its not offensive its just a white headscarf. Disney is making way too much of a fuss over this as for the costume bit :confused3 it looks neat and tidy why would that take anything away from the "magic" of disney?

The hijab is a Muslim religious symbol worn by Muslim women and is not "just a white headscarf".

Disney customers have the right to expect that cast members present themselves in the Disney costumes provided for the position that those cast members are representing.

Ms. Imane Boudlal does not have the right to dress any way she wants to dress, just because she practices the Muslim religion. She is a employee of Disney and is subjected to Disney's dress code for cast members.

I respect your right to your opinion. Did you know that the hijab issue comes as a national debate brews about a proposed Islamic center near the former World Trade Center site in New York City. Is it possible that the two issues may be linked?
 
I can't see what the problem with its not offensive its just a white headscarf. Disney is making way too much of a fuss over this as for the costume bit :confused3 it looks neat and tidy why would that take anything away from the "magic" of disney?

Because those are the rules, they are communicated when you are hired, and Disney will not make any exceptions because once you do it one time you have to keep doing it because you set a precedent.
 
But Ms. Imane Boudlal said, "Their offer to put me in the back is humiliating," she said in a statement. "They're saying because I'm Arab, because I'm Moroccan, because I'm Muslim, they don't want to see me in the front."

Ms. Boudlal, who was not a citizen of the United States when she started working for Disneyland Resorts around 2 1/2 years ago, works as a hostess at the Storytellers' Cafe in the Grand California Hotel. She worked there without wearing a hijab. Now she wants to wear the Muslim hijab.

Disneyland tried to accomodate her and accomodate its customers by offering her a job which was a compromise. But she didn't want any compromise. For her, it is her way or no way.

This isn't because she is Arab. It's not because she is Moroccan. It's not because she is Muslim. It's because she wants to work out of cast costume norms, as prescribed by her hostess job. She doesn't want to comply with the employer's needs and desires for that position

Now, she wants to sue Disney. Why?

Wait wait wait...Morocco is in Africa isn't it?? That makes her African, not Arabic. In fact, it's on the other side of the continent, nowhere near the middle east.
 
Wait wait wait...Morocco is in Africa isn't it?? That makes her African, not Arabic. In fact, it's on the other side of the continent, nowhere near the middle east.

Thanks, Jennasis. I just used the quoted statement that she made during a press conference that 50 people attended. I will try to get the source, it may have been from the LA Times.

I do have a question, though. Are there any Arabs that live in Africa?

According to Merriam-Webster, meaning 1b of the word "Arab" is: a member of an Arabic-speaking people. But, I do not know the context of the meaning that Ms. Boudlal was using during her press conference.

update for Jennasis: yes, she was quoted in the LA Times. Also, from the LA Times, here is another quote "Disney officials said the hijab would be a departure from the costume policy for Boudlal's role as hostess."

"It has to do with the costume, every role at Disneyland Resort has a specific costume," spokeswoman Suzi Brown said, adding that a number of employees wear religious clothing and work behind the scenes.

So, Ms. Boudlal reported to work "out of costume". So, Disney gave her the option to work behind the scenes as do other "out of costume" employees. Ms. Boudlal refused to comply. Disneyland Resorts was left with no other option but to allow her to go home. She didn't work, so she didn't get paid, I assume.

Maybe she should seek employment at other places that would accomodate her demands.
 
Wait wait wait...Morocco is in Africa isn't it?? That makes her African, not Arabic. In fact, it's on the other side of the continent, nowhere near the middle east.

Arabic is not synonymous with Middle East. Much of northern Africa is Arabic. It isn't about region but about areas in which the Arabic language is either the official language or the language of the majority. Tunisia is also an Arabic country in northern Africa.

There are also certain situations in which northern Africa is pooled in with the Middle East for demographic (religion, government, language, etc) as opposed to geographic reasons.

But, the belief that she is being told to go into the back because she is anything other then wearing a non-approved clothing item is just not the case. Any Moroccan, Arab, or Muslim who conformed to the dress code (including facial hair) is allowed to work 'in the front'.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom