Candlelight Processional or Osborne Lights...if you HAD to choose!?

[epcotty]

Osborne lights definitely, don't like CP much really

 

[Lumiere Lover]

O lights since it is the last year. I am so fortunate to say I will be doing both along with MVMCP this year.

 

[5DisneyNuts]

That's a tough one. I love the CP but my family not as much. No way am I going to wait in the standby line with the possibility of not getting in.
If it is possible to get a hopper, I would see OL at 6:30pm (ish) when they open, then hop to EPCOT, stand behind the rope to see CP (I usually have a fine view), and then grab a spot for Holiday Illuminations at 9:30pm. While I love CP and really love OL (and will miss them), my favorite hands down is Holiday Illuminations and 'Let There Be Peace on Earth'. I have never seen anything like that.

 

[Georgi Zhukov]

Not sure why you would HAVE to choose, to be honest. It's akin to asking TSM or Soarin' if you HAD to choose? Gun to my head, though, I'd choose CP but that experience is much more dependent on your religion and/or how religious you are. I personally loved hearing choruses sing beautiful Christmas music in between Gospel readings (by a celebrity usually, which is cool as well) about the birth of Jesus. I found it very moving and it really got me pumped up for the Christmas season.