Can't Sell House Because of Neighbor

Based on my prior home sales 3 weeks is no time. I guess I have never sold in a hot market because I always expect it to take 4-6 months to get an offer.
Yes, it sounds like you've never sold in a market like this one. My sister's similar house sold in 3 days, and that's typical here.
 
Yes, it sounds like you've never sold in a market like this one. My sister's similar house sold in 3 days, and that's typical here.

It sounds like we live in the same housing market! We have decided to downsize to a townhouse in our area. Based on what has been selling around us, our 5-bedroom home has nearly quadrupled in value since we bought it 21 years ago. Because of the location, proximity to freeways and many large employers, and the excellent school district, we are anticipating a fairly quick sale at a decent price. Your post just got me thinking about any obstacles we haven't yet considered. Luckily, there's no problem with the neighbors!

I think the right buyer will eventually come along for you. You can also have your agent carefully phrase answers to questions about the neighbor. Does his just have weird-looking stuff but mostly keep to himself? That's something the agent can pass on to other agents. Also, perhaps you or your agent can dig a bit deeper into the laws and try to contact your city council person. The council people in my area tend to be fairly responsive about local issues. Good luck to you on your sale!
 
I live with my long-term boyfriend now. If needed, I'd never be able to afford my own place in this town without a big profit from this house sale to use as a down payment. House flippers would be all over me like a rash if I were willing to sell this house for much less than it's worth. But I'm not willing to do that, as in this real estate market, that would be a huge loss for me.

Real estate prices are going to continue to sharply climb, unabated as they have in this area for the past 30 years. For me to walk away from this property now without making a major profit would be foolish imo. If I can't sell it now, I will rent it to keep it paid for, and then sell it in 3-5 years when its value is just too high for buyers to pass up, regardless of an unpleasant (but aging) neighbor next door.

I'm not sure about your area but in ours houses that were previous rental properties do not seem to retain the same market value as other homes on the market. Just something to think about, hopefully not an issue for you.
 
Renting is good if you find good tenants. I have been fortunate to rent to many great couples, but my fiancé's rental property has been nothing but a headache. You can't count on the market going up each year, so you are taking a risk by waiting. My advise is to come down on the price a bit. Three weeks is not a long time to go without selling your house. Another option is doing a rent to own. I did this with one of my rental properties. It gives someone the opportunity to buy a home in a great neighborhood who might not otherwise get the chance. It's something to consider if you cannot sell the house.
 
Real estate prices are going to continue to sharply climb, unabated as they have in this area for the past 30 years. For me to walk away from this property now without making a major profit would be foolish imo. If I can't sell it now, I will rent it to keep it paid for, and then sell it in 3-5 years when its value is just too high for buyers to pass up, regardless of an unpleasant (but aging) neighbor next door.

i hope that's the case for you price wise but be prepared if it's not.

the area i owned in for close to 20 years was similar for decades longer. i sold my last home there for over triple my original purchase price w/in 7 years of purchase. that same home sold 5 years later for half of what i sold it for and now 13 years after i sold it (and the surrounding homes) despite a very strong real estate market in a highly desirable area are still not selling for what i sold at. as someone said earlier in this thread-a house is only worth someone will pay for it.

that said-if you are going to rent and hold off selling, as someone else mention-homes that have been rentals often sell for less down the line than owner occupied so you might want to research the impact that will have on your future profits. also-research capital gains tax b/c if you convert the home into a rental i think you risk losing the tax exemption which depending on your tax bracket can add up to many 10's of thousands of dollars.


p.s. i feel for you-my mom's home had to be priced accordingly b/c of a neighbor whose yard was less than appealing. her realtor though was up front with her and had her run the numbers on holding on to the property in the hopes something would change (never did-not a priority for the city/county) vs. selling and moving on.
 
i hope that's the case for you price wise but be prepared if it's not.

the area i owned in for close to 20 years was similar for decades longer. i sold my last home there for over triple my original purchase price w/in 7 years of purchase. that same home sold 5 years later for half of what i sold it for and now 13 years after i sold it (and the surrounding homes) despite a very strong real estate market in a highly desirable area are still not selling for what i sold at
What city was that in? Why did the home lose its value?
 
