Just back from WDW - AKL - Discovery Magic package...
Here's our experience and initial observations:
Dining:
We used our wishes exclusively for meals. We had lunch at Portabello Yacht club (twice!), Rainforest Cafe, Chefs de France and Mama Melrose. Dinners at Jiko, Flying Fish, Brown Derby, Fulton's and Citricos. Breakfast at Boma.
We actually found that restaurants requiring one wish per person were easier to "get your wishes worth" moneywise given that the wishes (depending on what you paid for your package) are worth somewhere between $30-35, with the exception of Fulton's. Our food bill portion at both Flying Fish and Citricos were very close in price to lunch at Portabello's and Chefs de France and one wish dinners at Jiko and Brown Derby! However, we did enjoy our meals at both Flying Fish and Citricos very much (will be posting a restaurant review sometime in the near future). We were not able to use our wishes for the Food Among the Flowers brunch (nor are you able to use it for other special holiday packages).
Actually using the plan for dinner was somewhat different than listed in the Discovery Magic booklet...
The plan states that for dinner - you may select an appetiser, soup or salad, entree, desert and non-alcoholic beverage...however all restaurants we dined at for dinner followed the lunch rule of appetiser or soup or salad, with entree, desert and non-alcoholic beverage. (Not that we needed the extra salad or appetiser) However, when we used this plan in Nov. 2000 dinners included both appetiser and a salad. All restaurants allowed us to share the appetiser and would split the salad onto 2 plates for us as requested. The plan states that you need to inform your server that you are on Discover Magic prior to ordering...I don't know what would have happened if we had just ordered and then let the CM know we were on the plan afterwards.
Our server at Portabellos was the only one who volunteered the addition of lobster to our entrees!
If the service was especially good, and in most cases it was, we did tip extra (above Disney's included 15%) and many CM's were incredibly surprised. We always tipped on any wine purchased with our meal.
AK parade, Illuminations and MK Fireworks viewing:
This is available with the plan purchased through the WDTC or Disney Club (also WDTC) - no through CRO.
The location in AK is right on the Harambe bridge - there is no shade but the character interaction is great. Guests without the coupons are not allowed to line the bridge.
The location for Illuminations viewing is on the Morrocco boat dock waiting area (not the actual dock itself). This was a wonderful location for viewing Illuminations (but not as good as the Patio at Rose N Crown).
The location for viewing the Fireworks in Magic Kingdom is the patio below the Plaza and Pizza restaurants across from the Castle. If you arrive early enough you can grab a chair and be seated throughout the show. You also have a great view of Tinkerbell's flight. You can not see Spectromagic from this location and if there is a parade prior to the fireworks, be careful your location for viewing the parade so as not to get caught across the park or main street from the reserved location! This location is also a desigated smoking area - and the CM did not ask guests to refrain from smoking if they have coupons for the reserved viewing.
In addition to the coupons, guests must call and reserve their viewings...we called 45 days out from our visit. You must have paid for your package in full prior to making reservations.
We still feel that this an excellent package in 2002 - but not the bargain it was for us in 2000! We did enjoy the additions of the reserved viewing locations and didn't forget to pick up our pins!
For us, two adults, who enjoy eating at least one sit-down meal per day, it is still a great package.
Happy to answer any questions.
-LA