I've done it both ways. Last year I got an AP discount for our last night, added to a points stay. I had to go to the front desk and get new keys and parking permit on Friday morning. We got full housekeeping on Friday, which was nice after 5 nights. AP rate was about $20 less. This year I did the member discount for our Saturday arrival, then points for the rest. We just got trash & towel on Tuesday. The AP rate this year was about the same as member discount, so I took the member discount, less hassle, didn't need full housekeeping on day 2. The way they have been pricing the AP rates as a flat $ amount off ($70 on the last release for deluxe), the member discount would probably be better for a 1 bedroom.