I'm not sure about your area but in ours houses that were previous rental properties do not seem to retain the same market value as other homes on the market. Just something to think about, hopefully not an issue for you.
Why is that? Is it because of poor maintenance, or because people are biased against former rental properties?
 
Renting is not easy, and it won't necessarily make you money in the long run. I wouldn't take a big loss on the home, but if it's worth that much more than when you bought it, and if the market is that hot in your area... it will sell, just maybe in 3 months instead of 3 weeks, or for a few thousand less than comparable homes. I'd seriously consider waiting for the right buyer willing to overlook the neighbor over renting for years, then trying to sell again, with the eyesore still an issue...
Our area doesn't sound as "high end" as where you live, but it's definitely a seller's market right now. Not enough homes on the market, but those that are, sell quick and for top dollar). We've been looking for two years for the right house in the right area on the right property (luckily, we're in no rush for our retirement home). Every time we've seen a home that looks right, they were pending within about 48 hours on the market. Some of them were off the market before we even had an opportunity to visit or see the home. Another one popped up on the website I use to search on Monday evening, I drove by it Tuesday morning on my way to work, and there was another vehicle in front of me doing the same thing (slowed and pulled to the side so I could pass and they could get a look at the home, sigh). Luckily, I wasn't interested after seeing the property up close because it's pending today.
The market is just crazy right now. I've accepted that we may have a long wait, or be forced to bid high and jump quick when the right property shows up, or accept a blemish or two in the new property (like a less-than-stellar neighbor). We've been at this so long, that our friends/family/coworkers/mechanic are letting us know about houses the know of which will be selling soon, (we've already walked two properties before the home was for sale) maybe we'll find our future home that way...
I really think that if you drop your price just a bit to make it more appealing than comparable homes without a neighbor problem, it will sell... you've just got to wait for the right buyer. I'd be shocked if it took more than a month or two in a hot market at the right price.
 
Renting is not easy, and it won't necessarily make you money in the long run. I wouldn't take a big loss on the home, but if it's worth that much more than when you bought it, and if the market is that hot in your area... it will sell, just maybe in 3 months instead of 3 weeks, or for a few thousand less than comparable homes. I'd seriously consider waiting for the right buyer willing to overlook the neighbor over renting for years, then trying to sell again, with the eyesore still an issue...
Our area doesn't sound as "high end" as where you live, but it's definitely a seller's market right now. Not enough homes on the market, but those that are, sell quick and for top dollar). We've been looking for two years for the right house in the right area on the right property (luckily, we're in no rush for our retirement home). Every time we've seen a home that looks right, they were pending within about 48 hours on the market. Some of them were off the market before we even had an opportunity to visit or see the home. Another one popped up on the website I use to search on Monday evening, I drove by it Tuesday morning on my way to work, and there was another vehicle in front of me doing the same thing (slowed and pulled to the side so I could pass and they could get a look at the home, sigh). Luckily, I wasn't interested after seeing the property up close because it's pending today.
The market is just crazy right now. I've accepted that we may have a long wait, or be forced to bid high and jump quick when the right property shows up, or accept a blemish or two in the new property (like a less-than-stellar neighbor). We've been at this so long, that our friends/family/coworkers/mechanic are letting us know about houses the know of which will be selling soon, (we've already walked two properties before the home was for sale) maybe we'll find our future home that way...
I really think that if you drop your price just a bit to make it more appealing than comparable homes without a neighbor problem, it will sell... you've just got to wait for the right buyer. I'd be shocked if it took more than a month or two in a hot market at the right price.
We are at the right price, though. We did a careful market analysis taking the neighborhood into account, and potential buyers have commented on the good price. There are no comparably priced homes in this part of town right now- we are by far the lowest price and inventory is very low overall. I'd be willing to cut $5,000 off the price, but I'm not willing to cut $20,000 - $30,000 off, which is what it would take to sell it to an investor/house flipper who wouldn't care too much about the neighbor.

I will take your advice to heart about being patient. I've already planned to wait until mid-June before switching it over to a rental property. It's just a frustrating process. Thanks for the perspective.
 
Last edited:
We are at the right price, though. We did a careful market analysis taking the neighborhood into account, and potential buyers have commented on the good price. There are no comparably priced homes in this part of town right now- we are by far the lowest price and inventory is very low overall. I'd be willing to cut $5,000 off the price, but I'm not willing to cut $20,000 - $30,000 off, which is what it would take to sell it to an investor/house flipper who wouldn't care too much about the neighbor.

I will take your advice to heart about being patient. I've already planned to wait until mid-June before switching it over to a rental property. It's just a frustrating process. Thanks for the perspective.

Not trying to be argumentative, but you are not at the right price if the house is not selling. It may be a good price and the lowest price based on current inventory, but it is not a price that people are willing to pay for the house and the neighbor issue.

I agree with others about renting. Not saying it is bad, but it can have its challenges. If you rent it for a period of time, you will probably have to do some additional maintenance before being able to sell it for top dollar again. I watched this play out in my previous neighborhood. Also, housing markets are "hot" until they are not. After the last housing market crash, I am not sure I would ever say with certainty that housing prices are only going to continue to go up.
 
Last edited:
Do you carry a mortgage on the property? If so, that can have some preclusions when it comes to renting. There are differences in a mortgage note for a rental property and one that's being used as your primary residence.

Otherwise, I would agree with PP that three weeks doesn't seem like much time. It sounds like you had high expectations of it going fast based on others' experiences, but its not always the case. Where I live, its the very start of spring so houses are popping up everywhere. But there's also more buyers looking now too, so there's a lot more activity on both ends of the spectrum. Eventually, a buyer will come along that will overlook the neighbor if the house and price is right for them. I have friends who gave up having a backyard, simply because they fell in love with the new house and were sick of living in their current house. I know I may not give up on a house I loved if everything else was right, just because of what you described.
 
Not trying to be argumentative, but you are not at the right price if the house is not selling. It may be a good price and the lowest price based on current inventory, but it is not a price that people are willing to pay for the house and the neighbor issue.

I agree with others about renting. Not saying it is bad, but it can have its challenges. If you rent it for a period of time, you will probably have to do some additional maintenance before being able to sell it for top dollar again. I watch this play out in my previous neighborhood. Also, housing markets are "hot" until they are not. After the last housing market crash, I am not sure I would ever say with certainty that housing prices are only going to continue to go up.

Yup. It's the right price...if you didn't have that neighbor issue. But since you have the neighbor issue and that's what all the comments are about, it would seem that if you dropped the price, someone might be able to overlook the neighbor issue
 
Yes, the neighbor has lived there as long as I have. I am unhappy with my agent for not realizing the effect the neighbor would have. I knew there would be some effect, but not this much. As a professional she should have known better imo. She was quite glib, sure that the house would sell, and promptly. If I have to rent now and sell later, I won't use her again, which is a shame as she is basically a good agent. She's the one who helped me buy this house 9 years ago. She also helped sell and buy my mother's last two homes.

I did the standard improvements anyone would do when preparing a house for sale: making small repairs, new interior paint, new carpet, replacing a broken fence, deep cleaning, etc. I didn't put new cabinets in or any real "remodeling" like that. But even the basic repairs/improvements I did cost about $10,000.

This is a neighborhood that is gradually gentrifying due to sharply rising costs of living in the area.
It is very possible your agent is as surprised as you are about what a huge objection the neighbour is. It seems you were both assuming the strength of the market would have its desired effect but you both have over-estimated the demand. @morgan98 correctly points out the house is NOT priced right if it’s not selling. Granted you have not had it on the market long but if 50 (your number) buyers have been able to find better options at your price-point, your asking price is too high.

What city was that in? Why did the home lose its value?
I’m assuming by this question you don’t have much experience in real estate. Markets change based on many economic factors, practically all of which are beyond your control. It is naive to think prices only go one direction and homes are always appreciating assets. No one has any way of knowing what will happen in the future and markets that see exponential increases over short periods like the one you are apparently in are the most volatile of all.

Sell it or don’t sell it - even a 50% or 75% gain over your original purchase price is a huge profit. Real estate, like any other type of investment, is a crap-shoot and many of us here could tell stories of both wins and loses. There’s no guarantee that profit margin will be there another two years from now or that renting will work out the way you want it to. Either way, I wish you well. :flower3:
 
Seems like you have a few choices, anything you do is going to cost money one way or another.
1) Hire an attorney with real estate knowledge and push the City to clean up the mess they have allowed, if possible. There are other agencies out there that protect your property and others. If he's got old vehicles that might be leaking fluids that's another way to fight the owner. Clear water agencies carry a lot of power.
2) Cut the price to move it, if values have shot up as much as you say you're still looking at a good profit, reduce your gain a bit so you can move on.
3) You don't seem happy with the Real Estate agent, fire them and hire another. Market analysis sounds great, but it's a guessing game and a dime a dozen. Your agent knew you were dealing with a problem, how did they address that problem? You need a new agent that is as assertive as you are to move this. This will set you back a bit but might be the least expensive overall.
 
Before you decide to rent, check with the local regulations, your mortgage company (or loan/lien holder), and your insurance company. In my town there are many homes that are rentals, or have been converted to rental apartments (university town). it's now illegal to break up your home into rental apartments, and if you want to rent an entire home there are regulations (can only rent to one single person or a couple, limitations on them then renting out other bedrooms, etc).This was done to protect property values in our area, and these are the kinds of things that you should be aware of before just saying "I'll rent it out." Your mortgage company may have restrictions on your being able to rent your house, and you'll more than likely have to change your homeowners insurance coverage, too, as it will no longer be a single-family-owner-occupied dwelling.

Mentioned upthread, when people go to purchase a home that they learn has been a rental, they often shy away or expect a reduced price. I think it's because everyone assumes that the house hasn't been as well-cared for as a rental as it is for owner-occupied. I think the thought process goes along the lines of "the renters don't care as much about the house so they don't take as good care of it as if they owned it," "the owner isn't living here so they aren't as invested in quality repairs/upgrades," and "this house was rented because they owner couldn't sell it so maybe there is something wrong that's hidden and expensive to repair." Regardless of the thought process, most buyers looking at a rental property usually make a fairly low-ball offer because for some reason (like those above), rental properties are considered "less than" and should accordingly cost less.

Good luck. It's hard to sell a property if you have a nasty neighbor. I'd approach the town/city, find out what the ordinances are (even for "classic" vehicles), and make a lot of noise if the zoning regs are in my favor!
 
And here is the benefit of a (moderate, not over the top, not too zealous) HOA, which so many people dislike.

Sorry you are dealing with that.
LOL. Or the disadvantage of a HOA, because usually THAT kind of house belongs to an HOA board member who doesn't like the flowers you planted in your yard, but doesn't think the Sherman Tank in his yard is an issue.
 
Where are you located OP? I agree that 3 weeks isn’t a long time to be on the market. And if you’re in an area with lots of families, many will start looking as the school year closes, so they are moving between school years. The things you have done to your house sound like normal upkeep, not so much improvements & upgrades, so you might need to temper your expectations for return on your dollar.

As for renting for a few years so you get a higher sale price. Consider that you may not get perfect tenants. No matter how well you try to vet them. You may not want to drop your price say, 10%, to sell now. But if you end up with damage to your home because of bad tenants, it may cost you, say, 20% to repair & get it ready to sell later. Made up numbers of course, but my point is it may end up costing you even more after you rent. And if that neighbor is still there in a few years, that may be even more discouraging to buyers. They won’t know if he is an owner or just another tenant. They could see it as an area of absent landlords who don’t keep up their properties & avaoid it even more.
 
OP, I feel your pain. My house’s comps are around 525, but I’ve dropped the price to 475 because nobody’s biting. I’ve had a dozen showings and two open houses, but no offers. The common issue we hear from the feedback are the two houses at the start of our dead-end street. One is a rental with 4 or 5 cars always parked in the driveway and the house looks poorly maintained. The next is a house with an oversized detached garage and usually 1-2 bobcats or skidsteers sitting around.

Side note, I paid 495 for the property 15 years ago. Agent now says the house would probably sell at 450.
 
LOL. Or the disadvantage of a HOA, because usually THAT kind of house belongs to an HOA board member who doesn't like the flowers you planted in your yard, but doesn't think the Sherman Tank in his yard is an issue.

But a board member with that kind of house is one of five board members where majority rules, and a fraction of the quorum needed to pass or deny proposals. Regardless of how someone feels about an HOA, one of their benefits is that there is some recourse when you have neighbors like the OP. And people who choose to live in an HOA are usually interested in maintaining their properties to begin with. But I digress, since its a moot point for OP. Unless OP can find a way to incorporate and start one to get this guy to clean up! LOL!
 

//

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom