car insurance for teen driver question

4fosterkids

DIS Veteran
Joined
Feb 4, 2005
Messages
2,555
We have AAA for our cars/house and have for years and been very happy with them. To add my son on, will cost us a fortune. I've been looking around a bit for other options to get him his own policy, but its a bit overwhelming and time consuming.

Any suggestions to streamline my searching? Who do you have your teen driver's insured thru? Are you happy with them?
 
I am in retired from law enforcement and never added my children to my policy. they always had their own. With a car liability no collision. They bought their own car too, working to save money for one and upkeep. Never anything pricey to carry full coverage.

The difference from adding them and their own policy was nominal. They paid about $80-$100 a month. But, the liability was never worth saving the kids a few dollars.
It was no different when I started driving and had a car. I had a down payment, bought a family members used car, financed it and carried the insurance in my own name.

The kids would watch for the discounts as they turned 21, 25 and even got married. Taking drivers Ed, having good report cards gives them discounts.

I own 2 cars and my home, after investigating multiple accidents with teenagers I knew I would NEVER have that liability.
I was hit by a 17 yr old driving her mothers car that she bought for her dd, and the girl was underage, under the influance and rammed a police car. It ended my career,

So, no job, no car, no insurance....is our rule.

Also, if your teen driver receives a chargable citation or accident, how will it affect your policy? I would ask the question of an agent, if the teen is underage and cited, and in a chargable accident, can they drop your policy?

Know all these situtations before adding to your own policy.
Good luck,
di
 
We added DD last year (now 17) and DS will be taking drivers ED this year, I talked to our insurance company before she started driving to see what we could do to keep costs down. They recommended getting a car at least 10 years old so we would not have to carry collision, which really lowers your rates. If there is an accident you have to be able to walk away from the car, but there is no claim to raise the rates. Our insurance company had a couple of other things we could do to lower the rates (ie: good student). It may help to call them in advance and see what advice they have. Good luck.
 
We have Erie and pay $1500 a year for DS, plus we purchased an umbrella policy as well. He is driving a 5 year old Honda with full coverage. The car is still worth too much to just have liability. Plus I feel better knowing he is driving a safe vehicle that is less likely to break down. While I understand the risks of having him on my policy there is just no way he can afford to have his own right now. We have a ton of rules associated with him driving the car and don't just let him drive around willy nilly... So far, the arrangement has worked out well for us.
 

I have GEICO and it was about $1000/yr to add DD and another car with full coverage.
 
Allstate has a teen driver program. When they complete it they get either 10 or 20 percent off their premium until they turn 21. My dd will also be driving an older car and it doesn't cost that much to add her to our policy.
 
I am in retired from law enforcement and never added my children to my policy. they always had their own. With a car liability no collision. They bought their own car too, working to save money for one and upkeep. Never anything pricey to carry full coverage.

The difference from adding them and their own policy was nominal. They paid about $80-$100 a month. But, the liability was never worth saving the kids a few dollars.
It was no different when I started driving and had a car. I had a down payment, bought a family members used car, financed it and carried the insurance in my own name.

The kids would watch for the discounts as they turned 21, 25 and even got married. Taking drivers Ed, having good report cards gives them discounts.

I own 2 cars and my home, after investigating multiple accidents with teenagers I knew I would NEVER have that liability.
I was hit by a 17 yr old driving her mothers car that she bought for her dd, and the girl was underage, under the influance and rammed a police car. It ended my career,

So, no job, no car, no insurance....is our rule.

Also, if your teen driver receives a chargable citation or accident, how will it affect your policy? I would ask the question of an agent, if the teen is underage and cited, and in a chargable accident, can they drop your policy?

Know all these situtations before adding to your own policy.
Good luck,
di

Could you please explain about the "liabilities" of having them on our insurance? I have an 18 year old (on feb 24) on my policy right now, rated on his own 18-year old car without collision. My 16-year old is ready to get his license now so he will get the old car and my 18-year old plans on buying a "new used" car on his birthday. It adds about $150 to our current policy, but please tell me what the liabilities are about. Thank you. BTW, his own policy for the newer car would be impossible for him.
 
I think I know the answer to this question, but I'm going to ask it anyway:

It seems to be a given that the teen will have a car of his or her own -- what about insuring a teen driver who won't have a personal vehicle?

