GenieDana - We are late seating also. Maybe a midafternoon lunch would do the trick. Conch & lobster sounds too good to pass up but from what's been written, we don't want to miss the pirates night either. Thanks for the suggestion.
Stina - I heard that Pirates has replaced both Mexicali night on the western and tropicali night on the eastern. Only recommended Cozumel restaurant we've heard of (by a friend who entertains on Princess Lines) is "La Choza". He said the food there is not to be missed.