Dining reviews 12/17-12/24- mmm, good

xterratri

<font color=blue>Recommends the "livestock" workou
Joined
Jan 7, 2005
Messages
773
Cast of characters: Grandma, Mom, sister, and myself

Where we ate summary:Olivias(twice), Toy Story Pizza Planet, Rose and Crown, Ohanas breakfast, Le Cellier CP package, Pizzafari, Liberty Tree Tavern, Electric Umbrella, Boatwrights, Garden View Lounge Afternoon Tea, and Boma breakfast. Snacks from funnel cake place at MK, kringla and school bread from Norway, and cookies from Goofy's at DTD. All other food was eaten in our villa.

Olivias 12/17- Mom and I split sweet ancho chicken and sis and grandma got hot dog and chicken finger kids meals. Grandma and mom then split apple pie dessert, sis got little brownie sundae, and I got the key lime tart. Everyone liked their food but we loved the sweet ancho chicken, the apple dessert, and the key lime tart. Food- A+, service A
DDE savings= $9.38

TBC later this evening, please check back if interested in reading more as I'll post the rest to this thread also
 
reviews ctd. background- we had 4 quick and casual vouchers to use by 12/31/05 that we had recieved as the result of a DVC screwup so that affected our counter service choices.

12/19 Toy Story Pizza Planet- 1 pepperoni pizza meal deal, 1 veggie pizza meal deal, 2 rice krispie treats. Thought the pizza tasted fine and everyone really liked the rice krispie treats. Food A, service N/A

12/19 Rose and Crown- mom and I had potato lk soup and sis had salad for appetizers, then mom and grandma split the fish and chips and sis and I split the Cottage Pie, we then had the dessert sampler. Liked the toffee pudding really well. Food A+, service C/C-. I'm not quite sure what happened. Maybe they were overbooked due to the CP packages but we weren't seated until an hour after our ADR time of 6 pm and then we were seated outside. It was a cool night and I had NOT booked it with the intention of seeing Illuminations. There were some heaters out there but the one over our table was turned off and we had to ask twice(over a span of time) to get it turned on. The service was just slow and just not very good compared to everywhere else we ate that week. The server knew we were unhappy and the manager was supposed to come speak to us(not sure why, we didn't ask) but it never happened and then we were supposed to get 20% off. Um, we have DDE, we get that anyway. We would probably try again but maybe for lunch and will definitely avoid it during Candlelight Processional. We had plans for 9 pm that we were 1/2 hour late to due to that meal that was originally scheduled for 6 pm. So the DDE discount that night was $8.99.

12/20 Ohanas character breakfast. Sis loves Stitch so this was booked as soon as it was confirmed that Stitch would be there. Breakfast foods were fresh fruit, sausage, bacon, potatoes, eggs(yuck, soft and squishy 'scrambled' eggs), Mickey waffles. Character interaction was okay. Food B+(except eggs- D), service B+. DDE savings $15.19.

12/20 Le Cellier Candlelight Processional package- appetizers- salad for sis, beef and barley soup for grandma and mom, and canadian cheddar cheese soup for me. We all had the mushroom risotto filet. I had the maple creme brulee, sis and grandma shared the dessert sampler, and mom had the seasonal fruit cobbler. It was way too much food. We ate part of our entrees and then got the rest to go because the desserts couldn't be packaged to go. If the meal wasn't pre-paid in this combination, we wouldn't have ordered this much food. We loved the pretzel bread and in general were quite impressed with both the food quality and the service. Food A+, service A+.

More to come.
 
12/21 Pizzafari. Sis had the pepperoni pizza, mom had the kid's quesadilla, and grandma and I split the chicken parm sandwich. Decent food, reasonable cost. Didn't use the Q&C here due to the low cost and it would have been even lower if idiot(me) hadn't forget until the next day that this counter service takes the DDE card. Food A, service N/A.

12/21 Liberty Tree Tavern. Good food and lots of it. We had ate here in October prior to MNSSHP and the dessert was a cherry cobbler. This time it was apple. Character interaction was better than Ohanas. Food A, service A. DDE savings $22.39.