Before anyone says, "Have her get a job and earn the money herself", I'll go ahead and say that it's not a financial choice. We don't want her to have a personal car during high school; that's a parenting choice that we've made -- nothing to do with money. We want her to be able to drive one of our cars when it's convenient, but we don't want to give her the freedom and responsibility of car ownership at the tender age of 16.
 
I work in insurance and deal with this everyday. I've never seen it cheaper to get a kid their own policy. If someone does go that route I'd really suggest that they give the car to the kid and get it retitled. If the car is still owned by the parent even if insurance is in kid's name they could be held accountable. Cheapest way is to get something older that you wouldn't have to put physical damage coverage on. Once a kid has a license they need to be added as a household driver even if they don't have a car of their own. With my company in Texas if a kid is rated on any car in the house they are covered on all the cars on the policy. (This varies from co to co and state to state) I really try to put the kid on the cheapest car even if we know that is not the one they drive the most. It is really expensive to add the kids -boys even more so. I know it can be a shock.
 
Getting his own policy will probably cost him more than adding him to yours. I would seriously rethink this idea. Having him contribute part or all of the increase is a reasonable idea.
 
I guess the Laws are different in each State.
Where I live you are FORCED to put your child on your policy the second they get their License.
It is not an option for them to have their own policy if they live with me...:sad2:
 
Our son is 16 1/2 and just got his license. I dreaded going to add him to the insurance, but it is only costing $116.00 every 6 months. We have State Farm and also have our home with them. He was able to get 3 discounts....driver's ed, good student, and Steer Clear....which is a program they have where he fills out a booklet everytime he drives detailing his experiences. The parent has to sign that he actually did it. They said it will be a lot more once we get another car, but for now he drives one of ours. I was pleasantly surprised at the cost. :) :) :)
 
My son got his license in March and then he got his own car in May. I gambled and did a $1,000 deductible and guess what, he got into an accident. A minor one but still I had to pay the $1,000 deductible. I thought about putting the car in his name and then he get his own insurance but then I don't have the option of taking the car away from him if I need to (for punishment). I did get a good student discount, a discount from allstate because they are going to take the premium directly out of my checking account. So really to get the lowest price, you need to buy an old car so you don't have to carry collision, only liability. Ask for a good student discount. Ask if there are any other discounts, such as if you insure house or do an umbrella policy. I actually went with my old Allstate agent who really looked into getting me discounts so that might be a route for you to take. Personal attention from someone you can talk face to face vs. someone over a phone who doesn't really care about getting you a low rate.
 
thanks for all the information so far! It is very insightful and has brought up some things I have not thought about so far.
keep 'em coming if you have information to share....
 
We just went through the student insurance issue a few months ago- we asked alot of different people- and agents and what most said was to get a car that is "disposable" carry just liability and if there is an accident just plan on getting a different vehicle! We decided that sounded like a plan-especially since our DD had money saved- so for what we were looking for-safe and not too embarrassing- lol- she could pay a large portion of the car herself. We have 2 vehicles, our house and an RV with our agent and in the end I tried an online quote thru progressive and they ended up cheaper than my agent- even after our DD earned the good student discount,etc.. We went with them and have not regretted it.

Do the online quote and you can click to have someone call you- they call immediately! The lady I talked to totally sold me she was so nice and helpful!
 
My son got his license in March and then he got his own car in May. I gambled and did a $1,000 deductible and guess what, he got into an accident. A minor one but still I had to pay the $1,000 deductible. I thought about putting the car in his name and then he get his own insurance but then I don't have the option of taking the car away from him if I need to (for punishment). I did get a good student discount, a discount from allstate because they are going to take the premium directly out of my checking account. So really to get the lowest price, you need to buy an old car so you don't have to carry collision, only liability. Ask for a good student discount. Ask if there are any other discounts, such as if you insure house or do an umbrella policy. I actually went with my old Allstate agent who really looked into getting me discounts so that might be a route for you to take. Personal attention from someone you can talk face to face vs. someone over a phone who doesn't really care about getting you a low rate.

As long as your child is on a JR license as a parent you have control over the license. there are restrictions to hours drivng, the cinderella law, but provisions for return ing from work are in there too.

The kids love to advance and remove the jr license provisions but they do help a parent with monitoring control/ I can tell you that there is nothing more horriffic then going to a parents home to tell them of a horrendous crash their child was in. There are far too many divirsions for a 16 yr old to be handed the keys to a car as far as I am concerned after living the aftermaths....no matter how responsible, reliable the kids are, their parents have lost them too.

I couldn;t believe, not just teens, but adults TEXTING away as they drive! Big diversions, if others are in the car, huge chance of not having aletness radar on.

Because of my profession I allowed the kids to get a permit after 16 IF they had a part time ob. they stayed on the permit for a year until 17 to get their license. At 17 they had a Jr license that I was able to control to revoke under parental rights.

At 18 they got their own car, insurance and SR license. There is so many more cars on the road now, people not only teens paying attention, it is elderly, not all of them, it is adults always rushing and not defensive driving.

The liability comes when a child is in a car in your name and you own a home and something drastic happens. IT could devastate you. Especially if you child is issued sitations and in a reportable accident, or lent the car to someone and your insurance drops you, increases your rate higher then what the kid would ever have in the first place, or the damage they incure is more then the policy and they go after you.

The insurance for a shild is affordable as said in prior post, buy the older car you are willing to eat the cost if in a collision, do not but performance cars no matter how much they beg, nothing sporty....
I have to admit I never did it, but I did have two sons that were stopped in one car a blak firebird like KITT, and the other in a Dodge daytona fast backstyle, the state trooper I know progiled them as they drive that route all the time now in Civic's and Corrolla and have never had a problem.

My older dd was stopped in the daytona too, and the officer walked up and saw it was her and the whole story was different. It looked like a sticker was missing was the excuse,

A 16 year old is not ready to be handed the keys...
My opinion based on 20 years in law enforcement and two many tragidies. I could tell you each one and how I still see it on the parents faces.
The underage driver that rammed my crusier took away my carrier she was only months after her 17 birthday and at a party doing whippets and a candy bowl of parental med. chest pills, along with booze.
she also was the neice of a police officer.

There are a ton of nuts on the road and we meet them everyday. How do we think our babes can react to these idiots without lots of on road supervised driving experiance. Taking the extra year to train your child while in the car is well worth you time and their patience and understanding.

There are buses and parents to get to school. Two fatalities were on the way to school, I read another one this past week after snow the night before. Even more after school and on weekend nights with friends in the car.

As a parent that has lost a child, not to a car accident, but an accidental death, there is nothing worse. There is nothing worse then losing a child.
I guess that is another reason I take teen driving so very serious.
Di
 
We just went through this with our daughter. We have State Farm and they offer several premium reductions for teens which are quite substantial: "Steer Clear Safe Driver" which is a program from State Farm with a DVD for the teen to watch and a book to keep a log of her driving experiences (prior to getting her license). Also, a good student discount which required her to show her report card. (I think you have to be a least a B student) and the the premium reduction is given if your teen takes drivers education in school. Those three reductions added up to over $300. I researched the other insurance companies too, but found that having these discounts as well as the multi car discount and homeowners with State Farm couldn't be beat. Just call around and see where you get the best quote.
 
I've also used Allstate Insurance's teen program. They have great premiums as well as a lot of resources to keep teen drivers safe.
 
The liability comes when a child is in a car in your name and you own a home and something drastic happens. IT could devastate you. Especially if you child is issued sitations and in a reportable accident, or lent the car to someone and your insurance drops you, increases your rate higher then what the kid would ever have in the first place, or the damage they incure is more then the policy and they go after you.

Regardless of whether or not they have their own separate insurance policy. if your child under 18 is involved in an accident, you , as the parent, can be held personally liable for their damages. Any good lawyer will simply add you to a lawsuit for negligent supervision of a minor (ie you were negligent in allowing the negligent driver to drive)
 
Regardless of whether or not they have their own separate insurance policy. if your child under 18 is involved in an accident, you , as the parent, can be held personally liable for their damages. Any good lawyer will simply add you to a lawsuit for negligent supervision of a minor (ie you were negligent in allowing the negligent driver to drive)

I was just going to say this. It is exactly the same way in our state, you can't avoid liablity for an underage child you have custody of by putting it in their name. That is where an umbrella policy can help protect your assets.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom