CSI NY Rocks!!!

[dopeys biggest fan]

I love Lt. Dan!!!

this is just as good as the original CSI show. anyone else addicted yet?

 

[Megan's Mom]

It has proved to be pretty good and with the cast is should do well. I read that the medical examiner will have a few quirks also. What is it about this show that they have strange ME's.

 

[nuke]

It was good. Kind of creepy though.

 

[Penny2]

Too dark and creepy for me but I don't even watch scary movies. Not since the exorcist 25 years ago. Long story that I'll save to share at Halloween!

 

[momof2OH]

We Loved it! Just as good as the other two.

 

[PooohBear]

I Loved it too !! especially Gary Sinese !!

 

[KLAIT]

Like this one a lot better than Miami...Will definately watch it often...

I agree, I like the cast of this one a lot!

 

[stinkerbelle]

I feel asleep during it but here's my take.

1. Eddie Cahill (the cop) was also on Friends...he played "Tag" (Rachel's assistant a few season ago). His accent was so horrible and obviously forced.

2. I felt it was all around too "dark"...I dunno...I might give it another chance. I didn't like Miami at first either...Las Vegas is still my #1 fav.

 

[ttichenor]

ITA with KLAITT....better than Miami. Love that Gary Sinise!

 

[skuttle]

Didn't care for it too much. Didn't care for Sinese that much. Also found it too dark (the filming, not the storyline...thought the storyline was creepy). So far, it's my least favorite of the three. Of course, I didn't care for Miami at first and now I'm hooked.

 

[Desiree]

Better than Miami, but not as good as Vegas!

I'll still watch it though!

 

[goofy4tink]

Okay, I have to ask you guys....why is it that so many of us love CSI..Vegas but don't care for Miami?? I know that I do everything in my power to be able to watch Vegas but after trying for 2 months of watching, I just couldn't warm up to Miami. I tried to stay up for New York but just couldn't. Maybe it's the time it's on. When you get up at 5:30 a.m., you tend to fall asleep at 10!!! And I was so looking forward to watching NewYork.

 

[monkeyboy]

My BIG complain about ALL CSI's is:

when entering a dark room...why not turn on the light instead of using the small flashlight?

 

[stinkerbelle]

Originally posted by skuttle
Also found it too dark (the filming, not the storyline...thought the storyline was creepy).

yes - that's what I meant by "dark". I love to read medical mysteries...so the story line was pretty cool to me.

I think some people don't like Miami because
1. The coroner is always 'petting' the dead people and has a chest out to --------------------> here

2. Emily Proctor...she's kinda odd...but at least whoever is doing her makeup has gotten better in the past year.

3. David Caruso (actually - 'nuff said right there! heheh)

 

[ZachnElli]

Another vote for better than Miami, but not as good as Vegas, but still very good! It was dark, I hope they have some "lighter" episodes (not meaning story line).

 

[jeleebeene]

Saw the premiere last night and really enjoyed it. It has alot of the same qualities that I like in the original CSI series - can't wait for the next episode!

 

[mickeyboat]

monkeyboy - I thought that too, but maybe it's because they can focus better on only that small, illuminated spot than if they tried to take in the whole room at once.

Or maybe it's like in the horror movies. Why don't they run for the hills instead of investigating the room where they hear strange noises?

Denae

 

[oogieboogie]

Originally posted by goofy4tink
Okay, I have to ask you guys....why is it that so many of us love CSI..Vegas but don't care for Miami??

I like how CSI: uses all the characters' capabilities to solve a crime whereas in Miami it seems like Horatio is this superhuman supergenius investigator who sees something and suddenly just knows what is going on.

I do watch Miami though because I like watching Calleigh and the others. I just wish they weren't relegated to being underlings of Horatio. Plus, I think Alexx is way to weird!

As for NY, it's looking like Miami in that it really focuses on Taylor too much. I want it to focus more on the crime solving part. But since it's only the first episode, I'll reserve judgement until later.

 

[crazelion]

I l love CSI New York. The show was great. Can't wait for next show.

 

[WDWLVR]

Love NY, love Vegas, don't care for Miami at all. I think it is pretty much the cast.

I do think NY is darker than Vegas, but I expected that because I think NY the city is darker than Vegas. I will definately keep watching.