Captain's Grille or Big River Grille

[MishyMouse]

I am having trouble deciding between the two. Any advice?

 

[OKW Lover]

What do you like? Are you interested in a particular type of food? Is a variety of beer important to your dining? How many in your party and any food "issues"? Let us know and we might be able to give you some suggestions that are appropriate for you.

 

[loperella]

I'm curious about these two also...

No seafood/fish eaters at all in our family. More of chix, steak and veggies. Staying at the BC, so would like to eat in this area. Anyone have input, suggests, or advice?

Thanx!

OR

Is Yachtsman the way to go?

 

[Cheloconnell]

We have eaten at both of these.

I definitely recommend Captain's Grill. I have nothing nice to say above Big River Grill. The food was terrible.

I would go back to Captain's Grill. We do not like seafood and had the prime rib. It was very good.

 

[Cheloconnell]

Also to add.... My husband and I ate at Yahtsman as well this past December. We have had better steaks in other parts of Disney - Le Cellier and California Grill. I think it is overrated and overpriced. We probably will not go back.

 

[MJAJmom]

We went to Captain's Grill for lunch in early June. The place was not very busy on Sunday. The service was great and the food delicious. I had crab cakes for appetizer and the lobster roll for lunch, chocolate cake for dessert. All was well prepared and yummy. Check their menu for other options that are non-seafood.

 

[madalex]

I am a big fan of both restaurants. I do Big River for lunch at least once on every trip to WDW and Captain's Grille is definitely in the rotation for dinner. As a PP said, it just depends upon what looks good to you vis a vis the menus and, in the case of Big River, whether a variety of beers is important to you.

 

[twotoohappy]

I'm not a big fan of Big River Grill.
Ate there twice, both meals were poor.

We really like Garden Grove at the Swan.
The dessert chef has won all sort of awards.
http://allears.net/menu/menu_gul.htm