Cap'n Jacks or Whispering Canyon

[ktink]

I booked Cap'n Jacks a little while ago due to the fact that we would be staying at POFQ and thought we'd enjoy the boat to DTD. Well we've gone w/ ASMu instead. Is Cap'n Jacks worth keeping the ADR? We cancelled Whispering Canyon to do CJs but now I'm wondering since we won't be staying at FQ and we normally don't frequent DTD would you keep CJs or go back to WC?

Our ADR's are
Crystal Palace for dinner
O'hana for dinner
Sci- Fi dinner
Chef Mickey's breakfast
Coral Reef
LeCellier

Or is there somewhere that you would choose over the both of them? TIA

 

[Tess'smom]

WOW! We are now staying at ASMu instead of our first choice and I was going to ask the exact same question. How funny!

 

[ktink]

WOW! We are now staying at ASMu instead of our first choice and I was going to ask the exact same question. How funny!

That's too funny! Maybe someone will point us in the right direction.

When will you be at ASMu?

 

[Tess'smom]

We will be at ASMu from September 21 through September 30th. When will you be there?

 

[Kae]

WCC hands down.

Kae

 

[ktink]

WCC hands down.

Kae

Thanks.

Tess's mom, we'll be there 9/2 - 9/9

 

[lynninpa]

Just our humble opinions...we ate at both CJ and WCC during our last trip.

Cap'n Jacks: food service atmosphere
WCC: food service atmosphere

 

[PoohsFan1]

I second WCC over CJ no question. On our last trip we went to CJ on a whim because it was raining and that was close by. It, to me and my DH, seemed like there was no Disney Magic. The food was so so, both my DD's asked for buttered noodles, instead they got noodles with olive oil plus we hardly saw our waitress...and it wasn't busy. The WCC, on the other hand, is awesome. We went there for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. We are going back this June. The food is very yummy, we rolled out of the restaurant because we ate too much.

 

[ktink]

Thank you all so much. I called and cancelled CJs and went with WC.

 

[lynninpa]

Thank you all so much. I called and cancelled CJs and went with WC.

Have a great time! Hope you get Prairie Girl as your server at WCC!

 

[WDW1st-timers]

I second WCC over CJ no question. On our last trip we went to CJ on a whim because it was raining and that was close by. It, to me and my DH, seemed like there was no Disney Magic. The food was so so, both my DD's asked for buttered noodles, instead they got noodles with olive oil plus we hardly saw our waitress...and it wasn't busy. The WCC, on the other hand, is awesome. We went there for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. We are going back this June. The food is very yummy, we rolled out of the restaurant because we ate too much.

Now I'm double guessing myself on Capt n' Jacks. Hmmmmm

 

[MNWDWMANIAC]

WCC all the way...... but it looks like you already figured that out

 

[eeyoreiscool]

I would go to WCC instead of Cap'n Jacks. We weren't that impressed with Cap'n Jacks when we went last time.

 

[hthrbells]

Capt Jacks was by far our worst meael in Disney!!!! I have never been to WC, anything has to be better CJ's. I might go as far to say it was our worst meal ever!! Try a search I know a bunch of us slamed it about a month ago. we were there in Dec. Have fun on your trip!!!!

 

[maraki527]

Change quickly to WCC ....Captain Jacks is awful