Dinner review of Wolfgang Puck's Upstairs Fine Dining

Uncleromulus

Plain grey will be fine
Joined
Jan 28, 2001
Messages
15,529
But first--a rant:goodvibes It's always nice when the manager on duty stops by your table to see how things are going. Nice touch and appreciated. But this night the manager on duty stopped by FOUR different tables near us (including one where the patrons had just walked in)--and breezed right on by our table w/o glancing our way!! Uncleromulus didn't appreciate that AT ALL, and it took the edge off what was otherwise a pretty good meal.
Anyway--we arrived fashionably on time at 6:00 and since we were the first people in the upstairs area, we got a great table. Sort of a two person "high-top" right up against the window looking out at Saratoga Springs over the lake. Very pretty. Our server turned out to be Thomas. A great guy, knew the menu backwards and forwards, and had some excellent wine recommendations as well. After Mrs U got her wine and me a Tiger beer we ordered appetizers. I started with Gnocchi with Braised Boar Bolognese--described further as hand rolled potato dumplings with a wild boar meat sauce. Now--I can't tell a hand rolled dumpling from a machine rolled dumpling:confused: but these were fairly small and very good. The sauce had a paprika taste to it, but it wasn't spicy hot. The boar wasn't "gamey" tasting and all in all, it was a pretty good choice. For her appetizer, Mrs U had tempura Shrimp with wasabi vinagerette and Thai sweet Chili sauce. It had three large shrimp and she downed ALL of it. She thought it the best appetizer she had that week.
We then decided to split a salad--in this case, Southern Selects farm heirloom Tomamto Salad, with herb goat cheese, aged balsamic vinegar, and micro basil. THis turned out to be three very thick slices of tomato piled atop each other, with a bit of cheese at the top and on the bottom. One slice was red, one green, one rather pale yellow. Interesting looking and pretty good--could have used more cheese tho.
Entrees were next and that's when I asked Thomas' advice. I had my eye on the Spicy beef goulash (braised beef "osso bucco", with sauteed spatzle), but didn't really want it to be merely a hopped up version of pot roast. He told me that most nights the beef was excellent, but once in awhile it might be tough. He suggested I take the chance and I did. And it was pretty good. It was really "osso bucco" style beef but w/o any bone on the plate. Very tender. The sauce (again with paprika) was rather bland and the advertized
spatzles were few and far between.
MRs U went with a more traditional entree-filet, served with roasted squash, grilled portabello, and sauteed spinich. The steak was tender and cooked as ordered (medium)--the vegetables were all excellent, especially the 3 large portabello that came with the steak.
For dessert, I had the "24carrot" cake and Mrs U had the Key West Napoleon (with coconut ice cream, guava sorbet, and meringue). Her's was the better choice, as the carrot cake was pretty much like all the carrot cake I've ever had.
Although it was empty when we arrived, by the time we left at 7:30 the place was quite full. And there were more kids upstairs than I thought we'd see. The dress code (assuming they even have one) was not enforced. The fellow at the table right next to us had on a "Old Navy'" T-shirt. So there you go--
Truth to tell, Mrs U likes this restaurant a bit more than I do. I think
it's good, but not in that "special" category.
 
Great review, thank you for posting. We are considering this for our next trip, so it's good to have a fresh perspective.
 

Good but not that special is how I'd describe our only meal there too. But that was a few years back so I suppose we should give it another try some day.

The thing with the manager would tick me off too. I had a burger at B&C this trip. I was by myself and so sat at the counter. Usually service there is so fast but I probably waited 5 minutes before the server approached me. I ordered tea and when served thanked her. She said "you are very welcome." It just sounded over the top. Then a lady is a business suit sat down at the stool next to me. About 30 seconds later, the server approached her and aplogogized for the delay! GRRR! I guess I should have worn a suit to B&C.;) Server was new though as she didn't know what to do with my DDE card.

Anyway, I enjoyed your review. And Mrs. U's shrimp really sounded great!
 
Thanks for another great review! :thumbsup2 We were supposed to go there in December but ended up cancelling it. WP Upstairs is still on the list of places to try - just maybe a little lower. ;) It's a shame that the dress code is not enforced. Sorry about the manager - that would irk me too...

-Michelle
 












Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top