Kerri I wouldn't count on great rates for sept weekends. Most are booked.
I wouldn't say we are getting the short end of the stick because compared to booking through disney without an AP rate we are still getting a deal...just not the deals offered in the past. Seeing that rooms are booking up on the first 2 weekends at the pier even without a better rate led us to book a room as well. So maybe since some of us are booking rooms at these rates they won't lower them.
I'm not sure what the AP calendar looks like today for October (I didn't look at October yesterday when I looked at December's rates), but the last 10 times I had checked it,
all of October was available. So it could be that AP holders who were waiting for good rates gave up and are now just starting to book because they have to have something at one of the DLR hotels and that's the rate they are left with. But I
still think we are getting the short end of the stick as AP holders because the PIN code offer floating around is
so much better than what the AP calendar is showing for October and some of the Expedia rates for the PPH were outstanding. So lots of folks could book with those great rates, and by the time anything good for AP holders comes out, there are fewer rooms to be had. The Expedia rates and the PIN code rates made the little piddly 10% off with the AP look sad. I know I am not booking PPH for $221 plus tax and plus resort fee - not worth it for
that hotel. Now September had some great AP rates that were available for parts of September for a
long time - $129 for the PPH, for example - and finally they started to book up totally just a couple of weeks ago. And those were available well in advance.
I think that - especially since Disney raised the prices of the APs (with the PAP being especially lofty), they should always ensure they have some great AP rates each month - even if they are only available for two weeks out of the month - just something better than the 10% off.