I don't have a differing opinion! I am 100% on the Goofy's Kitchen bandwagon! (Breakfast, especially.) It is my favorite of all the DLR restaurants - character meals or otherwise. The food quality and variety is excellent - there are tons of things to choose from and the food is fresh and delicious. Mickey-shaped cobbler, bananas Foster crepes, biscuits and gravy, mini-Mickey waffles, mini-muffins, mini-donuts, WONDERFUL and juicy fruit, croissants, yummy bacon, potatoes and eggs, pizza - both P, B & J and regular pepperoni pizza, chicken, lox, French toast, cinnamon rolls, etc., etc. are just some of the things you can find there for breakfast. There is a LOT more, though. Even the pickiest of eaters can be satisfied. The "regular" characters that are on site all the time at Goofy's are Chef Goofy, Baloo, Chip, Dale and Pluto, and there are rotating guest stars which can include Alice & the Mad Hatter, Belle, Aurora and the Prince, Jasmine and Aladdin, Minnie, Max, etc. Goofy's is expensive but I feel it is totally worth it. It is an all you can eat character buffet, breakfast, brunch or dinner, the quality of the food is great, and I have always had good character interaction, minus maybe two times in 16 years.
People always say that Goofy's is so chaotic and frenzied, but I have never witnessed that in all my times eating there. Sure there were times where it was busier than other times, but I never noticed anything being too unruly or tough to take. I don't have kids and neither do my friends, so if we went there and there were nothing but unruly, loud children running everywhere, we probably would not have gone back. But everything is very well handled and fun. Goofy does the Macarena with the kids at certain intervals and Baloo comes up to move his ample bottom around to the music, and the Princesses will dance too. It's cute.
If you want to see a whole lot of pictures taken at Goofy's between 1992 and 2008 to get a sense of which characters have been there over the years, go to my Trip Report - the link is in my signature below.
I have done the Storytellers character breakfast twice. The first time I was there in 2001, I think I saw Timon, Rafiki, Meeko, Baloo, Chip and Dale, and someone I am forgetting. Like another jungle cat character, I think. The second time I went there for a character meal, in 2007, it was Chip, Dale, Koda and Kenai from Brother Bear, and I think Baloo came in as we were leaving. You basically find the woodsy/jungly Disney characters there. I was not overwhlemed with the character selection nor was I with the food. The off the menu prices were too much money for the portions, I felt, and I was not bowled over with the taste of the stuff at the buffet. It was only okay to me. However, Storytellers is a nice, relaxing atmosphere, cozy and homey, and you may prefer that. I actually prefer Storytellers for the non-character meals like lunch or dinner.
I have heard that Minnie's inside DL can get crazy and unruly. I have not eaten there yet, but the character selection looks good. Some people LOVE Minnie's and other say that the food is kind of lacking.
Lots of folks rave about Lilo and Stitch (in the PCH Grill) and their coconut scones. I look forward to trying that character meal one day.
The other option for an all-Princess meal is Ariel's Grotto in DCA. Not my cup of tea because I am not into princesses, but great for little girls, I would think!!!