Craigslist Scam! Must Read for Craigslist Advertisers

Luv Bunnies

DIS Veteran
Joined
Sep 3, 2006
Messages
9,189
My parents have a rental vacation home that I post on Craigslist for them. The replies come to my inbox and, if someone want to rent and their dates are open, I have them call my mom to make the arrangements. Otherwise, I just post the ad and field the questions as a favor to my parents (and because I get to use the place for free - I'm there right now!).

The other day, I got a reply from a woman who wanted to rent August 8-15. I replied back that it was open. Her next message said she would be taking the week of July 31 - August 7. She never asked if it was available, just said she would be taking that week (which happens to be open). Her message was very specific about sending her our name, address and phone number so she could send us a check. She said the check was coming from her husband's employer and would be a "cashier's check drawn on a US bank." Her messages are full of poor grammar and spelling errors. We sent my mom's name and address and also sent her cell phone number. We said that since her rental dates were coming up so soon, we would need to mail the keys through FedEx and she would need to call my mom right away to discuss the details. She never called.

While waiting for the check, I read a post on the Budget Board where someone was selling a car and got almost the exact same reply including the part about the check being drawn on a US bank. Other posters said the check would come and be written for an amount in excess of what you asked. The sender would ask you to refund them the difference by Western Union, the check would bounce and then you would be out all the money. I called my parents and told them if the check does, in fact, come not to cash it or destroy it. This morning, I got an e-mail from the person saying the check should arrive today by UPS and that it would be for more than the weekly rental amount. Surprise, surprise! She gave very detail instructions about how and where to wire the excess. She also said the check was 2 days after the date promised because her father had died and she had to make the burial arrangements. But, she is still planning her vacation to Lake Tahoe on Saturday!!!!!

I played along a little to see where it would go. I told her it was too late to rent to her since her arrival was only 2 days away and she never called us to confirm the details. I said we would destroy the check or we would be happy to mail it back. I talked to my dad this morning and the check did show up at their house. It was written for $3800 (the amount of the rental and cleaning fee came to $820). She e-mailed back saying she understood about us not being able to rent to her but she still wanted us to cash the check, keep $200 for our trouble and wire the rest by Western Union.

My husband just sent her a message saying that we would not be cashing the check or sending her any money. He said, "We're independent owners and we have to be wary of scams. I'm sure you understand." We're waiting to see if she responds again or if she knows the jig is up. We also contacting a consumer reporter on our local news channel. We want to get his advice on where we should report this scam. My dad said he would keep the check.

So, if you're selling anything on Craigslist, beware of this scam. I'm sure this person used a fake name and will probably disable the e-mail address and create a new one. My dad said my uncle was scammed out of $200 for something he listed on Craiglist. Our scammers were going for close to $3000! That takes a lot of nerve. I'm sure there's a special in he** for this person!
 
Very interesting scam! Way to keep on your toes!
 
And most likely the check is drawn on a legitimate business using the businesses actual bank information and the legitimate business in now dealing with the headache of all these fraudulent checks being drawn on their account.

The same scam is used in all sorts of different ways.

These people should rot.
 
This scam has been around a long time. You see it on Ebay too where they contact you and try to get you to sell it off auction.
 

I've only been selling on Craigslist for a few months now but have noticed that every. single. time. I list something over a few hundred dollars I get these kinds of responses. I hate them.
Glad you didn't fall for this one OP...keep your eyes out, there will likely be more!
 
If anyone only owes $820, why on earth would you send $3800. That is a red flag in itself! Can't imagine anyone thinking, "I only owe $820, but what the heck, I'll send almost 3 grand more than I need to!" Yeah, right!
 
I have to know...who in their right mind EVER thought that getting a check (a bank check) in excess of the amount needed, and sending back the excess, was legitimate???? Not you OP, I am talking about people who have fallen for the scam in the past and will do so in the future.
 
I have to know...who in their right mind EVER thought that getting a check (a bank check) in excess of the amount needed, and sending back the excess, was legitimate???? Not you OP, I am talking about people who have fallen for the scam in the past and will do so in the future.

The woman told us in her original e-mail that her husband's employer was paying for their vacation so the check would be coming from a business. Then she said the check amount would be in excess of the rental fee because the company was also giving them spending money. After telling us the check was late because her father died this week, she pleaded with us to wire her the excess because all of her vacation money was tied up in that check. When we told her we could not rent to her because of the delay, she said no problem, just wire me the entire amount of the check. We looked up the business that supposedly issued the check and it does seem to be legit. I'm sure the check is fake and the business knows nothing about it. I haven't seen the actual check yet since it went to my parents' house and we're up at the cabin right now. I'm sure some people would fall for her story and feel sorry that her father died. As predicted, as soon as we used the word "scam" in an e-mail back to her, she stopped communicating with us. And I'll bet the e-mail address has already been terminated!
 
I would be worried about renting to people from Craigslist. I'd rather go through a reputable rental agency. But way to keep on your toes, OP!
 
The woman told us in her original e-mail that her husband's employer was paying for their vacation so the check would be coming from a business. Then she said the check amount would be in excess of the rental fee because the company was also giving them spending money. After telling us the check was late because her father died this week, she pleaded with us to wire her the excess because all of her vacation money was tied up in that check. When we told her we could not rent to her because of the delay, she said no problem, just wire me the entire amount of the check. We looked up the business that supposedly issued the check and it does seem to be legit. I'm sure the check is fake and the business knows nothing about it. I haven't seen the actual check yet since it went to my parents' house and we're up at the cabin right now. I'm sure some people would fall for her story and feel sorry that her father died. As predicted, as soon as we used the word "scam" in an e-mail back to her, she stopped communicating with us. And I'll bet the e-mail address has already been terminated!

This scam (with checks in excess of the asking price) is not new though. It's very very old. I just don't understand how anyone could think that such a thing was legit and fall for it. Even if it was legit, I couldn't be bothered going through that effort of sending back extra money. What a hassle.

Think about it...if you WERE a legit person sending a check for extra $$$ how could you be sure the person receiving it was on the up and up and would send you the extra money?

It just doesn't make any sense, but I know it works cause people fall for it all the time.
 
This scam has been around a long time. You see it on Ebay too where they contact you and try to get you to sell it off auction.

Agreed.. It's been around for ages and not just Craigslist or Ebay.. Any kind of classifieds, etc.. Often there will be local story on the news about someone who fell for it..

I would have been suspicious right off the bat - with the "but drawn on a U.S. bank" line..:confused3
 

New Posts


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom