Dining Review - March/April 2025

Friday 3/21/25
We had breakfast at the hotel, we both had cereal with fruit, but I only took one picture. They were both similar.
IMG_6848.jpeg

We spent the day driving from Alabama to Florida. We arrived about 6:30; by the time we chatted with the lady checking us in we didn’t get to our room until after 7. We started cleaning the room a bit and unpacking. We were getting hungry so we headed out trying to figure out what we wanted for dinner.

We were able to book dinner at Yachtsman’s Steakhouse for 9pm so we drove to the Boardwalk to have pre-dinner cocktails at the Crews Cup Lounge.

Scott had a Martini. Even though it wasn’t on the menu anymore, the bartender was able to make me the Key Lime Pie Martini that I had here before. It’s really like drinking a piece of Key Lime Pie.
IMG_6895.jpeg

The bartender checked us in for dinner from the lounge and they came to get us when our table was ready. One of my first comments when we sat down to dinner was how nice it was to have comfortable chairs.
IMG_6896.jpeg

For an appetizer we had the Shrimp Cocktail: Poached, house-made cocktail sauce, lemon. This was pretty good but not as good as it’s been in the past. I would have preferred the cocktail sauce on the side to dip, but since the shrimp were just sitting on the sauce it was OK; if they were tossed in the sauce I wouldn’t have liked it.
IMG_6906.jpeg

They brought us bread. The onion pull apart rolls are delicious; this is the best bread at Disney. I like it with butter. Scott liked the roasted garlic on it.
IMG_6905.jpeg

I had the Pork Duo: Braised pork belly, grilled pork tenderloin, truffle polenta, mushroom conserva, port reduction. This isn’t something I would normally order but it sounded good. I’m really glad I took a chance ordering something I wouldn’t normally, it was delicious.
IMG_6911.jpeg

Scott ordered the filet with fries: 7-oz filet Mignon, mashed potatoes, bordelaise sauce. He subbed fries for the mashed potatoes. This is my usual dinner here and I think Scott ordered it in case I didn’t like the pork and we ended up switching dishes. You can’t go wrong with the filet here, it’s delicious. When I order it, I get it without the sauce on the filet, but he didn’t mind it with the sauce.
IMG_6912.jpeg

Scott also ordered the truffle Mac and cheese side. He loves Mac and cheese.
IMG_6914.jpeg

Of course both ordering our own entrees we ended up with lots of leftovers.

We couldn’t pass up dessert and ordered Yachtsman’s Signature chocolate cake: Mocha cake layers, milk chocolate pastry cream, salted caramel sauce, raspberry sauce, dulce chocolate crumble, espresso cream. This is a great chocolate cake, it’s not overly sweet.
IMG_6919.jpeg

Yachtsman’s was a great dinner to kick off the Florida portion of our trip.
 
Saturday 3/22/25
Since we haven’t gone to Publix yet, we picked up Sausage Egg and Cheese biscuits and Starbucks beverages from the Marketplace at the resort for breakfast. We enjoyed our breakfast.
IMG_6924.jpeg

We started the day at Magic Kingdom.

We stopped at the Confectionary on Main Street to get Scott his favorite Mickey Mouse shaped chocolate chip cookie with chocolate dipped ears. We were disappointed that they didn’t have the one he loved anymore; they had a similar one with snickers bits on it. He got that one but it wasn’t as good as the original.
IMG_6927.jpeg

Luckily, later in Big Top Treats (still in Magic Kingdom) we found his favorite original Mickey dipped cookie.
IMG_6968.jpeg

That evening we drove to the Boardwalk for our dinner reservation at Trattoria al Forno. We went a bit early leaving time to go to Abracadabar for pre-dinner cocktails. Scott had a Martini and I had Hoodunit’s Punch: Captain Morgan original spiced rum, orange juice, pineapple juice, coconut. This is great; ever since I started getting this drink here, it’s hard for me to want to try something else at Abracadabar.
IMG_6992.jpeg

We were seated at Trattoria a little past our reservation time as they were running behind.
IMG_6994.jpeg

We were brought bread with dipping sauce. I would prefer regular butter for the bread.
IMG_7006.jpeg

For an appetizer we had the fried Calamari: lemon aioli, parsley, pepperoncini. The calamari was very good; not greasy and well cooked.
IMG_7004.jpeg

I ordered the Bianca Pizza. This is an off-menu item. We learned about this a few trips ago from a couple who were sitting next to us and ordered it; of course I asked what it was and once they told us about it, we’ve ordered it a few times ever since.
IMG_7009.jpeg

Scott had the Shrimp Pappardelle: Artichokes, tomatoes, capers, white wine-butter sauce. Scott enjoyed his dish.
IMG_7011.jpeg

We skipped dessert at Trattoria since we wanted to get cake from the Cake Bake Shop.
 
Saturday 3/22/25 Continued
We went to the Cake Bake shop and waited on a short line to go into the bakery (not the restaurant side) to get our dessert to go.
IMG_7018.jpeg

Scott got a capuccino that he loved; probably his favorite capuccino in a while.
IMG_7013.jpeg

IMG_7017.jpeg

We ordered the Raspberry Champagne Cake: Vanilla cake brushed with a French champagne simple syrup, filled with our raspberry pixie jam and fresh raspberries. Frosted with champagne vanilla buttercream and topped with fresh raspberries.

We tried the cake when we got back to the villa. Scott didn’t like the cake at all and pulled out his Mickey Mouse cookie instead. The cake part had a weird almost wet texture. It was very pretty but we didn’t like it. Most of it ended up in the trash.

IMG_7019.jpeg
IMG_7024.jpeg
IMG_7026.jpeg

Since there was a whole menu of choices, next time we’ll try a different flavor.
 

Wholeheartedly agree with you on the onion pull-apart rolls at Yachtsman/Crews Cup. SO delicious. :love: Also agree with you on the cake at Cake Bake Shop. It just wasn't for me but I'm also not a sweets person in general. For some reason I always forget about Trattoria Al Forno as an option and it's been ages since we've been to Abracadabar ... need to get these back in rotation! Looking forward to hearing more about your trip!!
 
Interesting about the Cake Bake shop. I was hoping to try some cake. But every review I read does not like it.
We didn’t like that cake, but are glad we tried others since the others were much better. We also had dinner there one night and that was very good too. I think the cake we chose this night just wasn’t the right one for us.
 
Wholeheartedly agree with you on the onion pull-apart rolls at Yachtsman/Crews Cup. SO delicious. :love: Also agree with you on the cake at Cake Bake Shop. It just wasn't for me but I'm also not a sweets person in general. For some reason I always forget about Trattoria Al Forno as an option and it's been ages since we've been to Abracadabar ... need to get these back in rotation! Looking forward to hearing more about your trip!!
Those rolls are so amazing, when we think about dining at Disney we always mention those rolls. We enjoyed other cakes from Cake Bake that we enjoyed much more than the Raspberry Champagne one.
 
Broke my heart since this is one of my favorite cakes and i've been dreaming of when I can have another piece.o_O
We liked some of the other cakes from Cake Bake that we tried. The raspberry champagne one just wasn’t to our taste.
 
Sunday 3/23/25
We had breakfast in the room. Scott sliced and heated up the leftover filet and made mini sandwiches on the onion pull apart rolls separating the layers of the rolls to make the sandwiches (we had some extra we brought back with our leftovers). Unfortunately, I forgot to take pictures of our breakfast today.

We spent the day at Epcot

We went to the Boardwalk that evening for dinner at Flying Fish. We asked to sit at the bar.
IMG_7170.jpeg

The bartender mentioned she used to work at Abracadabar so I asked if she could make me Hoodunit’s Punch which she did, it was her version of it. Scott had a Martini.
IMG_7176.jpeg

The silverware with fish scales is adorable
IMG_7181.jpeg

The bread is really good and hard not to fill up on
IMG_7179.jpeg

For an appetizer we had the Slow-roasted Pork Belly “BLT” sweet tomato conserva, brioche Melba, creamed lollo rosso. This was great, we really enjoyed it. The salad dressing on the salad part was fantastic, we were trying to figure out what it was, the bartender mentioned it was a sort of green goddess like dressing.
IMG_7185.jpeg

For dinner I ordered the Ash crusted salmon: herbed risotto, baby turnips, maitake mushrooms, spring onions, shellfish Nage. This was pretty good, but it’s salmon. Scott makes great salmon at home so I probably should have gotten something that we don’t eat regularly. I also don’t like my food in liquid so could have done without the broth, at least the food wasn’t drowning in the liquid so I was able to avoid it. The dish was good, I don’t want it to sound like I didn’t enjoy it.
IMG_7196.jpeg

Scott ordered the Seafood Frutti di mare: shrimp, lobster, clams, mussels, trofie pasta, tomato broth, Parmesan chiffon. He loved his dish. He’s had this before and it’s his go-to at Flying Fish
IMG_7201.jpeg

We enjoyed our meal at Flying Fish a lot

We skipped dessert at Flying Fish since we wanted to go to Cake Bake and try another flavor cake.
 
Sunday 3/23/25 Continued
We headed over to the Cake Bake shop (bakery side) to get dessert to go.

Scott ordered a cappuccino since he loved this so much last time and it was just as good this time

We took our desserts back to the villa to enjoy

We ordered a slice of Red Velvet Cake: red velvet cake with Callebaut miniature chocolate chips. Filled with signature cream cheese frosting, and frosted in a rosette pattern with pink vanilla buttercream. The red velvet cake was very good, not necessarily the best cake ever but it’s good and we’re glad we tried another flavor. It’s very pretty look at how beautifully decorated it is.
IMG_7211.jpeg
IMG_7215.jpeg
IMG_7216.jpeg

We also got two truffles - a Raspberry truffle and a Black & White truffle. The truffles were OK, very rich. We probably wouldn’t get the truffles again.
IMG_7209.jpeg
IMG_7442.jpeg
IMG_7444.jpeg
 
Steak sandwiches on the onion rolls sounds like the best breakfast ever!! I think in Crews Cup they serve prime rib sliders on the rolls (can also purchase the rolls separately). The bar at Flying Fish is my favorite place to dine in WDW (tied with the cooking place bar at Jiko). The bartenders are just awesome, the food is so good, and the atmosphere in general is terrific.
 
Monday 3/24/25
We started the day at Hollywood Studios

Scott was in the mood for a soft pretzel and they are always better when they look like Mickey Mouse.
IMG_7354.jpeg

That evening we headed to the Boardwalk for dinner at the Cake Bake Shop. We went early for pre-dinner cocktails at Abracadabar. I had Hoodunit’s Punch and Scott had a Martini. We enjoyed our drinks.
IMG_7369.jpeg

We went over to the Cake Bake Shop and didn’t realize they had a bar or we would have just gone there for our pre-dinner cocktails. We asked if we could eat at the bar rather than a table which they were fine with; it frees up the table for someone else.

I took a few pictures in the restaurant. It’s very pretty. It reminds me of somewhere you would have a bridal shower.
IMG_7439.jpeg
IMG_7437.jpeg
IMG_7394.jpeg
IMG_7393.jpeg
 
Monday 3/24/25 Continued
We were seated at the bar and started chatting with the bartender and some of the other customers at the bar.
IMG_7374.jpeg

Scott ordered a Martini. I ordered Black Swan: Espresso, Ketel One Vodka, St George NOLA coffee liqueur, five farms Irish cream liqueur and vanilla simple syrup. They were missing the cream for the black swan drink but said they could still make it and would make it sweet for me.
IMG_7390.jpeg

For an appetizer we had the crab cake: Blue lump and jumbo crab cake and remoulade sauce. Served with Arugula salad. This was a pretty good crab cake with a nice amount of crab and not too much filler.
IMG_7399.jpeg

For dinner I had the Classic Burger: Ground chuck steak served all the way with Tillamook cheddar cheese. Served with pommels frites. I made sure there weren’t any sauces on it. This was a really good burger, I definitely enjoyed it. The fries were good too.
IMG_7408.jpeg

Scott ordered the gumbo with added shrimp. Gwendolyn’s Signature chicken and andouille gumbo: topped with long-grain white rice and chopped parsley. Served with a. Side of New Orleans crystal hot sauce and toasted Gambino’s French bread. Scott said this was a great dish.
IMG_7412.jpeg

