I know what you mean about schlepping into LGA or JFK. It's just so easy and stress-free to fly out of ISP, but the prices for October are making me crazy...$618.80 R/T for DH and I. That's almost $200 more than we paid last year!
I'm going to wait it out for now, but I really just want to have it done with, so I can stop stressing out about transportation and worry about the really important stuff...like ADRs, LOL.
I hate, hate, hate LGA! We're on the south shore, so it's easier to get to JFK, but even if we weren't, I'd go out of my way to NOT fly out of LGA.
If you don't mind me asking...did you take a car service, or did drive yourself and park in a long-term parking lot? I'm not crazy about the idea of driving in myself, but R/T car service would run in the area of $200 (with tip), which would pretty much eat up the savings we'd have by flying Jet Blue.
So frustrating!