UPDATE: Im going to try for an ADR at Cape May thanks to all your advice! If they're booked on that day, then I'll look into changing my lunch at Yak & Yeti to a breakfast at Tusker House on the other day instead. Thank you so much for your patience!!
Ok I keep staring at the menus and my itinerary and think I've narrowed it down to Tusker House character breakfast or Cape May Cafe character Breakfast. Here's my quick itinerary:
5/5: arrive 1:30pm. check in POFQ. Go to Epcot WS. Eat dinner CS there. stay for illuminations.
5/6: AK for RD. ADR at Yak & Yeti 12pm. Secretly treating mom to La Nouba this night!

6 pm. dinner cs or at hotel.
5/7: Epcot FW for RD. ADR at Le Cellier 12:50 pm. Evening/night at MK. CS dinner. Stay for Wishes 9 pm.
5/8: MGM. ADR for dinner at Kona Cafe 7:40 pm. (mom hasn't been since we went as a family in 1986. we stayed at the poly. so we're going to hang out here for a while and hopefully see the water parade and wishes from the beach this night!)
5/9: Last day. Drop off luggage. Hit either MK or Epcot - mom's choice. Leave for POFQ for 2 pm. Estimating Magic Express will pick us up at 3:30 for our 6:30 pm flight.
So...
OPTION 1: Tuesday- I can either cancel my Yak & Yeti ADR in favor of a Tusker House character breakfast. The food at Tusker House looks yummy and different from the standard buffet fare. We were excited about trying the new Yak & Yeti but Im not sure about the menu. Is this option worth the change?
OPTION 2: Thursday- this is a more laid back day. We could make a reservation for Cape May and then take the boat over to MGM for the day after we eat. Neither of us has ever been to the Beach Club resort so this would be another reason to go here. But the menu looks like standard blah breakfast fare. Is it better than the menu states?
Ok now which should I choose? haha Thanks again!
I have taken note of all the votes for Cape May which is why I was leaning in that direction.