The bartender was telling us how she liked to add pickled spicy asparagus to a martini. She gave Scott a piece which he loved and put it right in his martini
IMG_7413.jpeg

For dessert we had the Key Lime Pie: fresh lime zest and lime juice custard, graham cracker crust. Topped with fresh whipped cream, lime zest, and lime wedges. This was great; very light and creamy
IMG_7434.jpeg
IMG_7436.jpeg

Of course we had leftovers from our dinner

We really enjoyed our meal at Cake Bake Shop
 
Steak sandwiches on the onion rolls sounds like the best breakfast ever!! I think in Crews Cup they serve prime rib sliders on the rolls (can also purchase the rolls separately). The bar at Flying Fish is my favorite place to dine in WDW (tied with the cooking place bar at Jiko). The bartenders are just awesome, the food is so good, and the atmosphere in general is terrific.
I think that’s where Scott got the inspiration for the breakfast sandwiches from - he saw those prime rib sliders at Crews Cup Lounge. We definitely enjoyed Flying Fish’s bar to dine. We’ll have to try the Jiko bar another trip, but am trying to remember if they have hard chairs (that pet peeve of mine) since I vaguely remember having a pre-dinner cocktail there once.
 
Tuesday 3/25/25
We started the day in Animal Kingdom.

We drove to Disney Springs for and early dinner at the Boathouse and sat at the bar.

Scott had a Martini. I had Duck Duck Razz: Sky raspberry vodka, blue curaçao, lemon juice, simple syrup. This is a great drink, I say this each time I have it; it’s good, it’s adorable, but it’s stronger than it looks.
IMG_7529.jpeg

We started with 6 Wild Caught Sea of Cortez shrimp: London Dry gin cocktail sauce. This is our favorite shrimp cocktail at Disney, it’s always so fresh.
IMG_7521.jpeg

We were offered rolls. These are awesome rolls that are soft and pillowy; they are a very close second to the pull apart onion rolls at Yachtsman’s.
IMG_7524.jpeg

I had the filet sliders and fries. Filet Mignon Sliders (3) with Maitre d’Butter. This is my go-to dish at the Boathouse. I’ve always said that the Boathouse has the best fries at Disney; they were good today but not as amazing as usual.
IMG_7534.jpeg

I wanted to show the inside of the sliders too
IMG_7535.jpeg
IMG_7538.jpeg

Scott ordered the lobster roll, but asked for the hot butter version not the cold mayo version. He thought this was fantastic.
IMG_7542.jpeg

We didn’t get dessert at the Boathouse having something else in mind

We always enjoy the Boathouse, probably one of our favorite restaurants at Disney.
 
Last edited:
Tuesday 3/25/25 Continued
We stopped at Everglazed to pick up a few donuts to go and bring back to the villa. We each chose 2 even though we’ll share.

Cookies and Cream - this was one of Scott’s choices to be eaten another day
IMG_7544.jpeg

Apple Steusel - this was one of my choices to be eaten another day
IMG_7546.jpeg

Nutella Boston Cream - this was one of Scott’s choices. We cut this in half and ate it back in the villa this night. It was very good.
IMG_7551.jpeg
IMG_7554.jpeg

Strawberry iced with sprinkles - this was one of my choices. We cut this in half and each had a bite or two in the villa this night. I liked it but I like the plainer type of donuts. Scott didn’t like this one as much. We’ll finish this one nibbling on it over the next few days.
IMG_7549.jpeg
IMG_7555.jpeg
 
That Nutella Boston Cream sounds delicious (partly because it involves 3 things I love-Nutella, Boston Creme, and Donuts). I've never been to Everglazed, but I think I'll try it!
 
I LOVE Nothing Bundt Cakes. They have one close to where I used to live in St. Louis. Believe me, my birthday cake every year was a selection of different mini cakes to eat throughout the week. I miss that place soo much! And the red velvet is delicious!!
 
I'm with you about hard chairs. Just why? I get you want to turn over tables but I also don't want my butt to go to sleep while having dinner.

Once again, I think we should go out and drink. We are basically the same person when it comes to alcohol.

I might have to fight Scott if he keeps putting ketchup on his eggs.
 














Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top