I actually have the old Pixter(black and white) from last year and my 2 YO LOVES IT!!!! I actually bought both of them, the Leapster for my 5 YO and the Pixter for my 2YO. The Leapster seems to me to be more advanced then the Color Pixter, so if I had to buy one I would have bought the Color Pixter. Just a note, you can't find the cartridges for the Color Pixter almost anywhere, I ordered mine from fisherprice.com and they had almost all of them available.