12/22 Electric Umbrella. Sis and I had the bacon double cheeseburger meal w/ strawberry cheesecake for dessert and mom and grandma had the chicken strip meal w/ the no sugar added brownie. We used the last 2 Q & C vouchers here. I got an extra bun to split the burger and it cost $0.80. Food B+, service n/a.

12/22 Boatwright's. Sis had the ravioli which she actually finished, I had the jambalaya which I gave some to mom and still couldn't finish, and mom and grandma split the pot roast which they really liked. Food A+, service A+. DDE savings $10.79. We then did the carriage ride which was pretty neat.

The single BEST dining event of the week- 12/23 Afternoon Tea in the Garden View Lounge at the Grand Floridian. We were joined by my cousin's wife(they and their boys moved to Orlando area in June) and her mother. All 6 of us got the Buckingham. We tried the cinnamon spice-2 of us(which we bought some to bring home), blackcurrant, jasmine, peppermint, and the organic green tea. We shared the teas between us so we could sample more than one. We enjoyed the tea sandwhiches followed by the warm scone w/ devonshire cream, and then 3 of us got the trifle for dessert, one the fresh fruit and cream, and 2 the assorted pastries. It took 2 hours for the tea and it felt perfectly paced. We had plenty of time to visit and to eat. My cousin's mom had been to tea at the Empress in Victoria BC and said she preferred this experience. Food A++, service A+++. I'm going to send an email to Disney complementing our server Jennifer and this experience. DDE saved approx $20, this was the one reciept I lost track of.

12/23 Olivias. Mom really liked the apple dessert earlier in the week so we made a late ADR planning on dessert. In reality, mom and I split a penne pasta, sis had a cup of the pepperoni pizza soup and a kid's spaghetti, and grandma had the kid's chicken fingers, and no one had space for dessert. Food A+, service A+. DDE saved $6.67.

12/24 Boma breakfast. Probably tied w/ Kona Cafe and Boatwright's for the best breakfast we've had at WDW. Particularly appreciated the variety available and the quality of the carving station meats. I want to know where they get there grapes- at home I tend to buy green rather than red but I really like the red grapes I get at WDW. They are consistently sweet whether gotten in December or July. Food A+, service A. DDE saved $13.59.

in summary, we had many good meals during the trip. Ohanas breakfast is the one that we would most hesitate before booking again due to it just being kind of one step below the other TS(and 2 of the CS meals). It seemed like the experience at Rose and Crown was kind of just a result of circumstance and not something systematically wrong. We did think the food there was quite good and would probably give them another try.

So the reason I tracked the DDE savings and total food costs so carefully for this trip was the annoucement that DVC members will be able to get the dining plan starting this Spring. It somewhat appealed to have the cost pre-paid but we won't be getting it. It's too much food even w/ counter service and is more than we routinely pay for meals. The only day we exceeded $37.99/person was Ohanas breakfast/ Le Cellier CP and that would have been the equivalent of a 3 TS credit day. The dining plan may be great for some people but is not appropriate for us. Even the increase in price of the DDE still makes it a better value for us. We'll have 8 trips use out of it when our APs expire in May and it was paid for with savings started on the first trip on these APs.

Hope somebody finds these review informative and any questions, just ask.
 
I, too, love the tea at Gardenview. My mother also found the experience to be at least equal to the high tea experience at the Empress.

Glad to hear another good review of Boatwright's as I am sure we will having a few meals there during our stay.

Thanks for the great reviews!
 

Can you tell me more about Pizzafari's kid's quesadilla? I don't think they offered that the last time we were there.

I also appreciated your comparison of DDE and the dining plan. I've been wondering the same thing, myself, and have come to the conclusion that DDE would work best for us, too. For some reason, we just don't eat as much at WDW.

Pat

344 days and counting . . . again!
 
Excellent reviews! Sorry to hear about the problems you had at R&C, but it does sound like it was a one-time thing, and I'm happy to hear you won't let that keep you from returning on future trips.
 
Enjoyed reading your reviews ~ Thanx for posting.
 





Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE









DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom