
Great choice of hotels. We stayed both HRH and AKL this year - and loved every minute.
There have been a couple of negative comments about noise levels at AKL just lately, but I can honestly say we found this place to be tranquil - apart from around the pool, which is understandable. The room we were in - Savannah view - was silent and we didn't experience anyone shouting from their balconies.
The HRH was a great hotel - and I mean great. Hard to choose between AKL and HRH as to which was the best (AKL won in the end).
The room at HRH was spacious and clean - ours had Beatle's memorobilia

.
Have you stayed onsite before? If not, you have to! It's so convenient, better so than Disney. It's literally a 6 minute walk from HRH to the entrance to USF, and another couple mins onto Islands of Adventure. City Walk is just the same and you have the priviledge perks onsite like priority seating in most of the City Walk/HRC restaurants. You can also get the little river boat that takes you to the parks through the hotel's beautiful gardens, but we liked to walk through the gardens to USF.
The HRH pool was - awesome!! We didn't eat in the hotel, so can't comment on the food.
The best perk of all was the FOTL access - your room key card gives you this facility and it's not to be missed. We went on MIB three times in a row using this, Back to the Future twice and most of the other rides use this facility. Made our trip.
Paul Dents posted a long article back in Sept/Oct when he stayed there so might be worth a search to look for that
